Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•4w

The MG Windsor EV’s ride is indeed on the firmer side, and that’s something we’ve pointed out in our review as well. On broken roads and sharp bumps, it doesn’t feel very plush, but at higher speeds, it settles down and is quite stable. The air-conditioning isn’t the strongest in the class, yet in normal use, it does the job and is not a major weakness.Given the price, space and long list of features the Windsor offers, there’s very little that matches it for sheer value, so these compromises are something most buyers can live with.However, if you don’t really need that much space and mostly drive yourself, the Maruti Suzuki e Vitara is worth considering. It has a more comfortable ride, better overall refinement and an efficient air-con system, which will matter on long highway runs and in hot weather.

MG Windsor

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•4w

With your kind of usage of 30,000-40,000 km a year, mostly city driving, long-term ownership and an 8 kW solar setup, going electric makes a lot of sense. Running costs will be significantly lower, especially since you can charge at home using surplus solar, and the smooth, silent nature of an EV suits city driving perfectly.The Tata Nexon EV Long Range is still one of the most well-rounded options here. It offers a good balance of range, practicality and ease of use, and can handle your occasional 300-500 km trips with one planned charging stop. It is also a proven product with a wide user base.However, since you have concerns about Tata’s service, it is worth considering alternatives. The MG Windsor EV with the larger battery pack is a strong option. It offers more space, a more premium feel and a bigger battery, which helps with range and reduces charging stops. The Maruti Suzuki e-Vitara is another promising option, especially from a long-term ownership perspective, thanks to Maruti’s strong service network and reliability.Diesel is still a valid fallback. If you prefer complete flexibility and do not want to depend on charging infrastructure at all, options like the Hyundai Creta diesel automatic or Kia Sonet diesel automatic make sense, offering strong mileage and effortless highway performance.So, the decision comes down to priorities. Given your high running and solar setup, an EV is clearly the smarter long-term choice. Among EVs, the Nexon EV is the proven option, the Windsor EV offers more space and range, and the e Vitara is the safest bet for long-term ownership. Diesel should only be considered if you want maximum convenience without planning charging stops.

Tata Nexon EV

MG Windsor

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Hyundai Creta

Kia Sonet

Autocar India

•5w

The Maruti Suzuki E Vitara is a sensible EV for your usage and budget.For 70-80 km a day and around 25,000 km a year, going electric will significantly cut your running costs, and charging from solar makes it even more economical. The e‑Vitara is positioned as a reasonably priced compact electric car, so it should sit comfortably within your 17 lakh budget and still offer the ease of an automatic, quiet drive and low maintenance.However, there are some important comfort limitations to be aware of, particularly for someone who is 6'3". The cabin is not very spacious, and you’re likely to need the driver’s seat pushed all the way back, which leaves very little legroom for a passenger sitting directly behind you. The floor is also quite high because of the battery pack, so your knees sit more upright than normal, which can reduce long‑distance comfort for tall occupants.If rear‑seat space matters or you often travel with family, it’s worth looking at alternatives like the MG Windsor EV, which offers a noticeably roomier cabin and more comfortable back seat. But if you mostly drive alone or with one front passenger, the e‑Vitara will do the job quite well.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

MG Windsor

Autocar India

•4w

For your use case, the Maruti Suzuki eVitara, despite a range of 400+ km, drops out first. Its boot is only around 300 litres, which is tight even for two large suitcases, let alone 200kg of luggage plus four people. It’s fine as a family crossover, but not for heavy luggage and long‑haul highway use.Both the Mahindra XEV 9S and Tata Harrier EV are large, comfortable SUVs that will easily take four adults, and with their rear seats folded or adjusted, they can swallow serious luggage. The XEV 9S, being a three‑row SUV, gives you a huge, flat boot with the third row down, so it’s the most practical of the three for your 200kg luggage requirement.On range, the XEV 9S with the 79kWh battery delivers around 478km in Autocar’s real‑world test, versus about 401km for the Harrier EV AWD with a 75kWh pack. For your 100km daily highway run, both are adequate, but the Mahindra gives you a much bigger buffer even when loaded.In terms of driving feel, the Harrier EV feels more planted and tied down at high speed; the XEV 9S is softer and moves around a bit more on uneven highways, though it’s still safe and stable. On safety and maintenance, both are modern, 5‑star‑oriented SUVs with robust equipment; long‑term, Tata’s and Mahindra’s EV ecosystems are still maturing, so factor in dealer experience in your city and expect a few niggles too. Given your load, highway usage and need for range buffer, the Mahindra XEV 9S 79kWh is the most suitable overall.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Mahindra XEV 9S

Tata Harrier EV

Autocar India

•6w

The Maruti Suzuki e Vitara with its 61 kWh battery pack has an officially claimed range of 543 km on a full charge, which is comfortably the highest among the three you’ve mentioned. Even if you factor in real‑world conditions, you can expect a useful touring range that’s still well ahead of the Punch EV and Windsor.​For rear seat space, the MG Windsor EV is the one to go for; it has the most generous back‑seat legroom and overall cabin width, making it the most comfortable for passengers in the back. If you choose the Windsor Pro variant with the 52.9 kWh battery, you get a certified range of 449 km.In real‑world use, that typically translates to roughly 340-370 km depending on your driving style and conditions, which is more than sufficient for daily local and city driving. The Windsor isn’t quite as refined or efficient as the e-Vitara, but it strikes the best balance between range and rear seat space if those are your two main priorities.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

MG Windsor

Autocar India

•7w

Thanks for being a loyal subscriber. As you've rightly mentioned, the Maruti Suzuki e Vitara gets two versions 144hp/189Nm motor with a 49kWh battery, and the other is 174hp/189Nm motor, 61kWh battery. The common factor between the two versions is the 189Nm motor torque, which makes it zippy. Of course, being more powerful, the larger battery version is likely to hit higher (three-digit) speeds more quickly, but within town (up to speeds of 60-70kph), the difference between their acceleration is likely to be negligible. So opt for the 61kWh version only if you need more range, else as a city commuter, the 49kWh version's performance should be more than sufficient.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•8w

The Maruti Suzuki E Vitara is a sensible electric car, backed by Nexa's widespread sales and support network. It is also equipped with a large 61kWh battery, with which you can expect a highway range of approximately 370km on a full charge - city range will be better. The interiors feel premium, performance is smooth, and its light steering and tight turning radius make it very easy to manoeuvre. That said, the E Vitara's user experience is flawed, the floor is high, which results in a knees-up seating, and its suspension isn't as sorted as some rivals.We would suggest that you consider the entry-level variants of the Kia Carens Clavis EV or Hyundai Creta Electric, both of which cover the basics well. Yes, these have a smaller 42kWh battery, but their powertrain is very efficient, which will deliver impressive real-world range. Overall, both these are excellent options for similar money as the E Vitara.

Hyundai Creta Electric

Kia Carens Clavis EV

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•9w

Since you’ve had a long stint with your Maruti Suzuki Vitara Brezza, it’s understandable that you’re looking at the Maruti Suzuki e-Vitara as a replacement.You’ve mentioned 900km of city running, which we assume is per month. For that kind of usage, the 49kWh battery should be sufficient. In real-world city conditions, you can expect roughly 250-300km on a full charge, though we have yet to test the range ourselves. For pure urban use, the 49kWh battery is practical and cost-effective.The larger 61kWh battery would give you more range and flexibility. But given that you already have the Toyota Innova Hycross for highway trips. The smaller battery pack makes more financial sense unless you simply want the added buffer and peace of mind.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•9w

Given your usage of 1100-1400km per month, we do not recommend an electric car. Even if your usage is spread evenly over each day of the month, it will require frequent charging, which is not good for battery health.While you haven't stated a budget, given a basic-level Kia Seltos as your target, the Maruti Suzuki e Vitara would be on the expensive side. In fact, the Kia Seltos is probably the best option for you, as even the basic HTE variant will be good value for money.It's the largest, most spacious and most comfortable of the three SUVs, and even in the HTE variant, you get a decent amount of features. The 1.5-litre petrol engine is also reasonably efficient if driven carefully.

Kia Seltos

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•10w

Between the two, the MG Windsor Pro is more spacious, and its light coloured seats enhance the sense of space even further. Its boot is much larger, too. Furthermore, it is well-equipped and more affordable (than the Maruti e Vitara), hence it is a better value too.Even though the Maruti Suzuki e Vitara has a larger 61kWh battery, its kerb weight of 1.8 tonnes makes it much heavier than the Windsor Pro (1.56 tonnes) with the 52.9kWh battery. Hence, you can expect a real-world range of approximately 370-390km, similar to the MG.

MG Windsor

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara