Renault Duster Evolution 1.3 Turbo Petrol DCT

Autocar India

•1d

The Renault Duster certainly rides and handles better, and has a bigger boot too. However, its rear seat space is tight compared to a Tata Sierra, which is much more spacious in comparison. And besides a roomier cabin, the Sierra's seats (front and rear) are comfier, its cabin feels more inviting than the Duster's, and the turbo-petrol is a strong performer too.Overall, as a family car, the Sierra fits the brief better. Yes, it doesn't have a good reputation as far as reliability and after-sales service go, so we'd recommend you opt for the longest warranty coverage on the car.

Renault Duster

Tata Sierra

Autocar India

•4d

If you want the more rugged and driver focused SUV, pick the Renault Duster. It is likely to feel more engaging from behind the wheel, with a smoother dual clutch automatic and a tougher, more no nonsense character that should appeal if driving feel matters to you.The Tata Sierra, on the other hand, is the better choice if your priorities are comfort, premium cabin feel and family use. It feels more modern, more desirable and likely to offer a richer overall cabin experience, with a comfortable ride and strong road presence.The real difference comes down to character. The Duster feels like the more rugged, enthusiast friendly choice, while the Sierra is the more polished and premium family SUV.

Renault Duster

Tata Sierra

Autocar India

•4d

The Kia Seltos 1.5 turbo-petrol with the 7-speed dual-clutch automatic (DCT) is the one that fits your brief best. The DCT changes gears very quickly once you are moving, so city drives feel easy and highway trips feel strong and smooth. The Seltos also rides well for daily use, the seats are supportive, and the cabin looks and feels upmarket. For safety and build, it gives you a solid-feeling body, a long list of safety features, and on higher trims even driver assist tech; plus it received a 5-star Bharat NCAP crash test rating.A couple of things to note for your use: like most dual-clutch gearboxes, there can be a small pause at very low speeds, and if you spend hours in slow traffic every day it is best to drive gently. From your list, the Mahindra Thar Roxx 2.0 petrol automatic is the one to pick if you mainly want a tough, go-anywhere machine and love the stance, but for daily comfort and ease it is not as relaxed as the Seltos, and it has very poor fuel economy. The suspension isn't as absorbent and the controls aren't as light. The Duster and Sierra come much closer, the Renault imparting a tougher feel while still remaining comfortable, and the Sierra feeling large and more comfortable. However, overall, for mixed city-highway use and your priorities, the Seltos turbo DCT lines up best.

Kia Seltos

Mahindra Thar Roxx

Renault Duster

Tata Sierra

Autocar India

•3d

The Kia Seltos 1.5 turbo automatic (the DCT that changes gears on its own) fits you best. It lines up with what you value and what you felt in your test drives.As you mentioned, the Seltos' seat is the most comfortable; the 1.5 turbo is quick, feels strong and has that oomph that you're looking for. Also, being the newest car, its interior quality is a step up compared to the other options listed.Of course, being a taller car, its stability and handling prowess aren't as good as the Hyundai Verna 1.5 turbo DCT, which will give you a relatively sportier driving experience due to its low-set seating.We would advise you against the Mahindra BE 6, especially when you're currently residing in a rented flat with no assured socket at your parking, and even though Bengaluru has many public chargers, you can't solely rely on public charging. You could also check out the new Renault Duster 1.3 Turbo before finalising the Seltos.

Kia Seltos

Renault Duster

Autocar India

•5d

You should not read too much into Renault excluding clutch components from the Duster’s warranty, because clutch packs in DCTs are generally treated as wear and tear items by most manufacturers, including Kia. Even Kia’s warranty excludes clutch discs and facing components under normal wear and tear clauses. That does not mean the entire DCT gearbox is uncovered. Major transmission or mechatronic issues are still typically covered under standard warranty terms unless the failure is linked directly to clutch wear or misuse. Renault’s wording looks more worrying, mainly because they have explicitly listed exclusions in detail for the additional warranty package.So buy the one that suits your priorities better. The Kia Seltos feels more premium, more spacious and more feature-rich, while the Renault Duster has a more rugged character and is likely to feel more involving to drive. Although both use dual-clutch automatic transmissions, the Duster uses a wet clutch setup while the Seltos uses a dry clutch unit. In the real world, this usually means the Renault’s gearbox should feel smoother and cope better with heavy traffic and heat. On the other hand, the Kia’s DCT feels quicker and sportier during fast driving, but can feel slightly jerkier at low speeds.

Renault Duster

Kia Seltos

Autocar India

•1w

If you're looking to replace the Honda Elevate CVT with a Renault Duster, make sure you opt for the hybrid version. The Duster's 1.3-litre turbo-petrol-DCT combination isn't likely to deliver respectable fuel efficiency, especially in bumper-to-bumper traffic; hence, your fuel stops are likely to be as frequent, if not more so. A hybrid, on the other hand, will remain in EV mode while idling or at low speeds, which will significantly reduce fuel consumption. While Renault provides a puncture repair kit, a spare tyre will certainly come in hand in the event of a sidewall cut, which is a possibility on long drives and unfamiliar roads. Hence, you could purchase an extra tyre and place it in the boot, however that is likely to compromise luggage space.Alternatively, you could consider retaining your Honda Elevate. It is a very sensible, no-nonsense car. Also, keep in mind that because it isn't a popular model, resale value is likely to be on the lower side, hence you will have to add a fair bit from your pocket, to make the new purchase.

Renault Duster

Honda Elevate

Autocar India

•1w

In most modern strong-hybrid setups, the battery is packaged low in the floor or under the boot area, not under the rear seats. This means rear seat legroom and seating position remain largely unchanged. Even globally, the Duster sold as the Dacia Duster hybrid manages its battery packaging quite well, with minimal impact on cabin space. So, from a passenger comfort point of view, it should feel very similar to the ICE version.Where you may see a change is in the boot area. To accommodate the battery, the boot floor can be slightly raised, something we have already seen in cars like the Toyota Hyryder and Maruti Grand Vitara. This can reduce usable boot depth a bit, but manufacturers usually integrate it neatly, so the impact is not drastic.

Renault Duster

Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara

Autocar India

•1w

You are upgrading from a Grand i10 automatic and want something that is easy to drive, comfortable for family use and reliable for long-term ownership. The Creta ticks all those boxes. The IVT automatic is smooth and effortless in city driving, the ride is soft and comfortable which your family will appreciate, and Hyundai’s aftersales experience is something you are already familiar with. It also feels like a proper step up in space, comfort and overall refinement without being intimidating to drive.The Grand Vitara automatic is a good alternative if fuel efficiency is a priority. It is smooth and easy to drive, but the engine feels less responsive and overall it does not feel as premium or as refined as the Creta. The Ertiga and Carens Clavis are practical, but they are more MPV-focused and since you do not specifically need a third row, they are not the best fit.Cars like the Sierra, Duster and XUV 7XO are interesting, but your hesitation is valid. They are either new or evolving products, and compared to the Creta, they do not offer the same level of proven reliability and ownership peace of mind yet.

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Renault Duster

Tata Sierra

Autocar India

•1w

You are looking for higher ground clearance, smoother automatic, cooled seats and a more premium experience, and the Seltos delivers on all of these. The IVT gearbox is very smooth in city traffic, a clear step up from your current AMT, and the naturally aspirated petrol is refined and easy to drive for your low, city-heavy running. Being a newer generation car, it also feels more premium inside and out, offers better space and has a well-sorted ride that suits both city and occasional highway use.The Duster is a strong alternative if you prioritise driving feel. The turbo petrol with DCT is more engaging, but in daily city use it will not feel as smooth as the Seltos IVT, and fuel efficiency will also be lower. The Grand Vitara is efficient and easy to drive, but it does not feel as premium and the engine and gearbox combination is not as strong or responsive as the Seltos. It is also not as spacious. The Creta shares a similar powertrain, but being the older car, it does not feel as fresh or as premium inside, is slightly less spacious and costs similar money, which makes the Seltos the better pick.

Kia Seltos

Renault Duster

Hyundai Creta

Autocar India

•2w

Check out the the Skoda Kushaq 1.0 TSI Signature. It will feel closer to your old Punto than the Fronx does. The steering has good weight and the car turns in eagerly, so it is easy to place in tight bends and hairpins. The suspension takes rough patches well without tossing you around, and the car feels steady at highway speeds. The 115hp turbo petrol has strong pull once spinning, so quick overtakes on climbs are simple, and with the manual, you have full control of gears on steep sections. It also has a solid safety record, which matters on hill roads.A couple of things to note. At very low revs, you may need a downshift to get going cleanly on an uphill, so keep it in the right gear. Also, Skoda’s service reach is not as wide as Maruti’s, so check dealer support in your town.Other alternatives include the Renault Duster Techno Plus 1.3 Turbo, which feels tough, comfortable and characterful, but not as nimble, and as it's a brand new product which means its reliability is yet to be proven. You could also check out the Citroen Basalt X 1.2 Turbo AT, which is excellent value for money, but its dealer network is even smaller than Skoda's, so that needs to be borne in mind.

Skoda Kushaq

Renault Duster

Citroen Basalt

Maruti Suzuki Fronx