Tata Nexon Diesel Creative + S MT

autocar.india

•1w

Given your low annual running of 5,000km and the fact that the car will be idle for long periods, a naturally aspirated petrol engine paired with a torque converter automatic is the most sensible choice. The Maruti Suzuki Brezza fits this brief perfectly. It is a simple, reliable and low-maintenance package with a proven engine and gearbox combination that will serve you well over a long ownership period. The Sonet turbo petrol DCT is the more fun-to-drive option on the highway, but the DCT gearbox of this Kia car is not the ideal choice for predominantly city driving and long periods of idling. As for your current Nexon, if the car is running fine now, there is no immediate need to change it. However, given that the engine of this Tata car has already been opened and you are experiencing a perceived loss of power and mileage, it is understandable to want to move on. On the ethanol front, there is no official roadmap beyond E20 at this stage, and modern engines are engineered to handle E20 without issue. There is no need to wait for further clarity. The Brezza is the safer and more sensible long-term choice for your usage pattern.

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

Kia Sonet

Tata Nexon

autocar.india

•1w

With a monthly running of 1,500-2,000km and a 10+ year ownership horizon, diesel might sound like a good idea, but at your budget, there aren't many options. What you will get will only be base model cars with few creature comforts. In that respect, CNG is a better VFM option as you can get mid- to high-spec variants of cars. Plus, diesel requires the added maintenance of a DPF and the cost of AdBlue top-ups, as well as more maintenance costs over time. That said, there are also compromises of CNG ownership, such as lower power and torque, and the inconvenience of refuelling.The Maruti Brezza CNG ZXi would be the best choice, as it has an efficient yet powerful enough engine, a CNG tank located under the floor, and plenty of features within your budget. The Nexon CNG would be the next best bet, offering more power and similar underfloor CNG tanks, but it is not as efficient and is more expensive, spec-for-spec.

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

Tata Nexon

autocar.india

•1w

Out of the options you've listed, the Nexon 1.2 Turbo DCA and XUV 3XO Turbo AT deliver better value than the Brezza, as far as equipment and performance go. Out of these, the Mahindra XUV 3XO is a solid choice for its smoother, stronger engine and its seamless 6-speed torque converter (automatic). Cabin space is very good, and it drives like a more expensive car, giving you a confident experience be it in the city or out on the highway. Before going ahead, do keep in mind that the XUV's boot is a bit small, fuel efficiency might not be as good as the Brezza's, and Mahindra's service network isn't as widespread as Maruti's. However, on the whole, the XUV feels is a good option, and one that we'd recommend.

Mahindra XUV 3XO

Tata Nexon

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

autocar.india

•1w

With a very low monthly running of 200- 300 km, a petrol car is the clear choice, and your priority should be a smooth, reliable automatic car that will serve you well for 8-10 years. Between the Nissan Magnite Tekna Plus Turbo CVT and the Tata Nexon Creative AMT, the Magnite is the better fit for your needs. The Nissan Magnite price starts at 5.65 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi).The CVT gearbox is far smoother and more refined than the Nexon's AMT, especially in city driving. The Magnite also offers good value for money and a decent feature set.The Nexon is a solid car, but the AMT gearbox is not as smooth as a proper automatic, and over a long ownership period, that can become tiresome in daily use. If you are open to other options, the Maruti Suzuki Brezza automatic is worth considering. This Maruti Suzuki car uses a 6-speed torque converter automatic, which is smoother and more reliable than an AMT, and Maruti's service network and low maintenance costs make it an excellent long-term ownership proposition.Overall, the Nissan car is the best fit from your shortlist, but the Brezza automatic would be our top recommendation for long-term peace of mind and affordable ownership.

Nissan Magnite

Tata Nexon

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

autocar.india

•1w

Go for the Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi+ petrol automatic. With under 10,000 km a year, petrol is the right choice, and the Brezza is one of the most reliable and low-maintenance cars in the segment. This Maruti Suzuki car is also a genuinely comfortable 5-seater with a wide rear bench, good ride quality and a simple, proven naturally aspirated engine paired with a smooth 6-speed torque converter automatic. The ZXi+ variant is well equipped, so you are not compromising on features, and Maruti’s service network and ownership experience are among the best in the country.The Tata Nexon is also a strong option, but the Brezza’s naturally aspirated engine is better suited to long-term ownership and low-maintenance requirements. If you need the space and don't mind compromising on features, the Kia Seltos HTE (O) IVT is a good choice. It is actually well equipped for a lower-end trim and offers a roomier, more border cabin than the Brezza. Overall, the Brezza ZXi+ gives you a complete package without compromise, and that is the right approach for a first-time buyer looking for long-term ownership.

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

Tata Nexon

Kia Seltos