Tata Harrier Mileage

autocar.india

•1w

If you can charge at home, go for the Hyundai Creta Electric. Your 50km Mumbai city run suits an EV perfectly, and this one will do the coastal road crawl very smoothly and deal with stop-start traffic well, thanks to its nicely tuned one-pedal driving mode. Hyundai’s service consistency in Mumbai is better than Tata’s today, and the Creta’s size is easier to park than a Harrier. Running costs in the city drop sharply versus petrol or diesel, and your budget will comfortably get you the larger 51.4kWh battery, which, as per our testing, delivers a combined real-world range of 430km.The Kia Seltos is a fine pick only if you cannot charge at home or at the office. In that case, pick the 1.5 NA IVT combo for the most seamless drive in the city. Kia’s service is also generally hassle-free.One honest catch with the Creta Electric is that you need a reliable charging point at home or work, and the upfront cost is higher than that of a petrol Seltos. If you have a fixed parking spot with a plug, it is the easiest, cheapest way to do your daily Bandra East to Fort grind.

Hyundai Creta Electric

Kia Seltos

Tata Harrier

autocar.india

•4w

If you like the Tata Harrier Petrol automatic, go for it. It is a spacious car with impressive road presence and a lengthy list of features. Highway stability is very good too, and the turbo-petrol performs strongly, and the automatic is smooth in its operation. Do keep in mind that being a big, heavy car, fuel efficiency will be in single digits in the city, and in the low double digits on the highway.It will be a bit premature to predict the impact of a higher Ethanol blend on performance and fuel efficiency. So, unfortunately, we'll have to wait to test the higher blended fuels before we can share a conclusive report.

Tata Harrier

autocar.india

•9w

Between the two Tata cars that you've shortlisted, go for the Sierra. Considering you will be using the SUV in the city, it's relatively more compact and easier to drive, with lighter controls, yet doesn't give up too much in terms of space. It also has more features than the Harrier, including a three-screen setup on the dashboard in top trims. Both cars have 5-star crash test ratings from Bharat NCAP, since safety is a concern for you. The Sierra also has an edge on comfort, with the softer, more compliant suspension setup, while the Harrier feels firm, comparatively.However, being large and heavy SUVs, neither is particularly good on fuel economy, especially if you drive mostly in the city. Tata's new 1.5-litre petrol engine feels smooth and powerful in both SUVs, but in our real-world tests, returned poor figures in the Sierra. The diesel might be the better choice if fuel economy is a criterion, though beware of the additional maintenance required, such as DPF regeneration.With mostly metro-city use at 25-30 km a day and rare highway runs, a strong-hybrid like the Maruti Suzuki Victoris might make more sense. It uses far less fuel in stop-go traffic, it is very quiet and smooth at low speeds, and it is easier to park than bigger SUVs. Coming from a Honda City, you will like how calm and smooth it feels, and the ride is comfortable over broken roads. Moreover, it too has received a 5-star crash test rating from Bharat NCAP. The trade-off is space, which isn't as much as you'll find in the Harrier or Sierra, and performance, which compared to the turbo-petrol engine, isn't as strong. For your usage though, we would recommend the Victoris strong hybrid.

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

Tata Harrier

Tata Sierra

autocar.india

•14w

We haven’t yet tested the Tata Harrier petrol automatic for real-world fuel efficiency, though we plan to do so soon. The official lab-certified figures are also not available at this stage, and it’s worth noting that those tend to be optimistic compared to everyday conditions.Based on its specifications, a 1.5-litre turbocharged engine paired with the Harrier’s substantial size and weight, we expect fuel consumption to be on the higher side. You can reasonably anticipate single-digit mileage in urban conditions, with highway figures improving to the low double digits depending on driving style and traffic.In short, efficiency isn’t likely to be the Harrier petrol’s strongest suit; it’s more about smooth performance and size. If fuel economy is your top priority, you may want to wait for our full road test results or consider smaller and lighter alternatives.

Tata Harrier

autocar.india

•18w

If you have your heart set on the Tata Harrier, you should go for it. It has great road presence, you like the aesthetics of it, and it feels very tough, thanks to its Land Rover-sourced underpinnings. The new 1.5-litre turbo-petrol engine is a winner too, managing to be both powerful and smooth at the same time. If you're after the automatic variant, it's a very smooth gearbox too, if not a particularly sporty one. Tata's reliability has improved in recent years, but the cars aren't free from issues, particularly with the electronics.That said, Mahindra is not too far behind in this regard. It's luck of the draw, and we don't think it's worth putting off the purchase just for that if you otherwise have your eye on it. As for the mileage, it's unlikely to get anywhere near 12-18kpl (the Mahindra is even further off), as it is a heavy SUV with a turbocharged petrol engine, but driven carefully, you could get into the low double digits.

Tata Harrier

autocar.india

•20w

The Mahindra Scorpio N offers a larger, more powerful 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine, compared to the other two cars, and its rear-wheel drive layout will be a touch better to drive on hills, too. Additionally, being a body-on-frame SUV, it feels a touch tougher too, and more capable over bad roads. That said, since your usage is primarily in the city, the Scorpio N's ride will feel bumpier in the city. And purely for those reasons, we would recommend the two Tata SUVs.There's very little to differentiate between the Tata Safari and Harrier, with the former having a three-row seating configuration and the latter being a 5-seater. Both drive similarly, and the 1.5-turbo-petrol engine is surprisingly powerful, refined and smooth. So, between the Safari and Tata Harrier, pick the one that appeals to you more.

Tata Harrier

Mahindra Scorpio N

Tata Safari

autocar.india

•17w

All these SUVs are up to a high standard now and delivers a great all-round experience. While the Tata Harrier and Safari are capable in their own right, they sit in a higher segment, and thus, within your budget, you would only get a mid-range variant.Of the others, the new Kia Seltos is a good all-rounder that mixes quality, features, stability, mileage and comfort well. However, we would recommend checking out the just-launched new Renault Duster, which could prove to be the best value for money.The top-spec 1.3 Turbo Petrol DCT Iconic costs around Rs 22 lakh on road, and it has a strong features list too. While we are yet to review it, early impressions suggest it will have the same excellent ride and handling balance as its predecessor, while also delivering a tough and solid feel. And if you want the ultimate efficiency and can wait a while, the strong hybrid version is set to launch in Diwali this year.

Renault Duster

Tata Harrier

Tata Safari

Kia Seltos

autocar.india

•34w

The Mahindra XUV700 is a reliable and well-packaged SUV that is strong on road presence, has a good amount of equipment and a strong set of powertrains. Both, the petrol and diesel engines are strong, and while the diesel is more efficient, check if your annual mileage is above 15-20,000km. The Tata Harrier/Safari have a stronger road presence but are not as reliable or efficient as the Mahindra.

Tata Harrier

Tata Safari