Tata Sierra EV Empowered 63

autocar.india

•2w

For your 100 km daily commute, with comfort and stability as the absolute priorities, the Tata Sierra EV is the top recommendation. This Tata car is built on Tata's Gen 2 EV architecture, which is a dedicated electric platform with a flat floor and a long wheelbase. This gives it a very stable, planted feel on the road, and the suspension is tuned for comfort, with a soft, absorbent ride that deals with bad roads, speed bumps and undulations far better than a ladder-frame vehicle like the Crysta. The Sierra EV also has a spacious cabin with generous legroom, good under-thigh support and a wide, airy feel, making it a genuinely comfortable place to spend long hours, whether you are driving or being driven. Also, its 75 kWh battery pack gives it a strong range, so you don't have to worry about recharging even on long trips. The Mahindra XEV 9e and 9s are both strong products, but they are not quite as plush or as settled. The Harrier EV has a redesigned floor pan, but it still doesn't feel as spacious or airy inside as the Sierra. The Sierra also has a larger boot compared to the Harrier. Given that you are keeping the Crysta for airport runs and long-distance family trips, the Sierra EV is the best fit for your daily commute. It is the most comfortable, the most stable and the most fatigue-free option of the four.

Tata Sierra EV

Toyota Innova Crysta

Mahindra XEV 9e

Mahindra XEV 9S

autocar.india

•19w

What you felt in the Mahindra XEV 9e Pack Three is a fair observation. The XEV 9e does have a softer suspension tune, and for some rear seat passengers, that can translate into a floaty, slightly boat-like vertical movement over undulations, which can feel uncomfortable or even nauseating if you are sensitive to that kind of motion. As far as we know, there is no major suspension hardware difference between Pack One, Two and Three that fundamentally changes this character, so we would not expect the lower variants to feel significantly different in this regard.If rear seat ride quality and body control are a major priority, the Tata Harrier EV is the better option right now. It feels more tied down, composed and generally better controlled from the rear, without that excessive floatiness. If you still want to stay with Mahindra, the XEV 9e actually feels more balanced in this respect and does not have the same exaggerated bouncy character as the XEV 9S.That said, since you are clearly particular about ride quality and already like how Tata’s EVs are tuned, we would absolutely suggest waiting for the Tata Sierra EV as well, especially since its launch is right around the corner. It should sit in that sweet spot above the Nexon EV in size while potentially offering the kind of more settled suspension setup you seem to prefer.

Mahindra XEV 9e

Mahindra XEV 9S

Tata Sierra EV

Tata Nexon EV

Tata Harrier EV

autocar.india

•23h

At 6ft 1in, the Sierra EV is worth considering first because the cabin is genuinely spacious and the driving position should comfortably accommodate a taller driver. It also gives you the SUV stance and substantial cabin that you are looking for, while the large boot makes it better suited to your regular long trips.Your running also makes an EV a sensible choice. Around 180km a week is easily covered through home charging, while the longer 1,000km trips will require some planning around fast charging. The Sierra EV's ride is another advantage for your usage, particularly if those long journeys include uneven roads.The Kia Carens Clavis EV is the other car worth considering. It offers a very spacious cabin and greater seating flexibility, so it makes more sense if carrying family members regularly is important. For a primarily five-seat requirement, however, the Sierra's SUV packaging is likely to appeal more.

Tata Sierra EV

Kia Carens Clavis EV

autocar.india

•1w

Based on your requirements, the Maruti Suzuki e-Vitara would be our recommendation. It offers a comfortable cabin, especially up front, a relaxed driving experience and a good suite of comfort features.The Mahindra BE 6 has the edge on performance, while the Tata Sierra EV has more space, and both offer a longer real-world range, but they are also considerably more expensive and, for your requirements, not worth the extra outlay. The e-Vitara is a good all-rounder, with more than sufficient range, and also the comfort features you seek - ventilated front seats and a 360-degree camera.The Toyota Urban Cruiser Ebella is the same as the e-Vitara but more expensive, and again, it doesn't justify its premium. Overall, the e-Vitara strikes the best balance between comfort, features and ease of ownership for your needs.

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq

Toyota Urban Cruiser Ebella

Tata Sierra EV

autocar.india

•3w

With a monthly running of around 1,000 km, an EV can make sense, but only if you have a predictable usage pattern and access to home charging. The bigger question is whether it makes sense to exchange your Slavia, which is a relatively new and well-rounded car. The Slavia offers a great driving experience, good comfort and is a proven product. The XEV 9S is a very different proposition – it is a large, premium electric SUV with a very different ownership and usage profile.The BaaS (Battery as a Service) scheme on the XEV 9S is attractive because it reduces the upfront cost, but it also means you are paying a monthly subscription for the battery, which only makes sense if you are committed to long-term EV ownership and your usage pattern justifies it. The Sierra EV does not currently offer a BaaS scheme.Our advice would be to hold on to the Slavia for now. It is still a very capable car and you are unlikely to recover its value in a trade-in so soon after purchase. If you are keen on an EV, wait for a few more years until your Slavia has served its purpose and the EV market has matured further. If you are set on an EV today, the XEV 9S with BaaS is a good option.

Mahindra XEV 9S

Skoda Slavia

Tata Sierra EV