MG Astor

autocar.india

•2d

With 1,000km a month, your friend is doing about 12,000km a year, which is right on the threshold where a diesel can start to make sense, especially if he enjoys power and wants better fuel efficiency. The MG Astor CVT is not known for great fuel economy, and 7kmpl is on the lower side, but not entirely surprising for a petrol automatic in mixed conditions. The bigger concern is that the car is from the first batch and has already clocked 39,000km, so if he is not happy with the ownership experience, this is a reasonable time to move on.In the Rs 11-13 lakh on-road range in Chennai, the Hyundai Venue diesel is a strong option. This Hyundai car offers good performance, solid build quality, a good amount of space and an enjoyable driving experience, and of course will offer better real-world mileage than the Astor. As for resale, a 39,000km first-batch Astor in Chennai should realistically fetch somewhere in the Rs 7-8 lakh range, but all depending on condition, service history and variant. The key is to be realistic about the depreciation and focus on the long-term savings and improved ownership experience with the new car.Overall, if he is unhappy with the Astor and wants better fuel efficiency and more power, moving to a diesel Venue is a sensible decision.

MG Astor

Hyundai Venue

autocar.india

•10w

Go for the Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder strong-hybrid automatic - it will cut your fuel use sharply, often doing 20-plus kpl in city traffic where the Astor struggles. The automatic is smooth and stress-free, and because the hybrid runs on electric power a lot in stop-and-go, you get far better mileage without changing your driving style. Size, space and comfort are close to your Astor, so the switch is easy.Two things to keep in mind: the hybrid costs more upfront than a regular petrol automatic, and the boot is smaller. Also, when you press hard, the engine sounds a bit loud, but in daily driving, it stays quiet and efficient. Toyota backs the hybrid battery well, which helps long-term peace of mind.If most of your running is highway, look at the Kia Seltos diesel automatic instead - it returns strong highway mileage and feels relaxed at speed.

Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder

MG Astor

Kia Seltos

autocar.india

•10w

The MG ZS EV is still worth buying today, especially at the heavily reduced prices being offered currently. Yes, MG is working on a replacement for both the Astor and ZS EV, but that MG car is not around the corner. The replacement is expected only around 2027 and will be based on an all-new modular platform with newer technology and powertrain options.For your use case, that shouldn't be a deal breaker. Your daily commute is only 50km, which the ZS EV can handle effortlessly. More importantly, the current discounts significantly improve the value proposition. The money you're saving today will likely offset a large part of the depreciation hit associated with buying a model that is approaching the end of its lifecycle.The ZS EV also remains a very competent EV. It has a proven powertrain, a comfortable ride, good performance and a feature-rich cabin.

MG ZS EV

MG Astor

autocar.india

•18w

Go for the Renault Duster if you want a simple, easy first SUV, but be clear about what you are choosing. The new 2026 Duster is very different from the older one, and that slightly changes the decision. It is now a more modern, feature-loaded SUV with strong petrol engines, including the 1.3 turbo petrol with manual and dual-clutch options. This Renault car remains one of the better cars to drive in this segment and offers a comfortable ride along with an easy, confidence-inspiring feel, making it a good fit for a newcomer.Currently, the Duster is offered with two turbo-petrol engines: a 1.0-litre 3-cylinder unit from the Kiger and a 1.3-litre 4-cylinder direct-injection turbo-petrol engine. The Renault Duster mileage ranges from 17.75kpl to 19.41kpl. The 1.0-litre turbo-petrol manual returns 19.41kpl, while the 1.3-litre turbo-petrol delivers 17.75kpl to 18.45kpl, depending on the transmission.Compared to it, the Tata Nexon is smaller, less spacious and not as engaging to drive. However, being from a segment below at a similar price point, it offers more premium features, which is worth keeping in mind.The MG Astor’s biggest strength is its interior quality, which feels more premium. On the downside, the engine options are not as strong as the Duster’s, and it is also smaller and narrower inside, so it does not feel as spacious.

Renault Duster

Tata Nexon

MG Astor

autocar.india

•26w

The MG Astor is a decent all-rounder amongst the mid-size SUVs, but it doesn't excel in any particular area. You're right to observe that its 1.5-litre petrol engine won't feel punchy enough for highway overtakes, and moreover, it doesn't give you that confident, planted feel at high speeds. Design aside, both the Tata Nexon and the Kia Sonet will feel cramped compared to other SUVs available at this price. Given your priorities, you should definitely stretch for the Volkswagen Taigun Topline, as it seems to perfectly align with your needs. The 1.0-litre TSI turbo-petrol engine of this Volkswagen car has loads of punch, the SUV feels superbly planted at highway speeds, and on top of that, it is comfortable as well. The Taigun price starts at Rs 11.00 lakh (ex-showroom).It has a 5-star Global NCAP rating, so safety shouldn't be an issue, and since it is the Topline variant, it has plenty of features. There is a facelift of the Taigun coming later this year, but the price you are getting this 2025 example is too good to ignore, so we feel you should go for it.

Volkswagen Taigun

Kia Sonet

Tata Nexon

MG Astor