Tata Punch vs rivals: price, dimensions and powertrain comparison

    Published On Oct 19, 2021 03:05:00 PM

    75868 Views

    The Tata Punch rivals high-riding hatchbacks like the Ignis and KUV100, as well as the competitively priced Nissan Magnite and Renault Kiger compact SUVs.

    Tata Motors has finally launched the much-anticipated Punch micro-SUV, with prices starting at Rs 5.49 lakh. Based on the ALFA architecture that also underpins the Altroz, the Punch is available in four trims  Pure, Adventure, Accomplished and Creative, with a solitary petrol engine and two gearbox options.

    In terms of competition, the Tata Punch rivals high-riding hatchbacks like the Ignis and KUV100 and competitively priced compact SUVs such as the Nissan Magnite and Renault Kiger.

    • Tata Punch falls in the middle in terms of length and width
    • Tata Punch has the second largest boot space and fuel tank capacity here
    • Powered by a sole 1.2-litre engine with manual and AMT gearbox options

    Read on to see how Tata’s latest SUV compares against these aforementioned models in terms of dimensions, engines and gearboxes. 

    Tata Punch vs rivals: dimensions

    Dimensions
    PunchIgnisKUV100 NXTMagniteKiger
    Length3827mm3700mm3700mm3994mm3991mm
    Width1742mm1690mm1735mm1758mm1750mm
    Height1615mm1595mm1655mm1572mm1600mm
    Wheelbase2445mm2435mm2385mm2500mm2500mm
    Boot space366 litres260 litres243 litres336 litres405 litres
    Fuel capacity37 litres32 litres35 litres40 litres40 litres
    Tyre size16-inch15-inch15-inch16-inch16-inch

    In terms of dimensions, the Tata Punch falls right in the middle of the pack. The Punch is longer overall and wider and has a longer wheelbase than the Ignis and the KUV100, but it falls short on both departments against the Magnite and the Kiger. Similarly, the Punch is taller than the Maruti, the Nissan and the Renault, but is shorter than the Mahindra.

    The Kiger boasts of the largest boot here, at 405 litres, with the Punch following closely with a 366-litre boot. The Magnite is not far behind with a 336-litre boot. The Ignis and KUV100 have the smallest boots here, with a capacity of 260 litres and 243 litres, respectively.

    The Renault-Nissan Alliance twins also have the largest fuel tanks in this comparison at 40 litres. The Tata Punch, meanwhile, has a 37-litre tank, while the Mahindra KUV100 NXT has a 35-litre tank and the Maruti Ignis the smallest at 32 litres.

    In terms of tyre sizes, the Punch, the Magnite and the Kiger all get 16-inch alloys in their top-spec form. The Ignis and KUV100, meanwhile, make do with 15-inchers.

    The Punch also has class-leading breakover, approach and departure angles and water wading capability, as per Tata. The micro-SUV has an approach angle of 20.3 degrees, departure angle of 37.6 degrees, a rampover angle of 22.2 degrees and a water-wading depth of up to 370mm, proving its SUV credentials.

    Tata Punch vs rivals: engine and gearbox

    Engine and gearbox
    PunchIgnisKUV100 NXTMagniteKiger
    Type3 cyls, NA4 cyls, NA3 cyls, NA3 cyls, NA/3 cyls, Turbo3 cyls, NA/3 cyls, Turbo
    Displacement1199cc1197cc1198cc999cc/999cc999cc/999cc
    Power86hp83hp83hp72hp/100hp72hp/100hp
    Torque113Nm113Nm115Nm96Nm/160Nm(MT) 152Nm(AT)96Nm/160Nm(MT) 152Nm(AT)
    Manual gearbox5-speed5-speed5-speed5-speed/5-speed5-speed/5-speed
    Automatic gearbox5-speed AMT5-speed AMT-CVT (Turbo)5-speed AMT/CVT
    ARAI mileage MT-20.89kpl13.25kpl18.75kpl/20kpl-/20kpl
    ARAI mileage AT-20.89kpl-17.7kpl-/18.24kpl

    The Tata Punch is powered by a 1.2-litre, three-cylinder, naturally aspirated (NA) petrol motor that also does duty in the Tiago and Tigor. The KUV100, Magnite and Kiger also come with three-cylinder, naturally aspirated petrol engines, but while the Mahindra’s is a 1.2-litre unit like the Tata’s, Renault-Nissan make do with a 1.0-litre unit. 

    The Punch’s three-cylinder, NA motor is the most powerful of the lot, putting out 86hp, while the KUV’s is the torquiest, producing 115Nm. Given the Magnite and Kiger’s engine’s smaller displacement, they have least output – 72hp and 96Nm.

    Meanwhile, the Maruti Suzuki Ignis is the only car here that comes with a four-cylinder engine. The 1.2-litre unit is naturally aspirated and puts out 83hp and 113Nm, which is on par with the competition. 

    However, the Nissan Magnite and Renault Kiger also come with 1.0-litre turbo-petrol engines, making them the most powerful overall. It puts out 100hp and either 160Nm or 153Nm, depending on the gearbox. The Punch is likely to get the 1.2-litre turbo petrol engine from the Altroz in the future. 

    Talking of gearboxes, all vehicles get manual and automatic options, save for the Mahindra and NA version of the Magnite  which is manual only. The Punch, Ignis and the NA version of the Kiger get AMT automatic options, in addition to the standard 5-speed manual. Meanwhile, the turbo-petrol versions of the Nissan and Renault get a more sophisticated CVT automatic option.

    The Tata Punch comes equipped with automatic engine start/stop functionality which is said to aid fuel efficiency. The official ARAI-rated figure for the Punch is 18.97kpl for the manual and 18.82kpl for the AMT auto. Although these figures are impressive, they do lag behind the Ignis’ figures and the manual versions of the Kiger and Magnite turbo. The Mahindra KUV100, meanwhile, is the least efficient.

    Tata Punch vs rivals: price comparison

    Price
    PunchIgnisKUV100MagniteKiger
    MT variantsRs 5.49-8.79 lakhRs 5.10-6.97 lakhRs 6.06-7.72 lakhRs 5.71-9.00 lakhRs 5.64-9.21 lakh
    AT variantsRs 6.99-9.39 lakhRs 6.31-7.47 lakhNARs 8.51-9.89 lakhRs 7.04-9.89 lakh

    In terms of pricing, the Punch is on par with its competitors. Although the manual variants of the Punch have a higher starting price than the Ignis, it is lower than that of the KUV100, Magnite and Kiger. At the top-end, the Punch is more expensive than the Ignis and KUV100 but manages to undercut the Magnite and Kiger.

    Similarly, the automatic versions of Punch start at Rs 6.99 lakh, which, although more expensive than the Ignis, is cheaper than the Magnite and Kiger. In their fully loaded automatic specs, the Ignis is cheaper than the Punch while the Nissan and Renault are more expensive. However, it’s worth noting that these prices also take into account the more powerful, turbocharged variants of the Nissan and Renault which come with the more sophisticated CVT gearbox.

    Furthermore, the Magnite and Kiger are offered with additional equipment packs with some variants of the Kiger also offering a dual-tone paint scheme  which further drives up prices. This is how the Tata Punch compares against rivals on paper. However, only a proper on-road comparison will determine how it fares in the real world.

    All prices are ex-showroom, Delhi

     

    Copyright (c) Autocar India. All rights reserved.

    img

    No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

    Ask Autocar Anything about Car and Bike Buying and Maintenance Advices
    Need an expert opinion on your car and bike related queries?
    Ask Now
    Poll of the month

    Which upcoming Maruti Suzuki model are you most excited for?

    New Baleno

     

    9%

    New Brezza

     

    20%

    New Alto

     

    4%

    Jimny

     

    29%

    Creta, Seltos rival

     

    18%

    Compact SUV Coupe

     

    11%

    Safari, Alcazar rival

     

    10%

    Total Votes : 723
    Sign up for our newsletter

    Get all the latest updates from the automobile universe