Tata Manual Cars in India (9)

autocar.india

•6d

Between your two picks, the Hyundai Exter has the more refined powertrain. Its four-cylinder engine feels very smooth, and the clutch and shift action are light, making it very easy to drive in traffic. Performance is also stronger, and space and practicality are marginally better. Hyundai also has a strong reputation for reliability and after-sales service, so it offers peace of mind, which is important for your first car.The Tata Punch doesn't have the same level of refinement, but its ride quality is superior to the Exter's. It also has a higher driving position, which will be useful since you are a new driver. Tata's service can be inconsistent, so check your local dealer's reputation before you commit. Overall, the Exter is the more sensible choice; however, if ride quality and a high seating position are non-negotiable for you, then the Punch is a fine alternative.

Hyundai Exter

Tata Punch

autocar.india

•2w

Your average daily running of 40km and a monthly running of 1200km isn't much to justify the premium you would pay for a Hyundai Exter CNG over the petrol-manual version. On the other hand, the AMT gets you the convenience of an automatic without compromising fuel efficiency significantly (compared to the manual version), so it is certainly worth paying for; even more so, since your wife isn't comfortable driving a manual. If you're open to other options and absolutely want CNG along with the convenience of an automatic, consider the Tata Punch CNG AMT or the Maruti Baleno CNG AMT.

Hyundai Exter

Tata Punch

Maruti Suzuki Baleno

autocar.india

•2w

The Tata Nexon is one of the most value for money offerings in its segment, and because this second-gen Nexon has been around for a while now, the 2026 iteration feels the most mature version till date. The car is tough, its cabin is spacious and it gives the driver ample confidence at any speed.Before going ahead do keep in mind that its engine isn't the smoothest or the most refined in its segment. Also, an all-new generation of the Nexon will be launched in the second half of 2027. That said, if you like the current Nexon for what it offers, go for it.

Tata Nexon

autocar.india

•3w

We would recommend the Harrier diesel automatic if you do substantial highway driving or cover over 15,000km annually. If your usage is mainly within the city and your annual running is low, the petrol automatic is worth considering, although its fuel bills will be considerably higher than those of your Nexon petrol.The stricter emission norms coming into effect from April 2027 are fleet average fuel efficiency targets for manufacturers, not a ban on diesel cars. The diesel therefore remains a viable option, particularly if you intend to keep the Harrier for several years and regularly undertake long journeys. Fuel efficiency is the petrol Harrier's biggest drawback. In Autocar India's test, the petrol automatic returned 6.17kpl in the city and 12.49kpl on the highway, against 9.6kpl and 14.4kpl respectively for the diesel automatic.The automatic is more convenient in traffic, while the manual diesel offers slightly better efficiency. Neither gearbox should be chosen on durability assumptions alone.

Tata Harrier