Autocar India

Ask or share your thoughts

Get opinions from India’s growing automotive community

Discover topics

Follow topics to stay in the loop

•2w

I am looking to buy a car that will usually accommodate three people. I have shortlisted the Tata Punch CNG, Tata Nexon CNG and Tata Nexon diesel. My monthly running is around 400km in the city and 800km on the highway, and I live in Pune. Which of these three cars would you recommend, considering that I plan to keep it for more than 10 years? My priorities are low running and maintenance costs, along with long-term reliability. I would appreciate your suggestion based on these factors. Please restrict the comparison to these three options and do not include Maruti models.

51
Verified
•2h

The Tata Nexon diesel would be our recommendation, given your monthly running of around 1,200km, with 800km on the highway. Its 1.5-litre diesel engine produces 115hp and 260Nm, making it considerably better suited to highway cruising and overtaking than the CNG engines in the Tata Punch and Nexon. It will also deliver better fuel efficiency on long runs. The Nexon CNG is worth considering if minimising fuel costs is the overriding priority, but the diesel offers stronger performance and a more relaxed highway experience. The Punch CNG is the least suitable of the three for your usage, as it is smaller and its performance is more limited, particularly with passengers and luggage.For 10-year ownership, remember that the diesel will have higher periodic maintenance costs, including additional fuel filter and timing belt related expenses. CNG also brings its own filter maintenance and periodic cylinder testing requirements.

Tata Nexon
Tata Nexon

More posts from

Family & 7-Seaters

View all posts
•2w

I’m planning to buy an electric car, but I’m a little confused and would appreciate your advice. I’m a civil engineer, and my daily commute is around 100–150km, covering a mix of city and village roads. I also travel frequently to my hometown, which is in a hilly region, with a round trip of approximately 270km. My highway usage is relatively low. My primary requirement is a 5-seater EV, and my budget is around Rs 23 lakh. Currently, I’m considering the Tata Harrier EV Adventure S and the MG Tomahawk EV Excite, but I’m open to other suggestions if you think there are better options. I have already test-driven the Mahindra XEV 9S, but its base variant is currently unavailable, while the mid variant is beyond my budget. Could you please suggest which EV would be the best choice for my usage and requirements? Thank you in advance for your advice.

74
Verified
•6h

In your case, given the requirement and conditions, the Tata Sierra EV would be a good option to consider. While the Harrier EV is slightly bigger, the Sierra EV in the same price will get you the same battery with better range and a better feature set too. The claimed range for the Sierra EV is also better than the Harrier EV and it is a newer car. Rear seat comfort and space is also better and the ride comfort in the Sierra EV trumps the Harrier EV. Uphill drives won't be a struggle either given the four terrain modes the Sierra gets and being a RWD. All things considered, the Sierra EV makes the most sense so we would urge you to check it out.

Upcoming launch buzz

Community discussions on upcoming launches

•2w

I currently own a 2019 Honda Amaze petrol manual, which has covered around 70,000 km. I genuinely enjoy the car, particularly the creamy smoothness, predictable low-end response and reliability of Honda's 1.2-litre, four-cylinder i-VTEC engine. I am now contemplating a change, and the Renault Triber Turbo has caught my attention because of its modular seating, practical cabin and features such as cruise control. However, I am torn about whether moving from the Amaze to the Triber Turbo would be a genuine upgrade or an ergonomic and mechanical compromise. I would appreciate some advice on what to expect in terms of engine refinement, drivability, comfort and overall ownership experience compared to my current car.

77
Verified
•7h

The Renault Triber Turbo is a worthwhile upgrade if you want more space, versatility and stronger performance, but it won't match the Honda Amaze's engine refinement. Its 1.0-litre, three-cylinder turbo petrol engine produces 100 hp and 180 Nm, and is significantly more capable than the Triber's naturally aspirated engine. It has a strong mid-range, pulls well even when fully loaded and feels much more comfortable at highway speeds. The suspension is also well sorted, with good high-speed composure and improved body control around bends.However, the engine has noticeable three-cylinder vibrations at idle, and its power delivery is less linear than the Amaze's naturally aspirated i-VTEC. You will also need to keep it above 2,000rpm to avoid the off-boost hesitation. The five speed manual gearbox is notchy, while road and wind noise are quite noticeable at highway speeds. The Triber's front seats could also do with better lumbar and thigh support.We would look at the Triber Turbo as an upgrade in practicality and performance, rather than refinement or overall driving experience.

Renault Triber
Renault Triber
•2w

Dear Team Autocar, I am planning to buy a mid-size petrol automatic SUV and have a monthly running of around 500km. I am currently considering the Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder Neodrive G, Honda Elevate and Mahindra Scorpio. I have come across several online reports suggesting that a facelifted Toyota Hyryder could be launched soon. Could you confirm whether this is likely and, if so, provide an approximate launch timeline? I would also appreciate your guidance on choosing a vehicle that offers a low cost of ownership, affordable maintenance and better fuel efficiency. Thank you in advance for your suggestions.

105
Verified
•8h

The Toyota Hyryder facelift is still some time away. While there are reports suggesting an update in 2027, we haven't seen a convincing indication of an imminent launch, and there is no confirmed timeline from Toyota.We would suggest considering the current Toyota Hyryder Petrol G(O) Neodrive AT rather than waiting indefinitely. The 1.5-litre petrol engine and six-speed torque converter automatic make for a reliable, easy-to-own package, and with your relatively low monthly running of 500km. The Honda Elevate CVT is also worth considering if you prioritise a smoother drive and a more spacious cabin.The current Hyryder is also attracting attractive discounts, which are unlikely to be available on the facelift when it first arrives. Our advice would be to negotiate hard on the current model and buy it if you get a good deal, rather than wait for an update that is still some distance away.

Find related posts in one place

Explore topics to stay in the loop

•2w

I am planning to buy a car this year, around Diwali or the end of 2026. I am looking for a spacious, comfortable and safe 5-seater for my family, with an on-road budget of Rs 8–15 lakh. Around Rs 12 lakh is my sweet spot, although I am open to spending less if a car offers excellent mileage, safety, space and reliability. My expected running is around 7,000–8,000 km per month, primarily involving daily commutes, a mix of GT road driving and city driving. I intend to keep the car for at least 10–12 years, so fuel efficiency, low maintenance costs, long-term reliability, comfortable seating and good after-sales service are my top priorities. I am not particularly interested in fancy features that I may rarely use; essential safety and convenience features are more than sufficient. Considering my high monthly running, which fuel type, petrol, diesel or CNG, would be the most economical and practical choice over 10–12 years? Please recommend the best cars and specific variants within my budget, comparing their real-world mileage, running costs, maintenance expenses, reliability and family comfort. For CNG options, I would particularly like an assessment of factory-fitted underbody CNG tanks and their practicality for long-term ownership. Please suggest suitable options in both petrol and CNG, and explain which car, engine and fuel option you would personally choose for my usage, keeping long-term ownership costs and reliability in mind.

107
Verified
•9h

Given your exceptionally high monthly running, the Maruti Suzuki Brezza VXI CNG would be our recommendation. It offers a good combination of cabin space, comfortable seating, practicality and low running costs. The factory-fitted underbody CNG tank is a particularly useful feature, as it preserves most of the boot space instead of taking up the luggage area. The VXi should also fit comfortably within your Rs 12 lakh on-road target, without having to stretch your budget for features you may rarely use.

More posts from

Family & 7-Seaters

View all posts
•2w

With a budget of Rs 23–24 lakh, should I consider the Hyundai Alcazar Turbo Petrol DCT or the Kia Seltos GTX Petrol, comparing both the IVT and DCT options? My annual driving is approximately 6,000–7,000 km, and I would like a detailed comparison focusing on long-term ownership over 10–15 years, reliability, maintenance costs, transmission durability, fuel efficiency and overall value for money. I would also like to understand the practical differences between Hyundai’s K2 and Kia’s K3 platforms, particularly in terms of structural strength, safety, ride comfort, handling and long-term durability. Given my relatively low annual usage and preference for hassle-free ownership, which car and transmission combination would make the most sense within my budget?

101
Verified
•10h

Our top recommendation is the Kia Seltos GTX Petrol IVT. It is likely to be the most sensible combination of performance, comfort, running costs and long-term mechanical simplicity for your usage.The Hyundai Alcazar Turbo DCT is tempting because of its larger cabin, more powerful engine and three-row practicality. However, unless you regularly need the third row, I don't think it offers enough additional value to justify choosing it over the Seltos.There is also an important distinction between the Seltos IVT and DCT: for your relatively low annual mileage and long ownership horizon, I'd favour the IVT even though the DCT is considerably more engaging.The Seltos has moved to the new K3 platform in its second generation, while the Alcazar continues on the K2 architecture. Interestingly, the K3 platform's biggest practical advantage might not be structural strength but its overall refinement. It absorbs bumps more effectively than the previous generation while retaining good body control and high-speed stability.All things considered, the Seltos in its IVT guise makes for a better buy.

Kia Seltos
Kia Seltos
•2w

Hi Team Autocar, I am looking to buy a car within a budget of Rs 30 lakh. Initially, I was considering the MG Tomahawk PHEV, but delays in its availability have made me explore other options. I have also considered the Tata Sierra, Tata Safari and a few other models. My primary objective is to buy a recently launched 5 or 7-seater in its top-spec variant, with the best possible interiors, safety features and comfort equipment. I can stretch my budget to a maximum on-road price of Rs 32 lakh. I am open to petrol and hybrid options, although I may prefer a diesel given my annual running. However, concerns about diesel vehicle restrictions in Delhi after 10 years are making me reconsider that choice. My usage is primarily in Delhi traffic, with a daily commute of around 45-50 km that involves spending nearly 3-4 hours in the car. I also undertake weekend trips of approximately 400 km. Considering my requirements and usage, could you please suggest one or two suitable options? Thanks in advance.

151
Verified
•14h

We would shortlist the Mahindra XUV 7XO and Toyota Innova Hycross Hybrid. Both offer a strong combination of space, comfort and features, while allowing you to avoid the uncertainty surrounding long-term diesel ownership in Delhi.The Mahindra XUV 7XO petrol automatic AX7T would be the more sensible choice within your Rs 32 lakh on-road budget. It offers a modern, feature-rich cabin, three rows of seating, strong performance from its 203hp turbo-petrol engine and a comfortable ride. The AX7T also gets ventilated seats, a Harman Kardon audio system and Level 2 ADAS, making it a good fit for long hours in Delhi traffic as well as weekend highway trips. If you can stretch your budget, consider the Toyota Innova Hycross Hybrid VX. Its strong-hybrid powertrain is particularly well suited to your daily stop-start commute, offering excellent fuel efficiency and a relaxed driving experience. It also has a more spacious and comfortable cabin, especially for passengers in the second and third rows. However, in your budget you will get the VX or the VX(O) and not the top of the line ZX(O) variant.

Mahindra XUV 7XO
Mahindra XUV 7XO

Find related posts in one place

Explore topics to stay in the loop

More posts from

General Buying Advice

View all posts

More posts from

Ownership Experience

View all posts