autocar-logo
Delhi
Fallback ad for 970x90

Maruti Dzire vs Tata Zest diesel AMT comparison

The recently facelifted Swift Dzire, now has an AMT gearbox up its sleeve. Will it be another jerky affair, or is it better than the Zest?
1 min read17 Mar '16
Staff WriterStaff Writer
36K+ views

Dzire feels a bit firm at low speeds. It handles well. Performance overall is much better, it feels like a regular automatic car.

Simple yet functional design showing age. But interior quality is above average; Monochrome display looks dated in today’s colour touchscreen age.

Dzire’s well-bolstered front seats are very comfortable.

. Legroom in the back is decent, beige trim and seats give the cabin an airy feel.

Fiat-sourced engine makes 74bhp.

Telephony controls placed behind the wheel.

AMT gearbox smooth in operation.

Audio display functional but dated.

High loading lip is a bit inconvenient.

The Tata Zest has the ability to crush potholes but it rolls a fair bit. Performance is not as strong, it jerks and baulks at slow speeds.

Well crafted dashboard looks brilliant. Quality of materials used good too; Driving position is not so good with high-set seats and poor range of steering adjustment.

High-set front seats offer good visibility but are a bit too soft.

Rear seats are the comfiest here. Ingress and egress is a breeze.

The Zest uses an uprated 88.8bhp Fiat motor.

AMT gearbox jerky.

Knurled climate control knobs feel nice.

Touchscreen infotainment system has good acoustics.

Strut mounts intrude into the boot.

Fallback ad for 728x90

What’s new?

Hitting the sweet spot is of paramount importance. This is irrespective of the game you play; be it tennis, cricket or selling cars. The sweet spot in the car market currently rests somewhere above the compact sedan class. They have the right size, the right price and the right profile and Indian car buyers just love them.

Maruti’s Dzire, its compact sedan, has been whacking the ball dead center for more than four years now. A clear market leader, its precisely calculated formula is so on the button, many car buyers walk in and buy it without so much as a test drive. But Maruti isn’t satisfied as the customer is always a moving target. And the result is its first diesel automatic, a car guaranteed to widen the appeal of the already popular Dzire.

The Dzire AMT, however, isn’t the first car in its class; far from it. That bit of turf is actually owned by Tata, who pioneered the segment when it launched the Zest AMT at the Auto Expo a couple of years ago. And the cars share more than basic size and specifications. Both use Fiat 1.3-litre Multijet-based
diesel engines, both cars use automated manual transmissions or automatic gearboxes that are based on more affordable manual gearboxes and both cars cost in the region of Rs 8 lakh. So, which is better, the new Dzire or the Zest?

Fallback ad for 728x90
Fallback ad for 728x90

Mini Convertible launched at Rs 34.90 lakh

Available in the petrol Cooper S guise, the Mini Convertible is powered by a 189bhp 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine.
2 min read16 Mar '16
Jaiveer MehraJaiveer Mehra
Fallback ad for 728x90

New York motor show 2016 preview

Here is a look at some of the cars you can expect at the New York motor show this year.
1 min read16 Mar '16
Staff WriterStaff Writer
Fallback ad for 728x90

Mercedes-Benz CLA facelift revealed

The updated CLA gets cosmetic changes, added equipment and new variants; will make its debut at the upcoming New York motor show.
2 min read16 Mar '16
Jaiveer MehraJaiveer Mehra
Fallback ad for 728x90

Tata Tiago vs i10 vs Celerio vs Beat: Specifications comparison

We take a look at how the upcoming Tata Tiago hatchback matches up to the established players in the segment.
2 min read16 Mar '16
Jaiveer MehraJaiveer Mehra
Fallback ad for 728x90

Jeep reveals seven SUV concepts

Based on the Wrangler and the Renegade, the seven SUV concepts will be showcased at the 50th annual Jeep Easter Safari.
2 min read16 Mar '16
Jaiveer MehraJaiveer Mehra
Fallback ad for 728x90