I want to buy a mid-size SUV with a petrol automatic powertrain. My priorities are good fuel efficiency and strong resale value. The vehicle will be used mostly for city driving.

Autocar India

•1d

Go for the Marutu Suzuki Victoris AWD, not the Marutu Suzuki Jimny, for what you plan to do. You said no real off-roading, just “all sorts of roads” - broken village stretches, rain-soaked highways, mild slush. The Victoris’ AWD will send drive to the rear when it slips, so you keep moving without the drama, while giving you far better ride comfort, highway stability, space and boot than the Jimny. You also get a more modern cabin and features like a 360-degree camera, and in some trims, ADAS is available.Jimny’s low-range 4x4 only really pays off in deep ruts, rock steps and deep mud. For daily use, it’s slower, bouncier, narrower, and the boot is smaller.One honest catch with the Victoris: AWD won't be as fuel-efficient as the FWD model. If your routes are just rough and unpredictable rather than extreme, the Victoris AWD will suit you fine.

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

Maruti Suzuki Jimny

Autocar India

•1h

Pick the Tata Nexon EV Empowered 45kWh version. For a family of 5 on a Rs. 17 lakh budget, it gives the most spacious cabin and easy step-in height for parents and kids, it rides well on bad roads, and its real-world range is enough so you'll have to charge it once or twice a week. You also get proper fast charging and Tata’s wider EV support, which matters when you are out with family.Do note that three big adults in the back will be shoulder-to-shoulder on long trips, but it is fine for two adults and a child. If your use is mostly city and you want to save money, the Tata Punch EV LR does the job, but space is tighter for five.

Tata Nexon EV

Autocar India

•3h

Get the Tata Punch EV Adventure 40 - it fits your Rs 12 lakh budget and will comfortably do a 50km daily city run. Its range is enough to top up just twice a week, maybe even once. The small size makes traffic and parking easy, and Tata’s EV network is the strongest at this price.You will give up some space and highway pace versus bigger EVs, and DC fast charging isn’t the quickest, so long trips need planning. For city duty though, it’s smooth, quiet and cheap to run. Make sure you can have a charger installed at your home, though, as that is essential to EV ownership. If you want a fully loaded model, at the cost of range, check out the newly launched Tata Tiago EV Creative Plus 24. It's a bit more compact, but if that's not an issue, it's a great vehicle. However, the real-world range will be considerably lower than the Punch EV, and you'll have to charge more often.

Tata Punch EV

Tata Tiago EV