Mumbai

Arnav Nagar

•1d

Hi, we are buying a new SUV with a budget of around 16-17 lakh. Initially, we thought of buying the Sierra Pure Plus petrol NA, but after seeing reviews saying that it has the weakest engine in the lineup, we dropped the idea. Now we are thinking of buying the diesel Sierra. Our usage includes a 1,000-2,000km trip every three months, along with some city driving in between, so a diesel might make sense. However, we are still confused between the Creta and the Sierra. My dad, however, loves the Sierra.

Autocar India

•35m

This is very much a case of heart versus head. If your father loves the Tata Sierra, then the Sierra Diesel is actually a good choice. The diesel engine is far better suited to the Sierra than the naturally aspirated petrol, offering strong performance and effortless cruising on long highway trips. The Sierra also feels larger inside, has a wider cabin and is the better pure 5-seater of the two, with excellent space and comfort for family use.

The Hyundai Creta is the more sensible choice. Its diesel engine is more refined, the overall ownership experience is smoother, and Hyundai's service network and aftersales support are generally stronger. It is also a proven product with a long track record.

The drawback of the Sierra is that its diesel engine is not as refined as the Creta's, and Tata's ownership experience can be more variable depending on the dealership.

Explore cars mentioned

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 Lakh

Hyundai

Creta

from ₹12.92 Lakh

Compare suggested cars

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 lakhs

Hyundai

Creta

from ₹12.92 lakhs

Compare now

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki

Victoris

from ₹12.44 lakhs

Compare now

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki

Grand Vitara

from ₹12.75 lakhs

Compare now

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 lakhs

Toyota

Urban Cruiser Hyryder

from ₹13.01 lakhs

Compare now

Tata

Sierra

from ₹13.60 lakhs

Kia

Seltos

from ₹13.02 lakhs

Compare now

More questions on similar cars

Arnav Nagar

•3d

Hi, We want to buy a new SUV. We have selected some of the options between Siera and Creta. Our budget is between 16 and 16.50 lakhs. Firstly, we are going for the Sierra Pure Plus because it is new, but later we found out that its engine is the worst in this segment. So, we decided to go for the diesel variant of Sierra Pure, comprising the sunroof and also my dad wants a new design, actually Sierra's design. So what should we do, go for the Creta or the Sierra diesel? In Creta, we got almost all features. Our mostly drive is in highway, we take trips every four months, long trips like 1000km.

Autocar India

•2d

Pick the Hyundai Creta diesel. For your kind of use - mostly highway and 1,000 km trips every few months - Hyundai’s diesel is relaxed, efficient and already proven, so you get long range and low-stress cruising. You also said the Creta gives you almost all the features you want within Rs. 16-16.5 lakh, which keeps the maths clean, and this is something you will enjoy each time you use your car. The Tata Sierra looks fresh, and your dad will love the design, but the diesel with a sunroof will likely sit well above your budget.Creta’s seats and ride are sorted for long runs, and Hyundai’s network makes life easier on the road. You do give up the Sierra’s stand-out look and bigger road presence, so if design is your number one goal and you can stretch the budget and accept potential first-batch rough edges, go Sierra. Otherwise, Creta diesel is the smarter highway pick.

Hyundai Creta

Tata Sierra

Lalit

•1d

I'm planning to buy a new car in the approximate 18 lakh range. I'm confused between the Creta SX Premium Summer Edition and the Seltos HTX(A) variant. While the Seltos has more features, its petrol NA engine felt underpowered, and the turbo version is above 20 lakh. I generally drive in the city and on highways, but I also visit hilly areas often. Can you suggest any other options in this range?

Autocar India

•1h

Pick the Hyundai Creta diesel manual. Your hill drives will benefit from the effortless pull of a diesel at low speeds, and this engine gives that without making you work the gearbox. It also does better mileage than the petrol in all conditions, and the Creta’s ride is a touch softer, so your city commutes and long highway runs will be comfier. The only catch is you may give up a few of the Seltos’ showy features at this price, and the new-gen Kia Seltos is a bit more spacious than the Creta.If you’re fixed on petrol and want more pull than the Creta or Seltos' 1.5 NA petrol, look at the Skoda Kushaq 1.0 TSI or Volkswagen Taigun 1.0 TSI. Their turbo engines have strong mid‑range for hills and overtakes, and you can find good manual or automatic variants within your budget. They’re a size smaller inside than Creta/Seltos, and service reach isn’t as wide in smaller towns, but they drive superbly. Alternatively, check out the new Renault Duster, which offers both turbo-petrol engines across a wide price range.

Prateek Verma

I am planning to buy my personal car, and I am looking for an automatic transmission. I have been driving the Creta 2022 MT, and most of my driving would be in the NCR region, along with a few getaway trips to the hills or my hometown in UP. I have a budget of around 17-18 Lakhs on-road. I am looking for a car that’s comfortable to drive and has a good suspension. With Creta, I get around 19-20 KMPL on highways and a combined mileage of 13-15 KMPL within city limits. I don’t drive aggressively and am not a fan of overspeeding. Till now, I have figured out a few options like Skoda Kushaq signature 1.0 AT, Seltos HTK(O) 1.5 NA, or maybe I can consider Honda Elevate. Can you suggest a better car for me? I have heard the Seltos NA engine doesn’t have much power, though my current Creta has the same torque.

Autocar India

•17h

The Kia Seltos HTK(O) 1.5 Petrol CVT would be the pick here. It feels more premium than the Elevate, offers a comfortable ride and the smooth CVT suits everyday driving extremely well.As for performance, the 1.5-litre naturally aspirated petrol is essentially the same engine that powers your Creta. If you are happy with your current car's performance, there is no reason to worry about the Seltos feeling underpowered. It may not be the quickest SUV in the segment, but it is smooth, refined and well-suited to relaxed driving.The Skoda Kushaq 1.0 AT feels punchier in the mid-range and is more enjoyable to drive, but the Seltos is the more rounded package overall. The Honda Elevate CVT is comfortable and practical, though it does not feel as premium inside.

View all Posts

Expert reviews worth reading

Popular discussions right now

Balaji

•6d

I am looking to buy a 6/7-seater EV. My primary usage will be as a 4-seater, with occasional 6-seater use. I will mainly drive it in the city for my daily office commute and undertake long-distance trips of around 500 km once every two months. I have a solar setup at home and can charge the vehicle comfortably. My budget is Rs 30-40 lakh, although I can stretch it slightly if required.

Autocar India

•6d

You should go for the Mahindra XEV 9S. It's a proper three-row EV, and it fits your use case perfectly. With home solar charging, your running costs are very low, and the smooth, quiet drive is just right for city runs as a 4-seater. When you do need six or seven seats, the third row is reasonably spacious, and for your 500 km trip every couple of months, you’ll need just one quick top-up at a highway charger.Do note that with all three rows up, boot space is tight, so your highway trips will require some planning.Alternatively, consider the Kia Carens Clavis EV. It isn't as feature-rich and doesn't have as much range as the XEV 9S, but its third row is more comfortable for adults.

Mahindra XEV 9S

Kia Carens Clavis EV

Abhishek Das

•3d

I am planning to purchase a new automatic car and am confused between the Honda Amaze ZX CVT and the Skoda Kylaq Signature Plus AT. My usage will be around 90% city driving, primarily for office commuting between Dwarka, Delhi and my office near IFFCO Chowk, Gurugram (approximately 25 km one way). However, I will not be driving daily, as I often use the Metro as well. The car will also be driven by my 69-year-old father, so ease of driving, comfort, visibility, ingress/egress, and reliability are important considerations. Our previous car was an Alto K10 Manual, so this will be our first automatic car and a significant upgrade. Considering my usage pattern, family profile and the fact that we intend to keep the car for a long period for around 10 years, which of these two would you recommend?

Autocar India

•2d

Based on your requirement, we would recommend the Honda Amaze ZX CVT over the Skoda Kylaq Signature+ AT. The reason is that your priorities are not outright performance or driving excitement. You are looking for a car that will spend 90% of its life in city traffic, will also be driven by your 69-year-old father, and is expected to stay with the family for around 10 years. In that context, Amaze's strengths line up perfectly with your requirements. The CVT is smoother than the Kylaq's torque converter automatic in stop-and-go traffic, visibility is excellent, the car is easy to place on the road, ingress and egress are straightforward, and Honda's long-term reliability record is hard to fault. Coming from an Alto K10, it will already feel like a substantial upgrade in comfort, refinement and features.The Kylaq Signature Plus AT is the more desirable car from an enthusiast's perspective. The 1.0 TSI turbo petrol has more punch, the higher seating position is nice, and the overall package feels more substantial. However, it is also a larger vehicle to manoeuvre, and while the automatic is good, it is not quite as seamless in everyday traffic as Honda's CVT.Another point in Amaze's favour is that the ZX variant gets Honda Sensing ADAS, which adds useful safety features without making the car complicated to operate. Since your father will also be driving it, that extra layer of safety is a nice bonus.

Honda Amaze

Skoda Kylaq

Anshuman Mishra

•1w

I am planning to buy an automatic car for my family and am confused between the Kia Sonet and the Skoda Kylaq. Could you please advise which one would be the better choice and explain the pros and cons of each?

Autocar India

•6d

Skoda Kylaq is the better family automatic, mainly because it gives you a bit more cabin and boot space and a calmer ride over bad roads. It feels more secure at highway speeds with a full load, and its turbo engine with the automatic pulls cleanly, so hills and quick overtakes are easy even with the AC on. The petrol Kylaq automatic uses a torque convertor gearbox which is also smoother than the dual clutch unit on the Sonet so it would fare better in city traffic. Kia Sonet makes sense if you want more features and need Kia’s service reach which is wider. For weekend trips with four on board it will do the job too, but rear seat width and long-journey comfort are not its strong points and within a year it will get a major update, thus buying it now would not be ideal.

Skoda Kylaq

Kia Sonet

View all Posts

Curated collections

SUVs under ₹20L

73 CARS