Dear Autocar team, I own a 2022 Mahindra XUV300 W4 manual, which has covered around 50,000 km so far. Also, my father owns a manual Maruti Wagon R that was purchased about 1.5 years back. My daily commute is at least 50-70 km, with a mix of city and highway driving. Given the rising running costs and the increasing hassle of driving a manual in heavy traffic, should I continue with the XUV, or replace one of these two cars with an EV? The lower the budget, the better. However, my father needs a car with a high seating position and easy ingress and egress, while my priorities are safety, ride comfort, and suspension quality. Please advise.

autocar.india

•2d

The used EV market is still evolving, and there is no clear pattern at the moment with regard to value. The biggest factor affecting resale value is battery health, so cars with a healthy battery and a clear service history tend to hold value reasonably well. The key is to buy a car that is still within the manufacturer’s battery warranty period, and make sure that the warranty is transferable to the new owner. In terms of problems, electric cars have far fewer moving parts than ICE cars, so there is less to go wrong mechanically. The most common issues tend to be software glitches, infotainment bugs and occasional charging-related niggles. Battery degradation is the biggest long-term concern, but most modern EVs are holding up well, and manufacturers typically offer 8-year battery warranties. As long as the battery health remains within the warranty threshold, you are covered.Service bills are generally lower than ICE cars because there are no oil changes, fewer fluids and fewer wear items. Most service visits are basic checks, software updates and brake inspections. The main costs come from tyres as these can wear out faster thanks to the extra weight and instant torque they have to handle. The big unknown is out-of-warranty battery replacement, which can be expensive, but this is rare within the first 8-10 years if the car is well cared for.With a budget below Rs 20 lakh, however, you can actually opt for a new EV like the Tata Nexon EV, the MG Windsor or even the upcoming Kia Syros EV, and this may be a better option if you cannot find a good used electric vehicle.

Tata Nexon EV

MG Windsor

autocar.india

•2d

Given your requirements, the Hyundai Exter AMT is the best fit. As a senior citizen with city-only driving and low annual kilometres, the Exter offers the right balance of ease of use, comfort and practicality. The higher seating position makes ingress and egress easier, visibility is excellent, and the AMT gearbox is smooth enough for city traffic. The cabin is more spacious than the Swift, especially in terms of headroom and rear seat comfort, and the ride quality is better over broken roads. Compared to the Wagon R, the Exter feels more premium, better built and more refined, while still offering the same ease of use and practicality. The Swift is a good car, but its lower seating position and tighter rear seat make it less suitable for your needs. The Wagon R remains a practical choice, but the Exter is a clear step up in comfort, safety and overall ownership experience. Go for the Exter AMT, and you will have a car that is easy to live with for many years.

Hyundai Exter

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R

Maruti Suzuki Swift

autocar.india

•2d

The Maruti Suzuki Celerio is the best fit for your requirements. It is one of the most fuel-efficient petrol cars in the segment, has a proven ownership track record, and Maruti's service network ensures low maintenance costs over the long term. The 1.0-litre petrol engine is simple, reliable and well-suited to both city use and occasional highway runs. You even have the option of an AMT automatic for greater convenience. If you are open to CNG cars, the Celerio CNG is also worth considering, as it will significantly reduce running costs on your longer trips. The only drawback is that the Celerio is a compact hatchback, so if you regularly carry more passengers or luggage, you may want to look at the Maruti Suzuki Wagon R instead, which offers more space while retaining the same low maintenance and reliability advantages. Overall, the Celerio strikes the best balance between fuel efficiency, reliability and low ownership costs for your usage pattern.

Maruti Suzuki Celerio

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R