I am planning to buy the e-Vitara, as I feel the cost is a bit easier on the pocket when compared to the Creta EV, which is 5 lakh costlier for the same variants. Or should I wait for Sierra EV? What can it cost? What would you suggest among e Vitara, Creta EV and Sierra EV?

autocar.india

•1d

The MG Windsor EV would be our recommendation here. Coming from a Honda City diesel, you're likely looking for a comfortable, spacious and practical family car. Among the EVs you've shortlisted, the Windsor feels like the most complete package. It offers the roomiest cabin, excellent rear-seat comfort and enough space for five adults to travel comfortably. It also feels like a genuine upgrade from a sedan in terms of practicality and everyday usability.The Nexon EV 45 would be our second choice. It is a proven product, offers good performance and range, and is a sensible option if you prefer a more compact SUV. However, it cannot match the Windsor for rear-seat space and overall family-car appeal.The Maruti Suzuki e Vitara is worth considering, but it does have some notable shortcomings. The rear-seat headroom and boot space are limited, the seating position is slightly knees-up, the ride can feel busy and there is more road and tyre noise than we'd like. Given how late it is to the EV market, we expected Maruti to address some of these areas more effectively.The Punch EV continues to offer excellent value, but it is a segment smaller than the others and may not feel like a significant upgrade from your Honda City in terms of space and overall comfort.

MG Windsor

Tata Nexon EV

Tata Punch EV

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Honda City

autocar.india

•2d

Go for the Kia Seltos IVT. With 20 km a day and only a few 200-300 km trips a year, the Seltos keeps life simple on highways and in the city, with wide service support and no charging stops to plan. It also gives you the most rounded mix of space, features and safety from your shortlist, and it feels easy to drive every day.The Seltos is E20 compliant, and material-wise, it should be fine with slightly higher blends. A drop in fuel efficiency, though, is to be expected from higher ethanol content. The honest catch is the running cost. An EV like the Mahindra XEV 9e will be cheaper per km and quieter. If you have a fixed parking spot with a plug at home, the XEV 9e starts to make sense for your short daily runs, but fast-charging on intercity routes can still be hit-or-miss outside big cities. Alternatively, consider the Hyundai Creta Electric.Overall, the Seltos makes the most sense for your usage.

Kia Seltos

Mahindra XEV 9e

Hyundai Creta Electric

autocar.india

•4h

Of your shortlisted options, the Tesla Model Y L seems like the best bet. The Mercedes CLA will require some care over speed breakers, especially on your long drives to your hometown, but the Tesla Model Y L is not as bad. Its wheelbase is long, but it has sufficient ground clearance and can clear most bumps. It also has the most practical cabin of the three, with a third row in case you have more passengers that can be folded away to reveal immense luggage space. It's also packed with tech that will keep the kids occupied, and once you get used to the lack of buttons, it makes for a great overall driving experience. The iX1's range is very good and should serve your needs just fine, but yes, it's not as good as the other two. Another car you should consider is the BYD Sealion 7, which is a great mix of style, functionality, range and luxury. However, overall, we feel the Tesla Model Y L suits you best.

Tesla Model Y

BYD Sealion 7