I currently own a Honda City CVT, which I use for long-distance travel. I am now looking for a secondary car with a budget of under Rs. 10 lakh. The new car will be used mainly for city driving in congested traffic, with a daily commute of around 10 km. I am open to both petrol and electric options. Which compact car would you recommend?

autocar.india

•3h

The Tata Punch EV is the best fit for your requirements. It is one of the most affordable EVs on the market, and the base variants fall comfortably within your budget. It is a practical city car with low running costs, a simple feature set and no unnecessary extras like a sunroof. The Punch EV is easy to drive, compact enough for city use and has a proven track record as an entry-level EV. If you want something even smaller, consider the Tata Tiago EV. It's a hatchback that's better suited to city traffic and will be even more affordable than the Punch EV. Both cars are backed by Tata's strong EV ecosystem and widespread service network, making them sensible long-term ownership choices.

Tata Punch EV

Tata Tiago EV

autocar.india

•1d

An electric car can make sense for your needs if you can charge at home. If yes, the Punch EV 30kWh makes sense for your needs, but you will need to stretch your budget closer to Rs 11 lakh. The Punch has better ground clearance than your current Tiago and takes on bad roads very well. The base Smart trim is very bare-bones, so opt for the Smart+ instead.If you must stick to your Rs 9 lakh budget, then the Tiago EV is the only other option. While it will lower your running costs, you will still need to deal with the low ground clearance. Apart from that, the updated Tiago EV's interior will feel like a step up from your 2023 model. The Pure+ trim has most of the basic features covered, and the 19kWh battery should give you sufficient driving range. Just beware, if your current Tiago scrapes its belly on the rough patch you encounter, so will the Tiago EV. If you can't charge at home, the Punch CNG AMT is your best bet, but you will need to stretch your budget to about Rs 10 lakh. It has a dual-tank setup, so you still have a usable boot, the AMT works reasonably well and will make life easier in traffic, and it has the ground clearance you need.Overall, the Tiago EV is a good fit for your needs if you can charge at home. If not, the Punch CNG AMT is worth stretching for.

Tata Punch EV

Tata Punch

Tata Tiago EV

autocar.india

•1d

Go for the Tata Tiago EV. As a first-time driver with a dedicated home charging spot and heavy city traffic, it is the most sensible choice. The Tiago EV is extremely easy to drive, with smooth, linear acceleration and no gear changes to worry about, which makes stop-start traffic far less stressful. It is also quiet, refined and very cheap to run compared to petrol cars. The range is more than adequate for daily city use, and with home charging, you will never have to worry about fuel stations.The Hyundai Grand i10 Nios and Maruti Suzuki Swift AMT are both reliable and easy to drive, but their AMT gearboxes can feel jerky at low speeds, especially in bumper-to-bumper traffic. The Tiago EV, by comparison, is seamless and far more relaxing to drive in the city. The only real drawback is that long highway trips require more planning, but for your usage pattern, that is not a major concern.If you are open to a slightly higher budget, the Tata Punch EV is also worth considering as it offers a higher seating position and better visibility, which can be reassuring for a new driver. Overall, the Tiago EV is the best fit for your needs.

Tata Tiago EV

Tata Punch EV

Hyundai Grand i10 Nios

Maruti Suzuki Swift