Autocar India
5w

I currently own a 2020 Tata Tiago AMT, which has served me well. Now, I'm looking for a replacement for it, something under 15 lakhs, suitable for 60% city use. I'm not currently looking to switch to EVs, and preferably not a Mahindra or Tata product, since my experience with them has not served me well. So kindly suggest an apt replacement.

Verified
5w

Given your use case and considering your budget of Rs. 15 lakh, you should take a closer look at the Hyundai i20 IVT Asta (O). It is easy to drive in traffic, the CVT automatic is smooth at low speeds, and the steering is light, so city commutes will be far less tiring than in your Tata Tiago. The cabin will feel like a clear step up too: it is quieter, seats are more comfortable, and the car feels more premium overall, which you will notice on your daily runs and the odd weekend drive.

Do note, it is not a tall car, so if your roads have very high speed breakers or you like a high seating view, an SUV may suit you better. If so, take a look at the Hyundai Venue HX6 turbo petrol DCT. Overall, for your city-heavy use, the i20 automatic lines up best.

Hyundai i20

Hyundai i20

Want to sell your car?

Sell your car at the right price, without the stress.

More questions on similar cars

1d

I'm a first-time car buyer looking for an automatic petrol car mainly for city use and occasional long trips. I want modern features like a 360 camera, wireless Android Auto/Apple CarPlay, etc. My budget is Rs. 10-12 lakh, but I can stretch it to Rs. 14 lakh if the car is worth it. I had shortlisted the Hyundai i20 Asta variant, but I heard there will be a facelift soon, and Hyundai may launch the Bayon as well. Is it a good time to buy the current i20, or should I wait for the facelift or even the Bayon? Are there any good alternatives like the Venue or Sonet? I am avoiding Maruti Suzuki because I feel the features offered and safety ratings are poor compared to the competition at the same price. Please advise.

Verified
15h

You can go ahead and buy the Hyundai i20 Asta IVT now. There's no further facelift planned, and the Bayon-based crossover will be positioned much higher and closer to the Hyundai Creta in price. For mostly city use, the i20's smooth, automatic and light controls make traffic a breeze, and it fits your budget better than most compact SUVs would. You still get six airbags, a big screen, a sunroof and all the everyday comforts, and it’s fine for the odd highway run. However, the i20 doesn’t get a 360 camera, and Android Auto/CarPlay aren't wireless unless you buy a special adapter accessory.If a 360 camera is a must and you want the SUV look, the Hyundai Venue SX(O) DCT or Kia Sonet GTX+ have it, but they’ll sit well past Rs 14 lakh on-road in most cities, and their dual-clutch automatics aren’t as smooth as the i20’s CVT in bumper-to-bumper traffic.Another alternative you could consider is the Toyota Urban Cruiser Taisor Turbo Petrol V AT, which gets a punchy but efficient engine, a smooth automatic, and the features you want at around your Rs 14 lakh budget.

VehicleHyundai i20
VehicleHyundai Creta
VehicleHyundai Venue
VehicleKia Sonet
VehicleToyota Urban Cruiser Taisor
1d

Hi Autocar team, I'm replacing my 2017 Maruti Baleno Alpha petrol and would appreciate your recommendations. Location - Currently based in Pune - BH registration planned because there is a reasonable possibility of moving to another state in the future (likely Madhya Pradesh or Bangalore or Delhi) Usage - Primarily city driving (90%+) - Occasional highway trips, sometimes very long (up to 1,000 km) - Usually 2 adults + 1 child - Must comfortably accommodate 4 adults + 1 child when required - Annual running currently under 8,000 km, but could increase significantly because there will be two drivers and an automatic car is likely to be used more Drivers - One experienced driver comfortable with any size car - Second driver is relatively new and gets intimidated by judging the front-left corner and vehicle dimensions - Features such as a rear camera have helped significantly in building confidence Budget - Initially started looking around the Rs. 10 lakh on-road mark - Comfortable spending around Rs.14-16 lakh if the improvement in safety, confidence and ownership experience is clearly noticeable - Looking for the best overall fit rather than trying to maximise budget Priorities (in order) 1. Reliability and hassle-free ownership 2. Safety 3. Easy manoeuvrability and confidence in city traffic What I dislike about my current Baleno - Feels flimsy and dents very easily - Doesn't inspire confidence on highways anymore - Braking confidence is not great Preferences - Automatic transmission is mandatory - Open to petrol, hybrid or EV - Dedicated parking is available, and home charging is possible - Mostly good roads with occasional monsoon-related road damage - I value predictable ownership, service quality and peace of mind more than outright performance Test-drive observations We have driven a few hatchbacks and compact SUVs with automatic transmissions. One thing that became clear is that a commanding seating position and a clearer view of the road ahead significantly increase confidence, especially for the newer driver. However, we are still unsure whether this benefit alone justifies moving up from a hatchback to an SUV. Long-term thinking Initially, I thought a small hatchback would be ideal because I could pass it on to my parents after 3-5 years. However, if a slightly larger vehicle provides substantially better safety, comfort and confidence, I would rather keep it for 5-10 years and buy my parents a separate car later. Question Based on the above requirements, what would be your top 5 recommendations and in what order? More importantly: - Which body style would you choose: premium hatchback, compact SUV, midsize SUV, hybrid SUV or EV? - Which popular models would you eliminate despite their popularity, and why? - How much weight should I give to reliability versus crash safety when choosing a family car that will mostly be driven in the city but occasionally undertake long highway trips? - Am I likely to regret staying with a hatchback, or is moving up a segment the more sensible long-term decision for my use case?

Verified
1d

Given your requirements, a compact SUV would be a good next car for you. The higher seating will put the new driver at ease and will have a great bearing on confidence behind the wheel. Your priority for space, reliability and stress-free ownership leads us to the Maruti Suzuki Brezza AT and Hyundai Venue DCT. The Brezza is a no-nonsense compact SUV with good space, proven reliability and a practical interior. Your comfort and experience with Maruti's aftersales make it the one we'd recommend for you. You'll get a similar hassle-free experience with Hyundai as well. The new Venue ticks the important boxes for you, but it is pricey at the top end, in case the latest features are a must-have. The Venue's turbo-petrol engine does deliver punchier performance than the Brezza, but fuel economy isn't as good. If you want a larger SUV, there's the Honda Elevate CVT. However, the new driver in the family might not feel as comfortable driving it, given its size. If the hatchback form factor suits you, the Hyundai i20 CVT is a very likeable choice. Among EVs, the Punch EV is an option, but your running doesn't really justify going electric. You'd rather spend similar money on a larger or better-equipped petrol-automatic car.

VehicleMaruti Suzuki Brezza
VehicleHyundai Venue
VehicleHonda Elevate
VehicleHyundai i20
VehicleTata Punch EV

Popular discussions right now

Posted on: 19 May 2026