Autocar India

Mahindra XUV500 AT vs Hyundai Creta AT comparison

Is the new XUV500 automatic up to taking on the most popular car in its class, the Hyundai Creta and can it come out ahead?
1 min read•22 Feb '16
Selvin Jose
220K+ views

Creta feels very responsive at slow speeds. Ride and handling is more car-like.

Creta’s cabin quality is good. The bits and pieces used look quite upmarket too; driving position is good thanks to well placed seats and steering wheel adjustment.

Its long seat base all-around is very comfy.

Boot looks larger than its actual capacity.

Touchscreen infotainment not the best around.

Auto ’box works seamlessly.

Rear-AC vents not very effective.

1.6-litre diesel mill is smooth.

XUV feels easy to drive in city. Ride quality is decent. It doesn’t handle well, though

Black and beige theme looks nice. Quality of plastics is only average; minimal steering rake adjust makes it difficult to find ideal position.

Front seats comfy.

Rear seats a bit upright.

No boot space with third-row seats up.

Bluesense infotainment nice to use.

6-speed auto ’box works well.

Headlamps with light guides look nice.

2.2-litre engine has good pulling power.

What’s new?

Automatic cars are in vogue these days. And with more and more buyers warming up to the idea of clutchless comfort, carmakers are going ahead and specifying all their cars with automatic gearboxes. The first SUV maker to identify this niche was Mahindra. The company launched the Scorpio AT back in 2008 but it’s the recently launched XUV500 AT that has got us excited. A few months ago, we drove the XUV500 AT and were quite impressed with it. We liked it so much that we even recommended it over its manual counterpart. But is it good enough to take on what Hyundai calls ‘the perfect SUV’? Is the Creta automatic really that good?

On paper, the XUV dwarfs the Creta with its relatively large size, two additional seats and bigger 2.2-litre diesel motor. The Hyundai, however, is more affordable as it costs Rs 1.57 lakh less. It is more car like and though it comes with a smaller 1.6-litre diesel, real-world performance is unlikely to be down on the XUV. So, which car is better – the XUV500 or the Creta? Does the Mahindra give you more for more or is the Hyundai the better car pound for pound?

Hear from the

Autocar Community

50+Experts
20,000+Members
7,500+Posts

James Bond's Aston Martin DB10 sells for Rs 24 crore

The proceeds from the sale of the DB10 will go to 'Doctors without Borders'.
2 min read•21 Feb '16
Staff Writer

Lamborghini Centenario previewed

The upcoming special-edition Centenario is limited to 40 units, all of which have been sold out.
1 min read•21 Feb '16
Staff Writer

BMW reveals i8 Protonic Red Edition

The limited-edition i8 Protonic Red Edition gets a host of styling upgrades; production to start in July.
1 min read•21 Feb '16
Staff Writer

Renault India to start exports of Kwid

The Kwid hatchback will first be exported to Sri Lanka via the CBU route; Brazil, Latin America and Africa markets to get the model later as CKD units.
2 min read•21 Feb '16
Staff Writer

BMW i8 becomes world’s largest-selling hybrid sportscar

Following the success of the i8, BMW will unveil limited-run editions of the sportscar; BMW i8 Protonic Red Edition to be the first model.
2 min read•20 Feb '16
Staff Writer

Still have more question?

Get answers from Autocar experts and owners


  • 9,000+discussions
  • 20,000+users online
  • 10,000+members

Poll of the month

Which upcoming locally-made bike at EICMA 2026 are you looking forward to the most?

RE Himalayan & Continental GT 750
BMW F 450 R & F 450 RR
Norton 450 Urban
Hero Xpulse 450
Harley-Davidson X350 T
88 votes•32 days remaining

Upcoming Cars

Jeep SUV
Jeep SUV

₹15.00 - ₹20.00 Lakhs

Nissan Terrano
Nissan Terrano

₹40.00 - ₹45.00 Lakhs

Honda Compact SUV
Honda Compact SUV

₹8.50 - ₹13.50 Lakhs

Toyota Land Cruiser FJ
Toyota Land Cruiser FJ

₹30.00 - ₹35.00 Lakhs

Jeep Gladiator
Jeep Gladiator

₹68.00 - ₹70.00 Lakhs

Trending Cars