autocar-logo
Delhi

Opinion: Does the Indian car industry need more local competition?

Strong local competition will foster the biggest steps forward for the India auto industry.
2 min read6 Jul '25
Shapur KotwalShapur Kotwal
13K+ views
Indian car industry needs more local competition

Indian engineering, design and technology are fast ramping up, getting better every day. This wasn’t always the case. A sea change from what earlier started out as just proficiency in software slowly evolving into competency in control systems and, finally, computer-aided design, Indian engineering today has come a long way. And let’s not forget, we probably produce the most engineers globally today: 1.5 million a year, if the numbers are right. Now, yes, not all these engineers are top drawer, and the best candidates get on a flight soon after they graduate. Still, what you can’t deny is that the giant wheel of Indian engineering has started to turn; slowly at first, but increasingly faster now. 

Look around and you see the proof of this everywhere. From giant construction and infrastructure projects to space, defence, aero and, of course, the automobile industry. Think of Chandrayaan, the success of ISRO’s launch platforms, the fact that today we can build globally competitive stealth destroyers, aircraft carriers, light and heavy tanks, attack helicopters, fourth-generation combat jets and, importantly, many of the defensive and offensive missile systems used on these platforms. Sure, there are gaps in our capabilities, big ones, but there are also areas where we are further up the road than expected. Cue the Akash surface-to-air system, our integrated air defence system, or the BrahMos supersonic missiles we have engineered with Russia.

What you will also have noticed with our homegrown auto industry is an ever-increasing ability to get to grips with cutting-edge tech. Mahindra and Tata are already operating at a level that would have been scarcely believable only a decade or so ago. And from what we are seeing, this is only the beginning. Also, for once, it seems like we could do in 10 years what took China 20. Wouldn’t that be nuts?

However, what we are lacking is sufficient local competition. This is something that has proven essential in markets around the world. Strong local competition fosters the biggest steps forward, the greatest advances. Look at the local Chinese car industry; there are at least a dozen carmakers falling over each other to get to local customers.

And tough local competition has proven to be essential in places like Germany, the US and Japan. Even ‘communist’ Russia and China understand this and have multiple design bureaus fighting it out among themselves in their defence industries. This is something Indian authorities are finally doing today as well; they are in the process of creating competition for monoliths like ISRO, HAL, DRDO and others with the inclusion of private players. So yeah, to aid progress, we need more local players to give the Tatas and Mahindras a run for their money. After all, local competition has already started to heat up in the two-wheeler space, with the likes of Ola, Ather and Ultraviolette. Isn’t it time the car industry in India caught up?

Opinion: Do Indians like cars that have the 'family look'

While brands like Hyundai and Volkswagen tend to carry a family look across their portfolio, Maruti and Mahindra seem to avoid it completely.
2 min read29 Jun '25
Avik ChattopadhyayAvik Chattopadhyay
Hyundai Venue and Tucson have a family look while Mahindra XUV 3XO and XUV700 do not

Opinion: Three must dos for Nissan's rebirth in India

Nissan needs to treat its future plans as a re-entry and not a new phase.
2 min read21 Jun '25
Sergius BarrettoSergius Barretto
Nissan rebirth in India

Opinion: KTM will change after the Bajaj takeover

Now that we know KTM has been saved, the question is what its future identity will be.
2 min read8 Jun '25
Rishaad ModyRishaad Mody
Bajaj logo on Pedro Acosta KTM MotoGP bike

Opinion: Popular features are not necessarily must-haves

Getting the features package right is the biggest challenge for product planning teams.
2 min read25 May '25
Avik ChattopadhyayAvik Chattopadhyay
Sunroof ADAS and large touchscreens

Opinion: The real connected cars

Why cars today struggle to deliver a real ‘connected’ driving experience.
2 min read18 May '25
Shapur KotwalShapur Kotwal
Connected, feelsome and Fun to drive cars Shapur blog