I am using a 2020 BS6 Ciaz Delta manual petrol, and the odometer currently reads 83,000km. We are a family of three and are looking to upgrade to a spacious 7-seater. While my sedan is in excellent condition with no major breakdowns or accidents, I am concerned about the build quality. We plan to travel more frequently by road, so a good automatic 7-seater with a strong crash-test rating and decent fuel efficiency would help. My budget is Rs 15 lakh. Please suggest.

autocar.india

•57m

The best 7-seater for your budget is the Mahindra XUV 7XO, and you can comfortably get a mid variant (AX5) with an automatic within Rs 25-27 lakh on-road in most cities. The 7XO diesel is the pick of the range, offering strong performance, good refinement and sensible economy, and it probably has the best blend of performance, ride, handling and overall comfort in this segment. Its main weakness is the third row, which isn’t very spacious or comfortable for adults on long journeys, so it works better as an occasional-use or kids’ third row.If the third row is critical for you and will be used regularly by adults, the Tata Safari is worth considering, because its third row is more genuinely usable and comfortable. The Safari’s 2.0 diesel is quite outdated, but the newer 1.5 turbo petrol is smooth, refined and reasonably efficient for a petrol in this class.If you’d prefer something smaller and more city-friendly, the Kia Carens Clavis is also a good option, with a more compact footprint and easy manners in traffic, while still giving you three rows of seats for family use. It won’t match the 7XO for highway presence or outright performance, but for urban-heavy usage, it makes a lot of sense.

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Tata Safari

Kia Carens Clavis

autocar.india

•1d

The Kia Carens Clavis Petrol Automatic would be our recommendation. While your family consists of four members, you've specifically mentioned that your parents or in-laws do join you on trips from time to time, which means a genuinely usable third row is important. The Carens Clavis offers the best balance of space, comfort and practicality for seven occupants, while also being easy to drive and comfortable on the 400-600km trips you undertake every couple of months. With an annual running of around 8,000km, we would also avoid the diesel. Although your highway trips should help keep DPF-related issues at bay, the fuel savings are unlikely to justify the higher purchase price and complexity of a modern diesel. Given your knee discomfort, an automatic is definitely worth choosing over a manual and will make day-to-day driving far more relaxing.As for the Carens petrol's fuel efficiency, it is true that some owners report lower-than-expected figures, particularly in heavy city traffic. However, with your relatively modest annual running, we wouldn't let mileage become the deciding factor. The difference in fuel costs between the Carens petrol automatic and a more efficient alternative is unlikely to be substantial enough to outweigh the benefits of the Kia's superior space, comfort and practicality.The Ertiga Automatic remains a sensible option if value, fuel efficiency and ease of ownership are your priorities, but its safety credentials continue to be a concern. The Victoris feels more premium and offers greater comfort on long journeys, but if you genuinely expect to travel with six or seven people, the Carens Clavis is simply the more practical vehicle.

Kia Carens Clavis

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

autocar.india

•2d

Without knowing your budget, it's hard to know what to recommend, but strictly speaking, for your family of six, the best car around is the Toyota Innova Hycross Hybrid. It's the most spacious car this side of Rs. 50 lakh and comes with one of the most efficient hybrid powertrains. The interior is flexible, so you can reconfigure it to suit your specific needs, and being an MPV, getting in and out will not be too difficult for your parents further down the line. It's a Toyota, so reliability is a given, and maintenance costs are reasonable too. In the city, the hybrid powertrain will run mostly on electric power, giving you a refined and relaxing experience, and on the highway, there's enough punch, even with a full load of passengers. If this is outside your budget, however, consider the Kia Carens Clavis, which offers a great mix of features, space and flexibility for the money. Plus, with a wide choice of engines and gearboxes, you should find something that suits you.

Toyota Innova HyCross

Kia Carens Clavis