Would you guys recommend the new Punch EV? If so, what are the positives and negatives, and what are the alternatives to this car in a ₹13 to ₹15 lakh budget? It has to be an EV.

Autocar India

•3d

Pick the Tata Punch EV with the 40 kWh battery as your first choice. For your usage, mostly city driving in Kochi with occasional Coimbatore trips, it fits almost perfectly.The biggest advantage is how effortless and cost-effective it is to run in the city. It is smooth, silent and requires very little maintenance compared to petrol cars, which suits your usage pattern. With the larger 40 kWh battery, it offers a real-world range that is more than enough for your daily use and can comfortably handle the Kochi to Coimbatore run with planning, without range anxiety.It also comes with modern connected features and a good infotainment setup, so you are covered on the tech side as well, which you specifically wanted.If you are not fully convinced about going electric, then as a petrol alternative, you can look at the Skoda Kylaq automatic in the Signature variant. It offers a strong engine, a more engaging drive and a proper automatic experience, making it a good fallback if charging setup is a concern.

Tata Punch EV

Skoda Kylaq

Autocar India

•46m

Given your usage, an EV makes strong sense, and the Hyundai Creta Electric is a great fit. In our real-world test, the long-range 51kWh battery managed a combined 432km, which almost covers your monthly usage, so you would only need to plug in at home every couple of weeks. In city traffic, it is very smooth and quiet, with a strong pull at low speeds, so gaps are easy and you won’t feel gear shifts. Over 10 years, the simpler EV hardware means fewer routine services, and you are less exposed to fuel price swings. Most electric cars also come with a long battery warranty, which helps give peace of mind.A few trade-offs to keep in mind. At 500 km a month, the money you save on running will add up slowly, so buy it mainly for the smooth drive and ease of use. For the rare long trip, you will need to plan charging stops, but the Creta Electric can charge at up to 100kW, which makes quick top-ups easy.If you want a bit more space, the Kia Carens Clavis EV is a solid alternative in your range. Overall, for your city-heavy routine with home charging, the Creta Electric lines up best.

Hyundai Creta Electric

Kia Carens Clavis EV

Autocar India

•1h

Given six days of city runs, one highway day every week and a long trip every few months, we would pick the Kia Carens diesel for you, ideally with the automatic if the budget allows. Your pattern includes regular, steady highway driving, which is exactly what a diesel’s DPF needs to stay unclogged. You are coming from a Ciaz diesel with high mileage, so the diesel’s strong pull and lower day-to-day fuel use will feel natural and easy for you when the car is full.Here is why diesel suits your use. That weekly 150 km highway stretch gives the exhaust system enough hot, steady running to burn off soot, so the usual city-only DPF worry is much lower in your case. The 1.5 diesel also pulls well at low speeds and on inclines, so with family and luggage, it will feel calmer than the petrol. Your monthly distance is high enough that the fuel savings will add up over time.A couple of trade-offs to keep in mind. The diesel costs more to buy and is a bit louder at idle than the petrol. If your routine changes to only short stop-start hops with no weekly highway, you may need to do an extra 20-30-minute steady-speed drive to keep the DPF happy. If a DPF light shows, keep driving a bit until it clears rather than switching off.If you still want zero DPF worry, the petrol is the safer bet. The standard petrol is smooth and easy in the city; the turbo petrol feels stronger but can use more fuel in heavy traffic and its twin-clutch auto can feel jerky when moving very slowly.

Kia Carens