Autocar India
Posted inEVs & Hybrids
•1d

I am planning to buy the Tata Punch EV, but I have heard about many issues and problems with the car. Is that true? Should I avoid buying it because of these concerns?

10
Verified
•4m

The Tata Punch EV is a genuinely good product and one of the most affordable ways to get into a practical, well-sized electric car. It offers a comfortable ride and a very usable range for city use. However, Tata Motors has had a mixed track record when it comes to niggles and minor quality issues, and the Punch EV has not been completely immune to that. Most of the issues reported are relatively minor and not deal-breakers, but they can be frustrating over time. Frankly, there is no equivalent option in the same price range. Hence, the Punch EV is the best option for your money , but go in with realistic expectations and make sure you have a good service centre nearby. 

More posts on similar cars

•1d

Following my previous question about replacing my 2019 Tata Hexa, which has covered 1.30 lakh km, with a new SUV or MPV within a budget of Rs 35 lakh and for a daily commute of around 90 km, we had finalised between the Scorpio N and the XUV 7XO, and had found the Scorpio more familiar than the Hexa. Now I am confused about which variant of the Scorpio N to go for: the Z8T or Z8L. The Z8L has ADAS, which isn't much use for my family and me, so is the Z8T the right choice? Although we are not in a rush and can wait another year, are there any upcoming vehicles with the same RWD diesel-manual DNA that are worth waiting for?

70
Verified
•59m

Go for the Mahindra Scorpio N Z8T diesel manual. It is the right choice for your usage and budget. The Z8L's main differentiator is ADAS, which you have already identified as something you do not need. The Z8T gives you the same core mechanical package, the same strong diesel engine, and the same RWD and body-on-frame DNA that you liked in the Hexa, without paying extra for features you will not use. The Scorpio N is also one of the few cars in this price range that still offers a proper RWD diesel manual setup, which is exactly what you are looking for.On the question of waiting, there is no clear reason to hold off. There are no major RWD diesel manual SUVs or MPVs expected in the next year that would fundamentally change your decision. This Mahindra car is already a well-established product with a proven ownership track record, and it is one of the few cars that still offers this kind of mechanical package.The only thing to keep in mind is that the Scorpio N is a body-on-frame SUV, so it will not be as refined or as comfortable as the Hexa on long highway runs and bumpy roads as the ride is quite bouncy. But if you are looking for a tough, reliable RWD diesel manual with a strong ownership track record, the Z8T is the right choice.

•6h

I am purchasing a Creta petrol automatic S (Optional) model. How is this car in terms of fuel efficiency and long-term ownership? How will it perform on occasional long trips of 500- 700 km and routine city commuting?

193
Verified
•3h

The Hyundai Creta petrol automatic is a very sensible choice for your usage pattern. The 1.5-litre naturally aspirated petrol engine paired with the IVT (CVT) automatic is smooth, refined and well-suited to city driving, making daily commutes effortless. For occasional long trips of 500-700 km, the Creta is comfortable, stable and easy to drive, with a relaxed cruising nature and a well-sorted ride. Fuel efficiency is decent for a midsize petrol automatic SUV, with our testing recording 13.11 kpl overall, with 15.05kpl on the highway and significantly lower figures in heavy city traffic. A realistic expectation would be around 10-12kpl in the city and 13-15kpl on the highway, depending on driving style and conditions. In terms of long-term ownership, Hyundai’s strong service network, reasonable maintenance costs, and proven reliability make the Creta a safe bet. The S (O) variant strikes a good balance between essential features and value, and the overall package is well-rounded. The only thing to keep in mind is that this Hyundai car is due for a full generation change in 2027, so if you are not in a hurry, it may be worth waiting. Otherwise, it remains one of the most dependable and hassle-free choices in the segment.

Popular discussions right now

Explore more posts in topics

Upcoming launch buzz

Community discussions on upcoming launches

Find related posts in one place

Explore topics to stay in the loop

Posted on: 3 Oct 2026