We have a Hyundai Grand i10 manual purchased in 2017, which my son currently drives. We now want to purchase an AMT car and are considering the Hyundai Exter, Maruti Suzuki Baleno, or any other option you may advise. Body strength, safety, and a comfortable AMT are our key priorities.

Autocar India

•1d

For your requirement, check out the Tata Punch. It sits higher than the Dzire, the doors open wide, and the seat base is set at a nice hip height, so you don’t drop down into it or climb up too much. It also feels tougher over bad roads than your Wagon R, yet is still short and easy to park, which helps in tight city spots. The best part is that the Punch is available in a wide variety of flavours, and since you haven't specified a budget, there's bound to be something for you. There are many variants to choose from, as well as petrol, turbo petrol, CNG, manual gearbox, AMT and even an electric version, in case that suits you.Two things to note: the base petrol engine (or its CNG counterpart) isn’t very quick for fast highway runs, and the automatic can feel a little jerky when moving slowly; the manual is smoother in traffic. If you want the same easy cabin access but a smoother engine and gearbox, look at the Hyundai Exter mid trim. It also has a tall seat and the city-friendly size, but there isn't as much choice or variety as in the Tata car.Overall, for your “high seat, easy entry” need, the Punch fits best without jumping to a much bigger, costlier car.

Tata Punch

Maruti Suzuki Dzire

Hyundai Exter

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R

Autocar India

•1d

For mostly city use and a sub-Rs 10 lakh budget with CNG in mind, we suggest switching your booking to the Hyundai Exter CNG (the factory CNG variant). It fits your plan far better than a Venue 1.2 with an aftermarket CNG.The Hyundai Venue 1.2 is fine for calm city driving on petrol, but it will feel weak with a full load or the AC on. Adding a CNG kit will make it slower and could void most of the warranty. The Exter CNG comes ready from the factory, so the warranty stays, the tuning is safe, and in the city, it moves easily because the car is smaller and lighter. Fuel costs drop a lot without you having to worry about the kit.On the same Rs 10-lakh budget, you may even get a few more features in the Hyundai Exter. If you want a tougher look and a bit more cabin height, the Tata Punch i-CNG is a strong city alternative at this price. Overall, for your use, the Exter CNG is the safer, low-risk pick.

Hyundai Exter

Hyundai Venue

Tata Punch

Autocar India

•9h

We would suggest the Honda Amaze CVT as the primary pick. Since you already have a large SUV, this second car’s job is to be an easy, fuss-free city runabout, and the Amaze fits that brief really well. It gives you a proper automatic rather than an AMT, so smoothness in stop-and-go traffic is far better, and the latest Amaze has a 5-star Bharat NCAP safety rating, making it a strong fit given your safety priority.If you would prefer something hatchback or compact SUV-like, the Tata Punch AMT is worth considering, but the gearbox simply is not as smooth or polished as the Honda’s CVT.If you are open to electric cars and have reliable home charging, a Tiago EV is actually a very smart fit for this exact use case because your usage is overwhelmingly city based. That said, if you are specifically considering the Tiago EV, we would suggest waiting a little, as an update is expected and could bring better range value.

Honda Amaze

Tata Punch

Tata Tiago EV