Renault Scala Automatic review, test drive
10th Jan 2013 10:50 pm
Our first impressions of the Renault Scala Automatic.
Ever since its launch, the badge-engineered Renault Scala has made a decent impression in the market as a more attractive alternative to its cousin, the Nissan Sunny. However, its optimistic pricing hasn’t allowed Renault to unlock the Scala’s full potential. Renault hasn’t been sitting idle and is in the process of launching the Scala with an automatic version. But is the auto ’box good enough to handle the busy and crowded roads around India?
Initial impressions are good. The Nissan engine is quite responsive and the gearbox feels really well suited to urban stop-start driving. This complements the light steering quite nicely, making the Scala effortless to drive in traffic. The way the car drives has a lot to do with the new high-tech CVT automatic gearbox used on this car. Renault’s partner Nissan is one of the few companies that continued to pursue the Continuously Variable Transmissions technology, and this investment is now beginning to bear fruit. The X-tronic CVT featured on this car is a much improved version of the regular CVT box and it comes with a steel belt for greater durability and less of a rubberband effect.
The Scala, as a result, is happy to amble around at city speeds, the gearbox keeping the engine in the 1000-1500rpm band if you only use part-throttle. There’s more performance on tap if you use more throttle, but this is accompanied by an increase in engine speed and engine noise. However, this is useful when you need to overtake, the increase in pace somewhat linear with the rise in revs. Using maximum throttle is a bit pointless though. The engine becomes really noisy and strained and flat-out performance isn’t all that great anyway.
Where the CVT pays you back is in the area of efficiency. It keeps engine rpm down in the more efficient part of the power-band and every time you lift off the throttle, the engine gets ‘disconnected’ from the gearbox, reducing mechanical drag. The French carmaker claims that the Scala auto delivers an ARAI-tested 17.97kpl, which is a shade more than the Ford Fiesta’s DCT auto variant, which gives 16.97kpl (ARAI-tested).
Otherwise, the Scala automatic is very similar to the manual gearbox equipped version. You get plenty of space on the inside, a comfortable but slightly bouncy ride and a massive boot. The design of the interiors is a bit too similar to that of the Nissan Sunny and the Scala automatic isn’t really a car that you can enjoy driving fast. But if you are looking for a practical, fuss-free car for everyday commute, this Renault gives you a lot of car for the money.
Renault has initially only launched the Scala petrol with an auto ’box. It will be sold in RXL and RXZ trims and will come with a four-year warranty.
Renault Scala Petrol CVT RXL: Rs 8.99 lakh
Renault Scala Petrol CVT RXZ: Rs 9.89 lakh
Ford Fiesta AT Style: Rs 9.23 lakh
Ford Fiesta AT Titanium: 9.96 lakh
Honda City V AT: Rs 9.75 lakh
All prices ex-showroom, Delhi