I am confused between the XEV 9S and Harrier EV base models. Which one will be better for both city and highway driving?

autocar.india

•6h

With your 170km daily commute, including 80km on the expressway, the Tomahawk EV is a very strong fit. The 69.2kWh battery gives it a claimed 517km range, while our first drive review found it delivered 4.85km/kWh in a fast highway run, translating to around 336km of real-world range. That gives you a useful buffer for your daily commute.For your requirement of a comfortable 7-seater, the Tomahawk also has a spacious second row with excellent legroom, reclining seats and good third-row access. The third row is usable for adults on shorter journeys, although boot space with all three rows up is limited.The XEV 9S Pack Two Above 70 is the more sophisticated and performance-oriented option, but the Tomahawk's strengths are better aligned with your priorities: comfort, space and easy highway cruising. Our first drive also found it surprisingly easy to drive despite its size, with excellent visibility and light steering.The only concern is that the Tomahawk is a new EV, so there is no established 8–10 year ownership track record yet. An extended warranty would therefore be worth considering.

MG Hector Tomahawk EV

Mahindra XEV 9S

autocar.india

•1d

Given your usage and priorities, the Mahindra XEV 9S seems like the best fit. This Mahindra car’s biggest strength is its ride comfort over broken roads and potholes, which is exactly what you're looking for. The second row is genuinely spacious, with a wide bench and good legroom, so your son will be comfortable as he grows. The car is very easy to manoeuvre in the city, and the electric powertrain will ensure smooth and quiet performance, and with home charging, your running costs will be very low.It is a genuine comfortable 5-seater, and it gives you the flexibility of a third row. When the third row is folded down, it also has enough boot space for family luggage. The car is fundamentally comfortable but is also gadget-heavy, with plenty of screens and features on offer, something that you're against. Still, we'd recommend you consider it, as it is genuinely a well-rounded option.

Mahindra XEV 9S

autocar.india

•3d

The claimed range figures are based on the official MIDC test cycle, which is a laboratory test and not a real-world figure. The Mahindra XEV 9S and MG Hector Tomahawk EV are very different cars. The 9S is a more aerodynamic, lower-slung SUV, while the Hector Tomahawk EV is a larger, heavier SUV with a more upright body. Aerodynamics and weight play a huge role in efficiency, especially at higher speeds. So even though the MG has a bigger battery, it is also likely to be less efficient, which is why the claimed range is similar.In the real world, you should expect both cars to deliver significantly lower range than the claimed figures. The 9S will likely be the more efficient car, but the difference will not be as dramatic as the MIDC numbers suggest. The MG's larger battery will give it a slightly higher usable range, but it will also consume more energy per kilometre. Ultimately, the choice should be based on the car that best suits your needs rather than the claimed range figures.

Mahindra XEV 9S

MG Hector Tomahawk EV