I need advice on choosing between the MG Windsor EV and the Tata Curvv EV. Given the ongoing discounts, the Curvv EV variants are now priced similarly to the Windsor EV. My daily usage is mostly in the city, covering around 60-80 km, along with frequent weekend highway drives. While the Windsor EV offers better rear seat space, my primary concerns are safety and ride comfort, especially since I will be travelling with a small child. I would also like to understand how useful ADAS features are on Indian roads. Do they genuinely improve safety, or can they become a hassle, such as sudden braking, particularly in heavy bumper-to-bumper traffic during daily commutes? Which of these two EVs would be the better choice for my needs?

Autocar India

•1d

The MG Windsor EV’s ride is indeed on the firmer side, and that’s something we’ve pointed out in our review as well. On broken roads and sharp bumps, it doesn’t feel very plush, but at higher speeds, it settles down and is quite stable. The air-conditioning isn’t the strongest in the class, yet in normal use, it does the job and is not a major weakness.Given the price, space and long list of features the Windsor offers, there’s very little that matches it for sheer value, so these compromises are something most buyers can live with.However, if you don’t really need that much space and mostly drive yourself, the Maruti Suzuki e Vitara is worth considering. It has a more comfortable ride, better overall refinement and an efficient air-con system, which will matter on long highway runs and in hot weather.

MG Windsor

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara

Autocar India

•51m

Go for the Mahindra XUV 7XO AX5 diesel 7-seater. With your Rs 22 lakh budget and a monthly run of 1,000-1,500 km, it is a more complete upgrade from your Duster. The diesel engine is strong, refined and feels effortless both in the city and on the highway, making long trips relaxed and overtaking easy. With the updates, the ride quality has also improved, now feeling more plush and comfortable, even compared to the Tata Safari. Overall, it is the more modern, easier and more well-rounded SUV to live with.One thing to be aware of: the third row in the 7XO is best suited for occasional use, as space and boot capacity with all seats up are limited. This is where the Safari still has an advantage, offering a more accommodating third row with better space and support for longer journeys.In terms of cabin quality, however, the Safari does not have a clear advantage. The 7XO feels just as premium, if not more modern, with better technology and overall fit and finish, so the decision really comes down to whether you prioritise third-row comfort or a more effortless driving experience.

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Tata Safari

Autocar India

•3h

Go for the Tata Safari Petrol Accomplished X+. For your 70 percent highway usage, it is the more rounded choice when it comes to ride comfort, safety and high-speed stability. The Safari feels more planted at expressway speeds, deals with broken roads with greater composure, and overall gives you a stronger sense of confidence on long journeys. It also benefits from proven crash safety credentials, which adds to its appeal as a family SUV.In comparison, the Kia Carens Clavis GTX+ is easier to drive and more practical, especially if you regularly use all three rows. Its lighter controls, smoother low-speed behaviour and more usable third row make it better suited to mixed city use and carrying more passengers. However, it does not feel as solid or as planted as the Safari at higher speeds, particularly on uneven highways or in crosswinds.If your driving is largely highway-focused and you value stability and reassurance over outright practicality, the Safari petrol is the better fit. The Carens makes more sense if you prioritise space and everyday ease, but for your usage, the Safari is the stronger long-distance companion.

Tata Safari