Bongaigaon

•7w

Hi Autocar Team, I wanted your guidance on whether I should buy the new Lexus ES 350h Hybrid or wait for the upcoming BMW i5 LWB. My concern with the BMW i5 LWB is that it is likely to be one of the last models based on BMW's current platform, with the Neue Klasse-based i5 expected to arrive in the near future. Given how quickly EV technology is evolving, I am worried that it could become outdated relatively soon. On the other hand, the Lexus ES 350h is based on Toyota's sixth-generation hybrid technology, which makes me feel it may remain relevant for longer within its segment. That said, the idea of switching to an EV is also very exciting, so I am finding it difficult to decide. Which one would you recommend?

•6w

The new i5 LWB is expected to be a thorough revision of the current model based on the CLAR platform, with Neue Klasse-inspired styling and perhaps battery and motor updates, rather than an outright shift to the Neue Klasse platform of the i3. This is similar to what was done with the BMW i7, which also shares the CLAR platform, as both are only halfway through their life cycles. Besides, that is still some time away, and the only i5 you can buy now is the sporty (and low-slung) M60. You're right about rapidly advancing EV tech, but whether you choose today's i5 or the incoming LCI or LWB, you'll still have a luxurious, comfortable, refined and powerful EV.

As for the Lexus, if you're choosing the hybrid, know that it is about half the price of what the i5 LWB will likely cost. There is also the ES Electric, which is closer in price and concept to the i5. Either way, the ES seems like the better choice for you if you plan to purchase today, since as you mentioned, it is presently the more contemporary option. That said, depending on which camp you fall into, a hybrid may already be behind in terms of relevance compared to any EV, so it really comes down to the nature of your usage. For now, in India, pound for pound, a hybrid makes more sense than an EV, so if you're keen on the new ES hybrid, you should go for it.

Explore cars mentioned

BMW

i5 LWB

from ₹84.78 Lakh

BMW

from ₹2.08 Crore

Lexus

ES Electric

from ₹97.13 Lakh

•1w•

@krishna.50 Go with BMW i5 LWB 👍

More posts on similar cars

•22h

I am confused between the Maruti Suzuki Brezza VXI AT and Kia Sonet HTK(O) Turbo DCT. My monthly running is around 1,300-1,500 km, mostly in city traffic, with occasional trips. The Sonet offers more features and feels more premium, while the Brezza seems more reliable and fuel-efficient. Which one should I opt for?

•2h

Go for the Maruti Suzuki Brezza VXI AT. With your running of 1,300-1,500 km a month, mostly in city traffic, the Brezza’s naturally aspirated petrol engine paired with the 6-speed torque converter automatic is the better fit. It is smoother in stop-start conditions, easier to live with and more forgiving over long-term ownership. Maruti’s service network and lower maintenance costs also make it the more sensible choice for a long-term city car.The Kia Sonet HTK(O) Turbo DCT does feel more premium inside and offers more features, but the DCT gearbox is not as well suited to heavy city traffic. The Brezza may not feel as feature-rich, but it is the more dependable and cost-effective option for your usage pattern.

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

Kia Sonet

•11h

In this tight city, with bulky SUVs everywhere and the E20 era, I’m considering the Punch AMT and Altroz DCA petrol for a beginner with a 70:30 city-highway usage split. The Altroz has the advantage of a better automatic transmission and great looks, but I’m not sure how beginner-friendly it would be in city traffic. The Punch offers better visibility and ground clearance, but I’m concerned about the AMT being jerky, as many reviews mention. I’m also unsure about the real-world fuel efficiency of both.

•7h

Go for the Tata Altroz DCA petrol. The DCA is a proper dual-clutch automatic and is far smoother and more responsive than the Punch’s AMT, which feels jerky at low speeds. The Altroz is also a more refined car overall, with a better driving experience on highways and a more premium feel inside.What's more, the Altroz' cabin is more spacious, and even though you're seated lower than in the Punch, visibility is good, and it is still very user-friendly. In real-world conditions, both cars will return similar fuel efficiency figures, with the Altroz having a slight edge on the highway thanks to its more efficient gearbox.

Tata Altroz

Tata Punch

•9h

The new Sierra looks much more distinctive than most SUVs in this segment, but looks aside, I'm curious about everyday practicality. Between Sierra and Creta, which one would make more sense for a family doing mostly city driving with occasional highway trips?

View all Posts

Expert reviews worth reading

BMWi7

Read expert review

Popular discussions right now

•5d

I am confused between the Elevate and the Creta. I understand that the Creta is the more established one, but with Honda, the value it brings is amazing, while the price of the Creta is a bit higher than the value it offers. I am mostly a city driver, with around 95% of my driving in the city and occasional highway trips, covering around 10,000km per year. Can you help me get some perspective?

•3d

The Hyundai Creta is the more premium product with a richer feature list. Since your usage is mainly in the city, you are likely to appreciate the Creta's smoothness and refinement, as well as the additional features it offers. Sure, this Hyundai car might cost a bit more, but it is a proven product that commands strong brand equity, which is likely to translate to higher resale value. The Honda Elevate gives you most of what you need at a significantly lower cost, and Honda’s service network is strong enough to make ownership hassle-free. Go for the Elevate if you value its stronger engine performance, else for a refined drive experience, pick the Creta.

Hyundai Creta

Honda Elevate

•4d

Help me choose the right car for my usage. Please be practical and challenge my assumptions. My situation: I am 31 and work as a software developer. I currently work from home in Balsane, Dhule, but I am moving to Mumbai around March. My wife and I are expecting a baby in February. My parents live in a village where local transport is poor. My Mumbai office is near Powai, but parking is difficult. I prefer a manual car. Usage: My current running is around 10,000 km per year, but it may increase. I travel between Mumbai and Balsane, which is around 400 km one way, around 5-7 times a year, along with Dhule/Sakri and local trips. I also drive around Mumbai on weekends. The AC is usually on, and on long trips, the car will have my wife, baby, and luggage. Budget: Rs. 6-9 lakh on-road. I am willing to spend more only if it is genuinely worth it. Shortlist: - Tiago XE Petrol - Punch Pure+/Smart Petrol - Punch Pure+/Smart CNG - Brezza LXi turbo-petrol Please tell me: 1. Which one should I buy and why? 2. Petrol vs CNG for my usage? The CNG premium is around Rs. 1 lakh, and the nearby village pump may open around Diwali, but this is not guaranteed. 3. What real-world mileage can I expect with the AC on? 4. Please consider loan interest, fuel costs, maintenance, depreciation, and resale value. 5. Is the Brezza worth the extra money? 6. Give me one final choice and tell me what I should avoid.

•4d

The Brezza LXI Turbo is far superior to the Punch and Tiago as far as smoothness, performance, and cabin space are concerned. It is also backed by Maruti's widespread support network, and the ownership experience is likely to be fuss-free. The on-road cost of the Brezza LXI will fall within your Rs 9 lakh budget, and even though you might miss a few features, it still feels worth opting for. Alternatively, you could also consider the Maruti Dzire VXI MT for its large boot, comfy ride and strong fuel efficiency.

I am planning to buy a new SUV under Rs 30 lakh and am open to both five- and seven-seater options. I have tried the Toyota Innova HyCross non-hybrid, Mahindra XUV 7XO, Hyundai Alcazar, Kia Seltos and Renault Duster, but I am confused about which one to choose. My main priorities are space, comfort and a good engine. My running is not very high, at just under 1,000km a month. Please advise.

•4d

Go for the Toyota Innova HyCross non-hybrid. Your priorities are space, comfort and a good engine, and the HyCross delivers on all three. It is one of the most spacious cars in the segment, with a genuinely usable third row and a comfortable ride that makes it an excellent family car. The petrol engine is smooth, refined and well suited to your running of under 1,000 km a month, where the hybrid premium is harder to justify.The Mahindra XUV 7XO is a strong alternative with a more powerful engine and a more feature-rich cabin, but the HyCross has the edge on space, comfort and long-term ownership experience.The Hyundai Alcazar and Kia Seltos are good cars, but they do not offer the same level of space or comfort, and the Renault Duster is more of a driver's car than a family car. The Toyota car mentioned above is the car you will be happiest with after five years of ownership.

Toyota Innova HyCross

View all Posts