I am planning to buy my first car with an on-road budget of around ₹12 lakh. I work as a seafarer and will be away for 6-7 months at a stretch, during which the car’s usage will be very low. My driving pattern will be around 70% city and 30% highway. I am currently considering the Skoda Kylaq, Nissan Magnite, and Maruti Brezza, all in automatic variants. Could you please suggest which would be the best option for my needs?

Autocar India

•1d

Pick the Mahindra XUV 3XO MPFi petrol automatic. Its torque-converter automatic gearbox is the most robust for your mostly city use with smooth crawling and far lower risk of costly clutch wear than a dual-clutch. While efficiency will not be as high as others like the Nexon or Brezza, your low 1,000 km a month should not make this too much of a worry and on the whole it stays well within your budget. Mahindra service can vary from dealer to dealer, so do check your local dealer options.If your Mahindra dealer is really weak, between the others, you could wait a for just about two months when the new updated Maruti Brezza is due to arrive. It too has a torque convertor autobox and its low ride is very plush and really a boon to have over bad city roads.

Mahindra XUV 3XO

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

Tata Nexon

Autocar India

•15h

The Citroen C3 fits your requirement of comfort and no nonsense features very well. Space inside is good and the suspension is tuned to provide excellent ride comfort even over bad and broken city roads. The C3 is also not loaded with features but its covers all of todays essential requirements very well and will come in under your budget. The C3 also has a torque convertor automatic gearbox which is the smoothest type of autobox to have, so given that nearly all you driving is within the city, this is something you will appreciate. The only issue with Citroen is the dealer network is very sparse, so only go ahead if you have a reputed dealer in your area. An alternative would be the Skoda Kylaq, at your budget you would get the lower trims but since you are not chasing fancy features this should do well. Like the C3, the Kylaq too has a torque convertor gearbox so it will be smooth and easy in city traffic. About the Jazz CVT - there’s no official plan to bring it back to India. If they do a new small Honda car, it is not around the corner, so don’t wait.

Citroen C3

Skoda Kylaq

Autocar India

•19h

The Nissan Magnite CVT is worth serious consideration. For a relatively new driver in Mumbai, its light steering, compact dimensions, and smooth CVT automatic make it easy to manage in traffic and simple to park. The turbo-petrol has enough pull for the Pune, Lonavala and Mahabaleshwar ghats, so it cruises on the expressway without feeling strained with family and luggage. It rides well on broken roads, has useful ground clearance, and the cabin and boot work fine for a small family. With only 300-350 km a month, petrol keeps costs simple, and the Magnite fits your Rs. 10-12 lakh budget.The flip side is the cabin feels a bit basic, and Nissan’s service network is smaller than Maruti or Hyundai, so check how close your nearest service center is.If you like sedans and want an even silkier automatic for the city, the Honda Amaze CVT is also worth a look, but you will give up some ground clearance and the SUV-like view you get in the Magnite.Alternatively, you could look at the Maruti Suzuki Fronx turbo petrol automatic, but it will need you to stretch your budget to about Rs 13 lakh.

Nissan Magnite

Honda Amaze

Maruti Suzuki Fronx