Opinion: Why the Jimny and Thar are not competitors

    They may use serious 4X4 hardware and a body-on-frame construction, and soon, 5-door body styles, but they are far from being competitors.

    Published on Jan 15, 2023 05:00:00 PM

    24,898 Views

    Maruti Suzuki Jimny Mahindra Thar

    No sooner had Maruti and Mahindra announced the 5-door body styles of Jimny and Thar 4X4s, it was only natural for comparisons to begin. At the back of our minds, we knew the two were going to be quite different, but compare we all did. But standing next to the Jimny at its global unveiling, it really struck me just how different the two SUVs are.

    Sure they are both straight-edged upright 4X4s and both use genuine 4X4 hardware as well as a body-on-frame construction, but that doesn’t make them competitors just like the Maruti Alto and Hyundai i20 aren’t. Both are hatchbacks, both use a monocoque construction and are front-wheel driven, but they are clearly in different segments with differing sizes and prices. 

    And that’s going to be the case with the two 5-door 4X4s. At 3,985 mm in length, the 5-door Jimny comes in under the 4-metre ‘small car’ mark and that’s with the spare out at the back, though with its larger 1.5-liter petrol engine, it wont qualify for the benefits. It’s also very narrow at 1,645mm and short with a height of 1,720mm – that’s shorter than my 5foot 8inch frame and I was able to scan the Jimny’s roof.

    The Thar measures an identical 3,985mm but that’s the 3-door model. The 5-door will certainly stretch well past the 4-metre mark and, at 1,820mm and 1,850mm, the Thar is appreciably wider and taller too. Unlike the Jimny, I can’t peer at the Thar roof unless I stand on my toes. The Jimny is shorter than me, the Thar taller.

    Under the hood too, they are vastly different. The Thar comes with a petrol and diesel powerplant; the diesel with two choices – a 1.5-litre and a 2.2-litre unit – whereas the petrol is a 2-litre powerplant. The Jimny, on the other hand, has only a petrol motor and it’s a much smaller 1.5-litre unit that puts out 105hp as against the Thar’s 152hp. Clearly then, size and engine capacities put these two in different segments and I’m sure pricing will too.

    Prices of 5-door variants of the Jimny and Thar aren’t out, but it's safe to say that the Thar will sit higher. It's significantly bigger and has a larger and more powerful engine. Moreover Maruti is brutal with cost control. Thus, when the two 5-door 4X4s arrive they will certainly sit in separate price segments.

    I also suspect they will appeal to slightly different customers. Sure both sets of customers want a lifestyle 4X4, but it’s the Thar that will appeal more to buyers who are inclined to the rough stuff and that’s driven by its image and capability. Again, both the Jimny and Thar are similar here, but the Thar, thanks to the previous-generation model’s hard-as-nails image, has the tougher and serious off-roader aura around it. With larger tyres and more powerful engines – including torquey diesels – it will have an edge off-road. 

    Which brings me to another point – Maruti should really offer the 2-door Jimny and with a 4X2 option as well, while the Thar should not. But that’s another story. 

    Also see:

    Auto Expo 2023: Maruti Suzuki Jimny 5-door makes global debut

    Mahindra Thar 4X2 review: Then there were two

    Comments
    ×
    img
    img
    Subhash chandra bose - 19 days ago

    Why doesn't maruti use its 1.2 litre dual jet engine or turbo engine in cars like Jimny and Brezza, and get tax benefits?

    img
    Kaushik Hegde - 22 days ago

    Jimny with 1.5 petrol is not eligible for tax benefits right? Shouldn't petrol engines be below 1.2 litres?

    img
    Sergius Barretto - 21 days ago

    Yes you're right.

    Ask Autocar Anything about Car and Bike Buying and Maintenance Advices
    Need an expert opinion on your car and bike related queries?
    Ask Now
    Poll of the month

    Which was your favourite Car, SUV at Auto Expo 2023

    Maruti Suzuki Jimny

     

    24.79%

    Maruti Suzuki Fronx

     

    14.45%

    Maruti Suzuki eVX concept

     

    2.52%

    Tata Harrier EV

     

    10.09%

    Tata Sierra

     

    23.30%

    Hyundai Ioniq 5

     

    4.21%

    Hyundai Ioniq 6

     

    3.60%

    Kia EV9 concept

     

    2.94%

    MG4

     

    2.03%

    Toyota Land Cruiser 300

     

    12.05%

    Total Votes : 4082
    Sign up for our newsletter

    Get all the latest updates from the automobile universe