I mostly drive in the city and am planning to buy a new car. I’m confused about whether to buy the Tata Nexon EV or the Kia Sonet / Hyundai Venue. The EV’s budget is high, but I can save on petrol. What should I do? Please advise.

Autocar India

•22h

For city-only use, on a Rs 15 lakh budget, the Tata Punch EV fits best. It is small enough to park anywhere, yet sits high off the ground like your Kiger, so speed breakers and bad patches are easily dealt with. The motor is smooth in traffic, and the real city range is enough for many days of short trips, so you won’t charge often. And the best part is you'll get the fully-loaded top spec Empowered +S 40kWh variant in your budget.Know the trade-offs: fast charging isn’t the quickest, and the rear seat is fine for two adults but tight for three. The boot is smaller than your Kiger's, too. If you want a more spacious back seat and boot, and a bit more real-world range, you can check out the Tata Nexon EV. However, while it can be had in your budget, you'll only get a low to mid variant, so for outright value for money, we'd still recommend the Punch EV.

Tata Punch EV

Tata Nexon EV

Autocar India

•2d

With 1,200 km a month in Chennai and mostly city traffic, moving to one automatic is sensible if your family’s schedules work with a single car. In that use, the Tata Nexon EV Medium Range is the stronger fit in your Rs. 15-17 lakh window. It is very smooth in stop-and-go traffic, there is no clutch heat or strain, and the instant response makes gaps easy. Your monthly running suits an EV well, and if you can install a home charger, you start each day with a full “tank” and very low running costs. As your only car, the Nexon EV has enough space for a small family, rides comfortably over broken patches, and feels easy to place in tight lanes and parking. If you can stretch your budget, the Hyundai Creta EV would make for a much better EV with a better driving experience and a larger and more comfortable car. Two watch-outs: you need a fixed parking spot with charging, and longer highway trips will need some planning around chargers.If you would rather stay with petrol, pick the Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara automatic in a mid trim. It keeps life easy in traffic, sits a bit higher for a better view, and you already know Maruti service from your S-Cross, and if you can stretch for the hybrid, it will keep your fuel costs in check. Overall, for city-heavy use, the Nexon EV makes the most sense.

Tata Nexon EV

Hyundai Creta Electric

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara

Autocar India

•1h

With 70 percent city use, pick the Honda Amaze ZX CVT. It's well-suited to daily traffic because it is easy to steer, rides comfortably over bad patches, and the automatic keeps driving simply. It is also light on running costs and fits your budget even in this top-spec ZX trim, and the boot is big enough for weekend trips, so your 30 percent highway runs are covered too. The trade-offs: at higher highway speeds, it feels like a small car and road noise creeps in, and with five adults, it will not feel very strong on quick passes.The Skoda Kylaq sits in a much higher price band, and in your budget of Rs 12 lakh, you will only get entry-level models. It is nowhere near as fuel-efficient as the Honda, and maintenance will likely be more expensive in the long run. It does, however, have the punchier powertrain and is more fun to drive.Another great option is the Nissan Magnite, which gives you the best of both worlds. Reliability, fuel economy and relatively low running costs of a Japanese car with the high stance of an SUV and a punchy turbo-petrol engine. It is also one of the best value-for-money cars at this budget.

Honda Amaze

Skoda Kylaq