I have been owning a Baleno MT petrol for the last 6.5 years. Planning to change the vehicle now. My monthly running is approximately 1,000km (city + highway). I enquired at the market and shortlisted two options: the Creta SX Summer Edition (petrol manual) and the Curvv EV Accomplished X. Both are priced at a difference of just Rs 50,000. Could you please suggest which one to buy?

Autocar India

•3h

Go for the Hyundai Creta because your 70% highway use and family of five will benefit most from its space, calm cruising and real-world efficiency. The 1.5 NA petrol with the automatic is smooth, stress-free and proven reliable, and the Creta’s big cabin and boot make family trips easy. Real-world mileage should be good too, and maintenance should be relatively low. In your budget, you should be able to get the mid-range S (O) CVT. Coming from a Maruti Jimny AT, you’ll love the greater refinement, more comfortable ride and stronger high-speed performance.From Maruti Suzuki, there are the Grand Vitara and Victoris, which are both excellent options too. Great mileage, smooth gearboxes and exceptional reliability, but for a family of five, space in the back seat isn't as good as the Creta, and the 105hp 1.5-litre petrol can feel overwhelmed under heavy load, especially on the highway, where you do 70% of your driving. Honda's 1.5-litre petrol in Elevate doesn't have this issue, but compared to the Creta, space and comfort aren't quite as good, and it lacks the same wow factor. However, if you don't mind a sedan, the City is a more compelling choice.Overall, though you won't get it in a higher variant with as many features as others, we feel the Creta is the best all-rounder for the money.

Hyundai Creta

Maruti Suzuki Jimny

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

Honda Elevate

Autocar India

•2d

This is very much a case of heart versus head. If your father loves the Tata Sierra, then the Sierra Diesel is actually a good choice. The diesel engine is far better suited to the Sierra than the naturally aspirated petrol, offering strong performance and effortless cruising on long highway trips. The Sierra also feels larger inside, has a wider cabin and is the better pure 5-seater of the two, with excellent space and comfort for family use.The Hyundai Creta is the more sensible choice. Its diesel engine is more refined, the overall ownership experience is smoother, and Hyundai's service network and aftersales support are generally stronger. It is also a proven product with a long track record.The drawback of the Sierra is that its diesel engine is not as refined as the Creta's, and Tata's ownership experience can be more variable depending on the dealership.

Tata Sierra

Hyundai Creta

Autocar India

•2d

Pick the Hyundai Creta diesel manual. Your hill drives will benefit from the effortless pull of a diesel at low speeds, and this engine gives that without making you work the gearbox. It also does better mileage than the petrol in all conditions, and the Creta’s ride is a touch softer, so your city commutes and long highway runs will be comfier. The only catch is you may give up a few of the Seltos’ showy features at this price, and the new-gen Kia Seltos is a bit more spacious than the Creta.If you’re fixed on petrol and want more pull than the Creta or Seltos' 1.5 NA petrol, look at the Skoda Kushaq 1.0 TSI or Volkswagen Taigun 1.0 TSI. Their turbo engines have strong mid‑range for hills and overtakes, and you can find good manual or automatic variants within your budget. They’re a size smaller inside than Creta/Seltos, and service reach isn’t as wide in smaller towns, but they drive superbly. Alternatively, check out the new Renault Duster, which offers both turbo-petrol engines across a wide price range.

Hyundai Creta

Kia Seltos

Volkswagen Taigun

Skoda Kushaq

Renault Duster