autocar-logo
Delhi
DK

DK

2d

Hey Autocar Team, I recently purchased the Kia Seltos 2026 Diesel Automatic. Before this, I owned a 2020 Kia Seltos Diesel Manual. As far as I know, both cars use the same engine, yet my newer Seltos does not feel as smooth as the older one, mainly because of the gearbox. I understand that a torque-converter automatic is generally considered very smooth, which is why this difference surprises me even more. I feel this could be because the automatic gearbox upshifts at around 2000 rpm, whereas in my manual, I used to shift closer to 1500 rpm, following the “listen to the engine and shift when it groans” approach I was taught. Perhaps the engine revving higher and sounding strained is what feels unusual to me. I would like to know whether this behaviour is normal for the automatic, and if it is simply something I need to get used to, since I have driven only manual cars until now. Please advise.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
6h

The Kia Seltos 2026 diesel AT uses the same 1.5-litre diesel engine as the MT version, and the torque converter gearbox is known for its smoothness.However, the gearbox does tend to upshift at around 2000rpm, which is a bit higher than the 1500rpm you were used to in the manual. This is because the torque converter gearbox is tuned to keep the engine in its powerband, and the engine makes its peak torque at 1750rpm.The slight delay in the gearbox also means that the engine revs a bit more before the next gear is engaged, which is why you feel the car is a bit more vocal.This is normal behaviour for a torque converter gearbox, and you will get used to it over time.

VehicleKia New Seltos
AM

Amitesh

3d

I am considering an automatic, and the choice is between the Kylaq AT, Elevate CVT, and Grand Vitara (GV). I would like to consider the Kylaq, but since my monthly driving is less than 500 km and mostly in the city, would a naturally aspirated engine be better? I plan to keep the car for at least 10 years and want it to be reliable, low-maintenance, with a minimum 4-star safety rating and NVH quality comparable to my 2010 Honda Jazz. I am also willing to consider other SUVs or raised hatchbacks that meet these criteria. Please advise.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
7h

If you like the Skoda Kylaq AT, go ahead. It’s a very good car to drive, feels solid, and is the most engaging of the three. Low running will naturally minimise wear and tear, and modern turbo-petrol engines are perfectly fine for city use as long as they’re maintained properly. Don’t overthink the naturally aspirated vs turbo debate purely from a reliability standpoint - upkeep matters more.The Honda Elevate CVT and Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara are bigger and more spacious, and both are sensible, comfortable choices. The Elevate’s naturally aspirated engine is smooth and predictable, and the Grand Vitara scores well on efficiency. However, neither feels as enjoyable or as tight to drive as the Kylaq.Given your priorities - long-term ownership, decent safety, good NVH and low running - the Kylaq fits well if driving feel matters to you. If space and a more relaxed nature matter more, then the Elevate would be the calmer choice. But purely from the heart-and-head balance, the Kylaq is the one we would pick.

VehicleSkoda Kylaq
VehicleHonda Elevate
VehicleMaruti Suzuki Grand Vitara