I'm considering upgrading to an electric vehicle (EV) within a ₹16 lakh budget. My primary options are the Tata Nexon EV and the Mahindra XUV400 EV. While I find the Nexon EV appealing, I've encountered concerns from well-wishers regarding potential issues. Additionally, the specific trim and color I desire are currently unavailable. I'm aware that the XUV400 EV is nearing the end of its production run. Given these factors, what would be your advice?

Autocar India

•44m

Your use is mostly city driving with one long trip a month, so switching to the Tata Punch EV 40kWh as your only car makes sense. In daily traffic, it feels smooth, quiet and easy to drive, while the instant response makes gaps in traffic easy to manage. On the highway, it feels stable and cruises comfortably. Expect a real-world highway range of around 220-230km, which means you will likely need just one fast-charging stop depending on your speed and load. If your route has enough fast chargers and you can charge overnight at your destination, this should not be an issue, and overall, it is a better solution than keeping your Renault Duster and buying a smaller city car.Two things to note versus your Duster: the Punch EV’s cabin and boot are smaller, and range can drop sharply if you are travelling fully loaded with luggage on longer trips.If that does not suit your usage, then keep the Duster for the monthly highway run and get a Tata Tiago EV for city use only. Do remember that even if the Duster is used only once a month, it will still need regular upkeep. Choose this option only if the running costs and parking needs of owning two cars are not a concern.

Tata Punch EV

Tata Tiago EV

Autocar India

•3d

For a 40-50 km daily city run and a budget of Rs. 15-17 lakh, go with the Nexon EV 45kWh version in a mid trim. It suits your use and budget better than stretching for the Vinfast VF6. You’ll get more than enough range for the week with a healthy buffer; it is easy to drive and park, rides comfortably over bad patches. Also, Tata’s service reach is fairly wide. The Nexon EV has also proven to be a safe car.Do note, the Nexon EV’s cabin does not feel as premium as the VF6. But for office runs, traffic and the odd weekend trip, it works well.If you want a fresher shape and a bit more road presence from your shortlist, the Tata Curvv EV is worth a look.

Tata Nexon EV

Vinfast VF6

Tata Curvv EV

Autocar India

•14h

With 70 percent city use, some highway trips, a family of four, and a strict manual requirement, the Volkswagen Taigun GT Plus Sport 1.5 TSI manual is a good upgrade from your Maruti Suzuki Swift. However, the manual transmission on the 1.5 TSI was discontinued earlier this year and has not returned with the recent facelift. This means the car you are considering is a pre-facelift version that may have been sitting at the dealer for a while. Moreover, Rs 28 lakh also seems very steep, as the last recorded on-road price of the 1.5 GT Plus Sport MT in Chennai, as per our records, was around Rs 22-23 lakh. Haggle hard if you proceed, do a very thorough pre-delivery inspection, and push for an extended warranty.As for the vehicle itself, the 1.5 petrol with the manual is an excellent choice. It feels quick and smooth, pulls cleanly from low speeds so you do not have to shift constantly in traffic, and has strong performance for safe highway overtakes. It is not too big for city lanes, the higher seating position improves visibility, and it feels stable at speed. Cabin quality and the overall safety focus are clear steps up from your Swift.Two things to note for your usage: the clutch is heavier than your Swift’s, and fuel consumption and upkeep costs will be noticeably higher.Alternatively, you could consider the Hyundai Creta N Line manual or the Renault Duster 1.3 manual, both of which are great options for keen drivers.

Volkswagen Taigun

Maruti Suzuki Swift

Hyundai Creta