Hello sir, I am currently using a Hyundai Grand i10. I am planning to purchase a new car but am confused between the Kia Seltos HTK(O) AT Diesel and the Tata Harrier Pure X AT Diesel. My budget is around Rs. 20 lakh. My daily driving is approximately 80 km, with a mix of city and highway usage. Please help me decide which option would be better.

Autocar India

•3h

Yes, that combination actually makes a lot of sense if the roles are clearly defined. For the Seltos, the 1.5 naturally aspirated petrol is perfectly adequate if it is going to be your city car. It is smooth, refined, easy to drive in traffic and ownership costs are reasonable. You do not really need the turbo petrol if the car's primary duty is urban commuting. The NA petrol may not feel particularly exciting, but for city use it will feel relaxed and effortless. Even in its lower variants, the Seltos is surprisingly well equipped, so it does not feel bare bones.As for the Thar 3-door, if it is purely a weekend fun vehicle, the base model can make sense from a value perspective. However, it is worth remembering that the Rs. 9.99 lakh ex-showroom variant is a 4x2 model, so you do not get the full off-road capability that most people associate with the Thar. If your idea of enjoyment is primarily the lifestyle, road presence and occasional beach or trail drives, it will still do the job. However, if you genuinely want to explore tougher trails and off-road terrain, it is worth stretching to a 4x4 variant.

Mahindra Thar

Kia Seltos

Autocar India

•3h

If your priority is a combination of driving enjoyment and passenger comfort, we would lean towards the Duster 1.3 Turbo DCT.The new Renault Duster has a more absorbent suspension setup and simply feels more comfortable over broken roads. It has that traditional Duster trait of shrugging off bad surfaces without unsettling passengers, which makes it particularly enjoyable on long drives. The wet clutch DCT is another advantage, especially in Indian conditions, as it feels smoother and more natural in traffic than the dry clutch DCT used in the Seltos.The Kia Seltos 1.5 Turbo Petrol is the quicker and more polished-feeling car. The engine is strong, the cabin feels more premium and feature-rich, and overall refinement is excellent. It is also a very comfortable SUV, but its suspension is tuned more towards ride comfort than driving thrill.So if the emphasis is on ride quality, comfort and an engaging driving experience, the Duster gets our vote. The only real drawback is that the rear seat is not as spacious as the Seltos, which remains the better choice if rear passenger room and cabin premiumness are higher priorities.

Renault Duster

Kia Seltos

Autocar India

•1h

Its hard to recommend a specific car without knowing a few more specifics like importance of rear space, who will drive it, etc. However, if you are looking at an all rounder we would suggest the Kia Seltos. The new second generation car has grown larger and more room inside, including at the rear, where the previous car was not as spacious. Since your running does not seem very high we would recommend the 1.5 litre naturally aspirated petrol coupled to the automatic gearbox. The autobox is a CVT but is does not have a prominent 'rubber band effect' - where revs rise faster than the corresponding speed increase and in fact, it is quite enjoyable when driven at regular speeds in the city. On the highway too, its just fine and the handling at higher speeds is very secure and stable and the car tracks straight and level even on less-than-perfect surfaces. As typical of Kia, the Seltos is also very well equipped and at your budget, you would get a decently specced mid-level variant.

Kia Seltos