Hello, I have booked the Mahindra Thar Roxx Star Edition Diesel, but I am concerned about the way Mahindra is portrayed on social media. Many videos are complaining about service quality, lack of responsiveness, and product issues, which is making me apprehensive. I currently own a Volkswagen Vento, which I have driven for the past 11 years. It has had its own issues with suspension, steering rack, slow service, and expensive spare parts. However, when you love a car, you tend to live with some shortcomings. I understand that no brand is perfect, and I am prepared for a reasonable margin of error in both product and service. However, the sheer number of negative videos about Mahindra is making me uneasy. While some online content may be exaggerated, there must be underlying reasons behind such strong reactions. Could you please provide an informed and balanced perspective on whether these concerns are valid or amplified by social media? Thank you.

autocar.india

•2d

With a budget of under Rs 5 lakhs, you will only be able to get pre-owned examples of the first-gen Thar. And while it is a very appealing SUV, it is not the best choice for daily driving, especially if comfort is a priority. It is a rugged off-roader; however, the first-gen's ride is bouncy, entry-exit isn't very easy, and heavy steering and crude nature will become tiring for daily use. The side-facing rear seat is also neither safe nor comfortable, and overall, it is better suited as a lifestyle or weekend vehicle rather than a daily commuter.Since you have a Rs 5 lakh budget and you want something with good road presence, you could consider an SUV car which is compact and easy to drive. A Maruti Brezza or Ford EcoSport could be good options for daily driving.

Mahindra Thar

Maruti Suzuki Brezza

autocar.india

•2d

Why not consider the Mahindra Thar Roxx instead? The Thar is a good secondary car, however the absence of rear doors hampers practicality. Also, while the Thar is excellent off-road, it can feel a bit bumpy on the road. In comparison, the Thar Roxx feels a lot more practical, usable and comfortable for daily use and long drives. The Hilux is simply too large for daily driving, especially in the city. However, if you're looking to get a vehicle purely for butch looks and stand-out road presence, then nothing will come close to the new Hilux. Be prepared to spend a lot more for it (compared to a Mahindra Thar Roxx).

Mahindra Thar Roxx

Toyota Hilux

autocar.india

•2h

No, this is not normal at all for a premium 900cc adventure motorcycle. Modern engines are designed to last well beyond the odometer crossing 6 figures and requiring another major repair just 6,500 km later strongly points to an underlying issue that has not been properly addressed.The most likely technical reasons for such a recurrence are either a fundamental manufacturing defect in the cylinder head or valve train, improper repair or assembly during the first replacement, or an underlying issue such as oil starvation, cooling problems or incorrect valve clearance adjustment that is causing repeated failure. It could also be related to poor fuel quality, detonation or lubrication issues, but on a premium motorcycle this is far less likely if the bike has been maintained properly.From an engineering perspective, continuing with repeated component-level repairs is not the right approach. If the same failure has occurred twice in such a short mileage, it points to a systemic issue rather than a one-off component failure. At this stage, a complete engine replacement is the more comprehensive and sensible solution, as it eliminates the risk of hidden damage elsewhere in the engine and ensures long-term reliability.Alternatively, we'd also recommend you visit another authorised service centre and get your machine inspected by a trained mechanic. A fresh set of eyes can perhaps provide you with a solution you didn't know was available.