Autocar India
19w

Hi, I am planning to buy the BSA Scrambler 650. My usage will include a 40 km daily commute, weekend rides, and occasional long trips. I don’t prefer the RE 650cc engine as it feels too bulky, protrudes outward, and isn’t very ergonomic (during my test ride, I felt like I was sitting in an unnatural position, almost hugging the tank with my legs). In the past, I have owned a Passion Plus, Thunderbird 350, and Xpulse 200. I now want to move to the 500cc and above segment. Kindly help me make the right decision. Thank you!

Verified
19w

The BSA Scrambler 650 is a new launch in India and its long-term reliability still remains unconfirmed. While the engine is largely the same as the Gold Star and shouldn't throw any unwelcome surprises, the rest of the bike is significantly different and it would be prudent to wait a while before you pull the trigger on it.

Another important factor to consider is that BSA’s network here is still quite limited, and parts and service access need to be readily available when it comes to your daily ride. Add to the fact that Classic Legends has so far not been free from its share of customer complaints related to service and parts availability. 

We would advise you to consider other machines in the class or if you have your heart set on the BSA, at the very least, defer your purchase by 6 months to see how the market reacts to it.

BSA Scrambler 650

BSA Scrambler 650

More posts on similar bikes

1d

I have loved manual-transmission cars since childhood. I grew up watching people drive manual cars, and my love for cars and driving has only grown over the years. However, people keep telling me that driving a manual car in heavy city traffic can be difficult and tiring. I genuinely enjoy driving and feel that a manual car gives me a more engaging driving experience. So, what should I do? Should I accept the realities of heavy city traffic and buy an automatic, or should I follow my heart, buy a manual sedan and accept the inconvenience of driving a manual in heavy traffic? I am currently considering the Skoda Slavia 1.0 MT. Does it make sense to choose the manual given my love for driving, or would an automatic be more practical for city use?

Verified
19h

Have you been driving regularly or are you simply fascinated by the concept of owning a manual sedan? If it is the latter, we'll recommend you to rent any self-driven manual car for a week, and replicate your daily usage with. If you're comfortable driving the manual car in traffic, then go ahead and get the car you've been longing for. A self-drive rental might seem a bit expensive but it'll help you get clarity of which transmission you should pick for the long term.The Skoda Slavia 1.0 TSI MT is a good choice, but since you have a Rs 20-30 lakh budget for a sedan, we'd suggest you consider the Hyundai Verna 1.5 Turbo 6MT instead. The Verna's 1.5 Turbo engine is much more powerful, gearbox is smoother, and clutch is lighter than the Skoda's.

VehicleSkoda Slavia
VehicleHyundai Verna

Popular discussions right now

Posted on: 5 May 2026