Hi, I am planning to buy a petrol manual car with a budget of Rs 18 lakh. My dream car from my graduation is the Mahindra Thar or ROXX. But as I am married now, I am also thinking of the Skoda Kushaq or Volkswagen Taigun. Kindly please suggest to me whether I should go with the Thar or others. And one major thing is that the majority of the drive will be on hill roads and bad roads. So please suggest to me accordingly. Thank you.

Autocar India

•6h

Given your usage, you don't necessarily need 4x4. A rear-wheel drive, tough diesel SUV with high ground clearance should suffice. That leaves you with two options: Scorpio N and Thar Roxx. Both these SUVs meet your requirements, and both these will tackle treacherous roads rather effortlessly.Between them, the Scorpio N's ride on the highway feels a touch bumpier, whereas the Thar Roxx feels more settled in comparison. Hence, go for the Scorpio N only if you need that extra row of seats; otherwise, in every other way, the Thar Roxx seems like the better pick for you.

Mahindra Scorpio N

Mahindra Thar Roxx

Autocar India

•1d

Both are good choices at that price, but they’re aimed at slightly different buyers, so it depends on where and how you drive.The Honda Elevate and VW Taigun follow very different philosophies. The Elevate’s 1.5 naturally aspirated petrol with CVT is very well suited to city use. It is smooth, easy to drive and generally more relaxed in traffic. It is competent on the highway, but when you rev it hard for quick overtakes, the typical CVT “rubber-band” effect makes the engine sound loud and less refined than you’d like.The Taigun 1.5 TSI with the 7-speed DSG is the opposite. It is not as smooth in bumper‑to‑bumper traffic and it can feel a bit jerky at low speeds, but it comes alive on the open road. With about 150 hp and 250 Nm, it has a strong mid‑range and much quicker responses than the 121 hp Elevate, so it will comfortably leave the Honda car behind on the highway and makes overtaking effortless.Where the Elevate clearly scores is practicality. It’s the larger car overall and offers a more spacious rear seat and a significantly bigger boot (around 458 litres vs 385 litres in the Taigun), which makes a noticeable difference for family use and luggage.So, if your priority is comfort, space and mostly city driving with occasional highway runs, go for the Elevate. If you enjoy driving, do frequent highway trips and want performance and refinement at speed, the Taigun 1.5 DSG is the more satisfying choice.

Honda Elevate

Volkswagen Taigun

Autocar India

•3h

From your list, the Mahindra Scorpio N 4x4 diesel is the safest fit for this use. As a five-seater with the last row folded, it offers a large boot, a tough body and proper 4x4 with low range for slush, snow or rocky terrain. It also has strong pulling power on steep hill roads when fully loaded. Mahindra’s wide service network on these routes is an added advantage when you are far from cities.Be aware that the Scorpio N is not as quiet or as comfortable on long highways as softer monocoque SUVs, and in the city, the ride can feel a bit bouncy. The Mahindra XUV 7XO is the better road car. It is more comfortable and refined, but for your intended usage, it is not as robust or as versatile as the Scorpio N, especially for tougher terrain in the Himalayas where the Scorpio N’s higher ground clearance and proper 4x4 make a real difference. The same limitation applies to options like the Renault Duster Hybrid and Honda Elevate.As for the Mahindra Thar Roxx, it is less comfortable than the Scorpio N, especially in terms of seating and long-distance usability.

Mahindra Scorpio N

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Mahindra Thar Roxx

Renault Duster

Honda Elevate