I want to buy a family MUV. I am confused between the new Carnival and the newly launched MG M9. Both come at a similar price, and one is electric. I personally liked the M9 more, but I am unsure about the Carnival’s pricing and think it may drop considerably in the future, as it is now a completely CBU model. My monthly running would be no more than 500 km. Please guide.

Anshuman Singh

•29w

Both the luxury MPVs are very capable and offer a lot to the buyer. If long-distance drives are something you may do, the Carnival with its diesel engine would be better. However, judging by your monthly running, it appears that you have smaller trips and perhaps within city/town limits.

The electric MG M9 would thus be fine. It has a better interior in terms of appointments and rear seat functionality, and given that you already have a liking for it, we would recommend you go with the MG. On a side note, the Carnival isn’t a CBU but is locally assembled.

Was this helpful? Ask a follow-up

Got a suggestion for Shiteej?

Add a Comment

Related questions you may find helpful

Sudhir Singh

•1d

I am confused between the Tata Safari petrol and the Scorpio N. Which would be better, and what's the major difference between the Tata Safari Pure X and Adventure X Plus?

Autocar India

•1h

The Safari's three rows are much more comfortable and spacious than the Mahindra Scorpio N's, and its suspension feels a lot plusher too, making it better to drive as well. Overall, the Tata Safari feels more polished in comparison, hence it gets our vote.The price difference between Pure X and Adventure X Plus variant of the Safari is approximately Rs 1.40 lakh (on-road), with the latter being more expensive. For the premium, the Adventure X Plus variant gets larger 18-inch alloys (vs 17s in the Pure X), drive modes, one-touch up and down driver's power window, electonic parking brake with auto hold, rear defogger, leatherette upholstery and an electric driver's seat with memory.While these are nice to have, none of these features is a deal-maker. Instead, the Pure X variant is very well-equipped and actually a better value for money.

Tata Safari

Mahindra Scorpio N

Sunny

•1d

I am thinking of buying the Sonet HTK Optional DCT turbo petrol, which is around ₹12 lakh, and at the same time, the Venue HX5 turbo DCT petrol is coming at ₹13.5 lakh on-road in Bangalore. Which should I pick? Second, are heating issues still a thing to consider in both these DCT models?

Autocar India

•1h

Between the two, we would suggest going for the Kia Sonet HTK (O) DCT. The Sonet and the Venue share the same 1.0-litre turbo petrol engine paired with the DCT gearbox, so performance and the overall driving experience will be very similar. In terms of equipment as well, both these variants are quite similarly equipped, but the Sonet is around Rs 1.5 lakh cheaper, which makes it an excellent value for money.That said, the Hyundai Venue is the newer car and offers slightly better rear seat space. So if rear seat comfort is an important factor for you, that is something to keep in mind.On the topic of DCT overheating, it can happen in very heavy bumper-to-bumper traffic where the car is constantly crawling forward. However, this gearbox has been around for quite some time and has seen improvements over the years. In normal usage, it is not a major concern, and there are safety systems built in to alert you if the gearbox temperature rises too much.

Kia Sonet

Hyundai Venue

shreekumar

•21h

Hello Team. We are planning for a bigger car and are currently confused about whether buying a Harrier EV Stealth Edition makes sense, or if we should buy a used Innova Crysta and use it for 3-4 years and wait for EV infrastructure to develop more, as most of our running is on highways.

Autocar India

•2h

The Tata Harrier EV with the 74.61kWh battery pack is capable of delivering a highway real-world range of over 400km quite easily. So, if your highway round-trip is usually less than 400km, you can comfortably make it back to your starting point on a single charge. Even if you usually drive for longer distances, you'll need to plan your breaks or rest stops at places where there are fast charging options, along the way. In fact, even a 15-20 minute top-up on a 60kW DC fast charger will add an additional 120-140km of range.Yes, there are some challenges like chargers not working, or lack of electricity, or some ICE vehicle blocking the charging bay, hence you need to ensure you identify a few options (not just one place) on the way. To answer your question, go for the Harrier EV Stealth Edition. It'll feel a lot more special and the driving pleasure will be far greater than a used Toyota Innova Crysta.

Tata Harrier EV

Toyota Innova Crysta

View all Posts