Sir, I currently own two cars, a 2022 XUV700 diesel manual and a 2024 BMW X1 diesel. We are a family of five, and I plan to keep only one car since maintaining two is becoming difficult. Which one should I keep, or should I sell both and opt for a new one? I’m confused. Please advise.

Autocar India

•16w

It would make sense to keep your BMW X1 and sell the Mahindra XUV700. While the XUV700 is cheaper to maintain and offers the added flexibility of a third row, the X1 is newer, has a more premium cabin, provides adequate space for five people, and carries the advantage of BMW’s brand value.

BMW X1 Front Left Three Quarter — BMW X1

Explore cars mentioned

BMW

from ₹58.60 Lakh

Mahindra

XUV700

from ₹15.86 Lakh

Was this helpful? Ask a follow-up

Got a suggestion for Samuel?

Add a Comment

Latest questions people are discussing

Deepak

•2d

Hi, I am from Akola. I previously owned a Ritz VDi and am now planning to buy a new sub-4 metre car. My city usage is very limited, and most of my driving would be on the highway. There is no fixed monthly running, but annually it would be around 10,000-12,000 km. I am considering the Venue Diesel AT.

Autocar India

•5m

The Hyundai Venue diesel AT is not a bad option. It's spacious, comfortable, well-equipped and packed with the latest tech. Above all else, it is smooth and surprisingly refined, which bodes well for all driving conditions.However, perhaps its only shortcoming is a lack of punch, which, considering the majority of your driving is on the highway, could be an annoyance. Test drive the Venue diesel AT and see if you find it satisfactory, but an alternative is the Mahindra XUV 3XO diesel. It's a far punchier engine, which is great on the highway, and besides that, it has class-leading cabin space and excellent comfort. However, if you're after an automatic, its AMT is nowhere near as smooth as the Venue's AT, so bear that in mind.

Mahindra XUV 3XO

Sushma

•1d

I am in Bangalore and planning to buy my first automatic car as a new driver, with a budget of ₹10-12 lakh. I am confused between the Baleno AMT, i20 iVT and Sonet. Earlier, I was thinking of buying the Punch, but due to service issues, I am not considering it. The Exter AMT also seems like a good option.

Autocar India

•30m

Given your requirements, you should consider the Hyundai i20 IVT. Unlike the Maruti Baleno and Hyundai Exter which get AMTs, the i20 offers a more seamless drive experience thanks to the CVT automatic, which is smooth and user-friendly. The Sonet, meanwhile, comes with a DCT automatic, which is more jerky in stop-and-go traffic than the CVT.The Hyundai i20 IVT is powered by a refined 88hp, 1.2-litre petrol engine that has a claimed efficiency of 20kpl. This hatchback offers a spacious and comfortable cabin and comes with all the features expected in this class. Being a Hyundai car, the i20 will also be reliable and easy to maintain. Hyundai i20 IVT prices range from Rs 8.13 lakh to Rs 10.34 lakh (ex-showroom).

Gaurav Rai

I have been driving a Honda Amaze petrol for the last 10 years and am now planning to switch. I have shortlisted the Basalt X/Aircross X automatic transmission. Will it be a good option considering their good ride quality, or are there any better options available between ₹13 to 14 lakh?

Autocar India

•55m

Yes, the Citroen Basalt X or Aircross X would make great upgrades from your Honda Amaze. For one, they are a size larger, and secondly, they are very well priced - although consider upping your budget very slightly to get a higher-spec automatic variant.Both cars have excellently calibrated suspension, which gives them superb ride quality as well as sharp handling. This is only complemented by their smooth yet punchy 1.2-litre turbo petrol engine and 6-speed torque converter automatic. Considering your requirements, either of these would be a great option for you.

Citroen Aircross

Citroen Basalt

View all Posts