Tata Sierra Ev vs Tata Punch Ev

Autocar India
Tata Sierra EV

Tata Sierra Ev

Empowered A 75 AWD

25.99 lakh

Tata Punch EV

Tata Punch Ev

Empowered + S 40

12.79 lakh

Engine & Transmission

Fuel Type/ Propulsion

Electric
Electric

Motor Type

Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor

Gearbox Type

Auto
Auto

Number of Gears

1
1

Paddle Shifters for Automatic Gearbox

–

Drive Layout

All Wheel Drive
Front Wheel Drive

Max Motor Power

306 hp
129 hp

Max Motor Torque

504 Nm
154 Nm

Number of Motors

–
1

Pure Electric Driving Mode

–

Lockable Differential/s

–

Fuel & Performance

Emission Standard

Other
–

Drive Mode Types

Multiple
Multiple

Terrain Modes

Battery Capacity

75kWh
40 kWh

Claimed Range

624 km
468 km

Charging Time

–
5.3hrs 10%-100%(7.2kW AC), 30min 10%-80%(65kW DC)

Suspension & Steering

Front Suspension Type

McPherson Strut and Stabilizer bar
Independent, MacPherson Strut

Rear Suspension Type

Independent Multilink with Stabilizer bar
Non-independent, Torsion Beam

Type of Power Assist

Electric
Electric

Steering Adjust type

Manual
Manual

Steering Adjust

Tilt and Telescopic
Tilt

Turning Radius

5.32 m
5 m

Front Brakes

Disc
Disc

Rear Brakes

Disc
Drum

Wheel Size

19 inches
16 inches

Front Tyre Size

225/55 R19
195/60 R16

Rear Tyre Size

225/55 R19
195/60 R16

Wheels

Alloys
Alloys

Front Springs

–
Coil Springs

Rear Springs

–
Coil Springs

Damper Control

–

Ride Height Adjust

–

Spare Wheel

–

Dimensions

Length

4340 mm
3880 mm

Width

1841 mm
1742 mm

Height

1750 mm
1622 mm

Wheelbase

2730 mm
2445 mm

Ground Clearance

205 mm
195 mm

Chassis Type

Monocoque
Monocoque

Boot Capacity

622 litres
366 litres

Doors

5
5

Kerb Weight

–
None kg

Comfort

Sunroof

Panoramic
Single Pane

Glove Box

Front Seatback Pockets

–

12 Volt Port Boot

–

Rear AC Vents

Push Button Start

Electric Tailgate Release

Cruise Control

Yes (Adaptive)

Cooled Glovebox

Climate Control

2-zone
1-zone

Rear Window Sun Shades

Steering Mounted Controls

Audio and Phone
–

Front Passenger Seat Adjust from Rear

Rear Parcel Tray

Power Windows with One Touch-Up

Driver Window Only

Power Windows

Front and Rear
Front and Rear

Power Windows with One Touch-Down

Driver Window Only

Adjustable Underthigh Support

Front Only
–

Voice Assisted Sunroof

Ambient Lighting

Exterior Mirrors Electric Adjust

Powered Tailgate

Yes (Gesture Control)
–

Vanity Mirror

–

Exterior Mirrors Electric Fold

Yes with power folding

Trunk Light

Auto Parking

Cooled Storage

–

Cup Holders

–

Rear Power Outlet

–

Dead Pedal

–

Door Pockets

–

Powered Backseat Recline Adjustment

–

Driving Modes

–

Accessory Power Outlet

–

Flat Bottom Steering Wheel

–

Foldable Seatback Table

–

Launch Control

–

Keyless Entry

–

Hands-free Boot Opening

–

Interior Lamps

–

Heated ORVM

–

Sunglass Holder

–

Single Pedal Driving

–

Bottle Holder in Doors

–

Rear Windscreen Sun Shade

–

Cooled Cup Holders

–

Roof Grab Handles

–

Remote Locking

–

Safety

Tyre Pressure Monitoring System

With Display
With Display

Speed Assist System

–

Traction Control

Side Airbag

Rear Cross Traffic Alert

Rear Cross Traffic Collision Avoidance

–

Rear Defogger

Hill Start Assist

Rear Washer/Wiper

Parking Camera

360 degree
360 degree

Adaptive Cruise Control

Airbags

6
6

Anti-Lock Brakes (ABS)

Anti Theft Alarm

–

Auto emergency braking (AEB)

–

Automatic Headlamps

Automatic Wipers

Blind Spot Monitor

Central Locking

Curtain Airbag

Day Night Interior Mirror

Automatic
–

Door Ajar Warning

–

Driver Airbag

Hill Descent Control

Passenger Airbag

Overspeed Warning

–

Lane Keep Assist

Lane Departure Avoidance

–

ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts

Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD)

High Beam Assist

–

Height Adjustable Seat Belt

–

Electronic Stability Control

Electronic Parking Brake

Yes with Autohold

Brake Assist (BA)

–

Child Safety Lock

–

BNCAP Rating

–
5

Speed-Sensing Auto Door Locks

–

Speed Sensing Door Lock

–

Blind Spot Collision Avoidance Assist

–

Traffic Sign Recognition

–

Anti-Pinch Power Windows

–

Parking Sensors

–
Rear

Oncoming Lane Mitigation

–

Pretensioners & Force Limiter Seatbelts

–

Dashcam

–

Driver Attention Warning

–

Day/Night Interior Mirror

–
Auto-dimming

Exterior

Roof Rails

Front Fog Lamps

Headlight Type

LED
LED

Puddle Lamps

Projector Headlamps

LED DRLs

LED taillights

–

Outside rear view mirror (ORVM)

ORVM turn indicators

Pop-Out Door Handle

Manual
–

Stop Lamp

Welcome and Goodbye Animation

Charging Indicator On Light Bar

–

Follow Me Home Headlamps

Antenna

Shark Fin
Shark Fin

Illuminated Logo

–

Integrated Washer Jets with Wiper

–

Wheel Arch Cladding

–

LED headlamps

–

LED fog lamps

–

Cornering Foglamps

–

Cornering Headlights

–

Body Coloured Bumpers

–

Daytime Running Lights

–
LED

Sequential Turn Indicators

–

Door Handle Finish

–
Body Coloured

Interior

Rear Seat Armrest

Yes with Holders

Rear Seat Backrest Split

60:40

Driver's Seat Memory

Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel

Ventilated Seats

Front Only
Front Only

Electric Adjust for Driver's Seat

Adjustable Rear Headrests

Adjustable Front Headrests

Electric Adjust for Front Passenger's Seat

Speedometer

–
Digital

Gear Indicator

–

Head-up Display

–

Trip Meter

–

Average Speed

–

Low Fuel Level Warning

–

Instantaneous Consumption

–

Distance to Empty

–

Average Fuel Consumption

–

Rear Seat Backrest Fold

–

Leather-wrapped Gear Knob

–

Massage Seats

–

Heated Seats

–

Individual Chairs at Rear

–

Front Seat Armrest

–

Front Passenger Seat Memory

–

Front Passenger Seat Height Adjust

–

Seats

–
Leatherette

Third Row Seats

–

Rear Seat Backrest Recline

–

Seat Count

–
5

Driver's Seat Height Adjust

–

Entertainment

Apple CarPlay

Wireless
Wireless

Branded Music System

JBL
–

Speakers

12
–

Display

12.29-inch Touchscreen
10.24-inch Touchscreen

Android Auto

Wireless
Wireless

Voice Commands

Alexa

Second Row USB port

2 Type C
–

Satellite Navigation

On-board
Phone-based

Front USB port

2 Type C
–

Wireless Phone Charging

MirrorLink

–

Steering Audio Controls

–

Rear Entertainment Screens

–

Web Browser

–

Video Player

–

Rear Seat Infotainment Controls

–

USB Input

–

Steering Phone Controls

–

Touchpad

–

AUX Input

–

Front Passenger Screen

–

CD Player

–

Audio System

–

Bluetooth Telephone Function

–

Gesture Controls

–

Bluetooth Audio Streaming

–

Connected Car Features

Over the air (OTA) updates

–

Digital Key

–

SOS Button

–

Questions you may find useful

•13w

Sir, how is the rear suspension and ride quality of the Mahindra XEV 9e Pack One and Two? I tested the Pack Three and found the rear seat very boat-like with too much movement both vertically and sideways, which can get nauseating for rear-seat passengers. Is the suspension setup in Pack One and Two any better? Should I instead go for the Harrier EV 75 RWD if I want better ride quality, or should I wait for the Sierra EV? I want an EV bigger than the Nexon, but I do not like the Curvv EV and was thinking of avoiding Mahindra because of the suspension. I tried the Nexon EV and new Punch EV and found their rear suspension much better than the XEV 9e and even the eVitara. Please guide.

Verified
•13w

What you felt in the Mahindra XEV 9e Pack Three is a fair observation. The XEV 9e does have a softer suspension tune, and for some rear seat passengers, that can translate into a floaty, slightly boat-like vertical movement over undulations, which can feel uncomfortable or even nauseating if you are sensitive to that kind of motion. As far as we know, there is no major suspension hardware difference between Pack One, Two and Three that fundamentally changes this character, so we would not expect the lower variants to feel significantly different in this regard.If rear seat ride quality and body control are a major priority, the Tata Harrier EV is the better option right now. It feels more tied down, composed and generally better controlled from the rear, without that excessive floatiness. If you still want to stay with Mahindra, the XEV 9e actually feels more balanced in this respect and does not have the same exaggerated bouncy character as the XEV 9S.That said, since you are clearly particular about ride quality and already like how Tata’s EVs are tuned, we would absolutely suggest waiting for the Tata Sierra EV as well, especially since its launch is right around the corner. It should sit in that sweet spot above the Nexon EV in size while potentially offering the kind of more settled suspension setup you seem to prefer.

VehicleMahindra XEV 9e
VehicleMahindra XEV 9S
VehicleTata Sierra EV
VehicleTata Nexon EV
VehicleTata Harrier EV