Autocar India
•13w

I am confused between the Tata Safari Petrol MT and the Tata Sierra Accomplished/Accomplished+ Petrol AT. This will be my first car, and I plan to keep it for around 8-10 years. My primary requirement is a real-world city mileage of at least 10-11kpl. Most of the driving will be in the city, with a monthly running of around 300km and one long trip every 1-2 months. Good road presence is also important. I would also prefer an engine with enough power for effortless highway overtaking. My wife is particularly interested in the passenger screen available on the Sierra Accomplished+, which is why I am considering stretching the budget for it. However, the Accomplished+ is around Rs 2 lakh over my original budget. Considering my usage and requirements, which car would make the most sense? If the Sierra is the better choice, should it be the Accomplished or Accomplished+? Is spending around Rs 2.5 lakh more on the Accomplished+ mainly for the passenger screen and additional features actually worth it?

Verified
•13w

Firstly, ask yourself whether you need the third row seating. If yes, then the Tata Safari is your best bet - it is a spacious three-row SUV. That said, its manual gearbox is not the smoothest, nor is its clutch as effort-free as that of most other smaller mid-size SUVs. Also, to extract 10-11kpl from your short city runs will be difficult. These are trade-offs you will have to make for its road presence, performance, as well as cabin space.

If you don't need the extra row of seats, it makes sense to opt for the Tata Sierra instead. Do note, it isn't an efficient turbo-petrol-automatic combination, so be prepared for higher monthly fuel bills. The good news is that the 1.5 Turbo-Petrol's performance is strong, and the 6-speed automatic gearbox works smoothly. It is a spacious, sturdy SUV; you can choose from the multiple variants on offer.

If you plan to keep the car for an 8-10 year period, it could be worth stretching your budget a bit and getting all the bells and whistles. 

Tata Safari

Tata Safari

Have a question about Sierra or Safari?

Get answers from Autocar experts and owners


  • 9,000+discussions
  • 20,000+users online
  • 10,000+members

More posts on similar cars

•1d

I'm confused between the XUV 7XO diesel automatic and the Kia Carens Clavis turbo-petrol automatic. My annual usage is around 10,000km, and I want a seven-seater. With the XUV 7XO, I'm doubtful whether a diesel engine would suit my usage, and I'm not interested in the petrol version. With the Kia Carens Clavis, I'm concerned about the seven-seat configuration, although I like its practical seating arrangement. Which one would you recommend? Also, is it worth waiting for the seven-seat Renault Duster?

Verified
•1d

If third row seating is an important requirement, then the Kia Carens Clavis is the better choice. Access to its third row is more convenient thanks to the one-touch tumble-and-fold feature of the middle row seat. Further, the middle row seats can be moved forward and backward, and this enables better flexibility in terms of balancing space for second- and third-row occupants. The Mahindra XUV 7XO gets a fixed middle row seat, and third-row seating isn't ideal.This Kia car with the turbo-petrol engine and DCT gearbox combo also offers enough power to drive with a full load of passengers in comfort. That being said the performance is no match for the XUV 7XO diesel automatic, which feels stronger, especially at highway speeds. A diesel only makes sense for you if you have frequent highway runs. If you are looking primarily for a car for city use, avoid a diesel.The 7-seat Renault Duster is due to come to India in 2027. Compared to the standard Renault Duster, the 7 seat version will be slightly longer in its wheelbase and have a larger rear overhang too, enhancing space inside the cabin. We are yet to experience its third row, but it might not be quite as roomy at the very back as a Carens Clavis, which is designed as a people mover.

VehicleKia Carens Clavis
VehicleMahindra XUV 7XO

Has E20 fuel affected your mileage?

Quick car quiz

Which one gives better diesel mileage?

Have a question about Sierra or Safari?

Get answers from Autocar experts and owners


  • 9,000+discussions
  • 20,000+users online
  • 10,000+members

Is ADAS worth paying extra for in a car?

Popular discussions right now

•1w

Hi Autocar India team, I would appreciate your advice on choosing a used automatic car for around Rs 12 lakh. I currently own a 2009 Maruti Alto LPG, which has covered 1.1 lakh km. My annual running is around 7,000km. My village is about 350km away, so I make two to three highway trips there every year. I have a family of four and want to keep my fuel expenses within Rs 5-6 lakh over the next 10 years. My priorities, in order, are an automatic gearbox, good road presence and reliability, followed by maintenance costs, as I have a close friend who is a mechanic. I want to avoid diesel cars, DCT gearboxes and gimmicky features. The Nexon, Venue and Punch feel a little too small for my needs. I would also prefer to avoid 1.2-litre three- or four-cylinder engines, as I don't want too much vibration at highway speeds. My shortlist, with all these cars test-driven and available for around Rs 12 lakh, includes the Hyundai Alcazar 2.0, Maruti Grand Vitara mild-hybrid, Hyundai Creta/Kia Seltos IVT and Honda Elevate CVT. I am also open to MPVs and sedans as a last resort. I have a few questions: 1. Which of these would you pick, and why? 2. If E30, E85 or E100 petrol is introduced, would retrofitting the Alcazar with a CNG kit make sense? I do not need the third row. 3. Are there any other used cars I should consider? 4. Would a 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid be worth considering at around Rs 6-9 lakh? 5. What about a Toyota Innova Crysta for around Rs 9 lakh? 6. Should I consider EVs? I would love to hear your opinion.

Verified
•6d

Since you don't need the Alcazar's extra third row, why not consider a Hyundai Creta 1.5 IVT instead? It is a smooth, spacious, comfortable and sensible choice. You should get a 2022-23 manufactured, well-maintained example in your Rs 12 lakh budget.Alternatively, in case you're looking for road presence, you could also consider a used Jeep Compass diesel-automatic. It is an excellent highway car, and the 2.0-litre diesel and 9-speed torque converter automatic combination will ensure that your fuel costs are in check compared to its petrol-automatic version.

Upcoming launch buzz

Community discussions on upcoming launches

Add a photo of your Safari

First sightings, real road conditions, delivery buzz

Posted on: 16 Aug 2026