autocar-logo
Delhi
VK

Vishnu Kumar

1d

I am a 31-year-old lawyer looking to purchase my first car with a budget of ₹15-17 lakhs (on-road). My primary use will be a daily city commute of approximately 40-50 km. I am looking for a vehicle with a classy, sophisticated aesthetic, nothing overly aggressive or 'intimidating', and a premium, well-appointed interior. I am undecided between a sedan and a mid-size SUV. While I value the fuel efficiency and sleekness of a sedan, I am considering whether an SUV’s ground clearance is necessary for city infrastructure. Given my daily running, good mileage and ease of driving are priorities. Based on these requirements, which specific models and variants would you recommend for a professional first-time owner?

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
3h

Given your requirements, we would recommend you choose between the Honda City and the Honda Elevate. Both models have understated styling and a well-appointed interior.The Honda City sedan has a spacious and comfortable cabin, and the 121hp, 1.5-litre petrol engine is refined and peppy. It can be had with either a 6-speed manual, which has a claimed mileage of 17.8kpl, or a CVT automatic, which is claimed to do 18.4kpl. The City also has a comfortable ride quality, which will be good for your daily commute. Given your budget, you should either go for the City ZX MT (Rs 17.25 lakh, on-road Delhi) or the City VX CVT (Rs 17.33 lakh, on-road Delhi).However, if you want the road presence and ground clearance of an SUV, consider the Honda Elevate. It's gets the same powertrain options as the Honda City, although claimed mileage is lower with 15.31kpl for the manual and 16.92kpl for the CVT auto. The Elevate also has a spacious cabin and a comfortable ride quality. Given your budget, you should either go for the Elevate ZX MT (Rs 17.38 lakh, on-road Delhi) or the Elevate VX CVT (Rs 17.30 lakh, on-road Delhi).

VehicleHonda City
VehicleHonda Elevate
TA

Tarun

9h

Hi, I have shortlisted 5 cars and will buy one of these in the upcoming weeks. I am coming from an i20 1.2 Elite, and I am looking to buy an automatic petrol. My budget is around Rs 15-16 lakh. I am looking at the 3XO, Sonet, Astor, Kylaq and Venue (not a fan of the Nexon / Syros looks). I stay in Mumbai, and most of my running will be city driving, so automatic transmission smoothness will be an important factor. My weekly average is around 80-100km. A couple of times a year, we might take the car for a 300km highway run, but that’s rare. Features like a panoramic sunroof, ventilated seats and mood lighting are good to have, but not deal breakers. Could you please suggest what you think are the most suitable options? I took the 3XO for a test drive and really liked it, and will be driving the others over the next 2 weeks as well.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
3h

Given your priorities from a petrol automatic, your best options are the Mahindra XUV 3XO, which you already like, and the Skoda Kylaq. Both have a lot in common, like a punchy turbocharged petrol engine, a solid feel, great ride quality and - most importantly - a smooth torque-converter automatic gearbox.The Mahindra car has a more spacious cabin, though this comes at the cost of the boot, which is smaller. And though its engine is stronger, it's also not very fuel-efficient; although, given your low running, perhaps this is not a deal breaker for you either. The XUV 3XO also has more features, though that drives the price up too, and at your budget of Rs 15-16 lakh, you should find evenly-equipped versions of both cars.Overall, they're closely matched, and preference plays a big role, but we feel the Skoda Kylaq is a better all-rounder.

VehicleSkoda Kylaq
VehicleMahindra XUV 3XO
Skoda Kylaq
Skoda Kylaq