I am planning to purchase a new automatic car in the next 6 months, with an on-road budget of ₹20 lakh in Bangalore. I am preferably looking for an SUV with a 5-star safety rating and a large boot of around 500 litres. I like the Tata Sierra, but am wary of its new naturally aspirated petrol engine paired with a DCA automatic. My annual running is low at around 7,000km, with about 30% highway usage. I understand that my usage does not ideally suit a diesel, but I am still interested due to the mileage and torque benefits. My main concern with diesel engines is DPF issues, given my low running. Do the Sierra or other Tata diesel cars face DPF issues with limited highway use? Are there any better alternatives that suit my requirements?

Autocar India

•1d

The Tata Sierra is an impressive product, and the praise is justified. It is spacious, has a standout design, rides well and feels like a genuinely fresh entrant in the segment. But if you are making a rational ownership decision, the Kia Seltos feels like the more complete and mature package right now. The diesel automatic is refined, has enough punch for effortless highway cruising and overtakes, is easy to live with and is very well suited to long-distance touring. The new Seltos also feels more polished in terms of fit and finish, overall refinement and long-term ownership confidence.The Sierra diesel automatic makes a stronger case if rear seat space and road presence are bigger priorities. But the diesel engine is not as refined as the Kia’s, and while Tata has made significant strides. Overall, ownership consistency still does not quite match Kia for a buyer looking for the safer all-around choice.

Tata Sierra

Kia Seltos

Autocar India

•1d

For your priorities, we would suggest the Renault Duster 1.3 turbo DCT. Coming from an Ignis AMT, this will feel like a massive upgrade in every meaningful way. The wet clutch DCT is a big advantage in Bangalore traffic because it is smoother and less prone to overheating than the dry clutch DCT setups used in rivals like the Seltos and Creta, while still delivering quick responses when you want to drive enthusiastically.More importantly, the Duster is genuinely enjoyable from behind the wheel. It feels involving to drive, has strong performance from the 1.3 turbo petrol and the ride quality is very absorbent and comfortable, which matters on Bangalore’s mixed road conditions. The one trade off is rear seat space, which is not as generous as some rivals in this segment.If rear seat space matters more, the new Tata Sierra 1.5 turbo petrol automatic is also worth considering. It is practical, spacious and still nice to drive, though it is not quite as driver focused as the Duster.If your absolute priority is playing it safe from an ownership familiarity perspective, the Kia Seltos turbo DCT is the safer mainstream pick.

Renault Duster

Tata Sierra

Hyundai Creta

Maruti Suzuki Ignis

Kia Seltos

Autocar India

•2d

The Tata Sierra deserves the praise because it does a lot right. It is spacious, practical, has a strong road presence, and from a pure packaging point of view, it is an impressive product. But if your concern is long-term ownership confidence, consistency in quality and overall longevity, the Kia Seltos is the safer bet.The Seltos simply feels more polished and more mature as a product. Interior quality is better, the CVT automatic is smooth and stress-free in daily use, and Kia’s ownership experience and long-term consistency inspire more confidence than Tata currently does. That does not mean the Sierra is a bad car, but if you are the kind of buyer who notices panel fit, switch quality and overall finish, the Kia will likely keep you happier over time.The Sierra’s advantages are space and the fact that it feels like the newer, more interesting product. But if this is a rational long-term purchase and not an emotional one, we would pick the Seltos CVT.

Tata Sierra

Kia Seltos