Autocar India
AS

Anirudha Sen

19w

I own a Honda Activa 5G that is five years old and has covered approximately 24,000 km. The scooter is serviced every three months, with an average maintenance cost of around ₹3,000 per service. My daily commute is roughly 40 km, primarily in city traffic. Over the past year, I have started experiencing several issues that are impacting ride comfort, confidence, and safety. The suspension feels overly stiff, and since the Activa 5G does not feature a telescopic front suspension, even small road imperfections and potholes are felt sharply. Although the rear tyre was replaced at around 23,000 km at a cost of approximately ₹1,500, cornering confidence - especially on wet roads - continues to feel inadequate. Additionally, noticeable vibrations through the footboard and handlebars beyond 40 km/h raise concerns about long-term comfort and potential mechanical wear. Given these concerns, I am evaluating whether it makes more sense to continue using the Activa 5G despite its limitations, upgrade to another scooter such as the Honda Activa 125 or alternatives from other brands for better ride quality and stability, or transition to a motorcycle like the Honda SP160 or Honda Unicorn, even though I have no prior experience with geared motorcycles. I am seeking expert guidance on which option would be the most practical and financially sensible choice for my usage pattern over the medium to long term.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
17w

Given your usage pattern, the fact that you are used to a scooter and don't have experience riding a geared motorcycle, we would recommend you stick to one. Since you are familiar with the Honda dealer and after-sales network, upgrading to the Honda Activa 125 would make sense. It will offer you better performance, ride and handling and more features over your older Activa 5G. 

You should also take a look at other proven options like the TVS Jupiter models and the Suzuki Access if you're considering the Activa. The Jupiter, in particular, has a few segment-first features and makes for a genuinely compelling alternative. 

A test ride will help you figure out which is the better option for you. 

 

Honda Activa 125

Honda Activa 125

More questions on similar bikes

KJ

Kaustubh Jirapure

2d

I own a Hunter 350 Dapper White for over two years. Lately, the suspension has started to bother me, and I am considering upgrading to an adventure bike. Which model would you recommend within a budget of Rs. 7 lakh? If there is an upcoming motorcycle that is worth waiting for, I am also considering upgrading the suspension on my Hunter 350 in the meantime. I was particularly interested in the Honda NX500, but the latest version seems significantly more expensive. What would you suggest?

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
1d

Since you're innately familiar with Royal Enfield ownership, upgrading to the Himalayan 450 seems like a safe bet. The Himalayan's suspension can iron out pretty much any road imperfection you encounter and its performance will be a big step up over the Hunter you own too. The only caveat with going for the Himalayan is that it is a tall and heavy bike, and these attributes will make their presence felt at slower speeds inside the city. If you want slightly higher performance levels on a lighter machine, then the KTM 390 Adventure models (whether you opt for 350cc or 399cc iterations is up to the budget you have) are worth considering. The KTM bikes have great handling, punchy top-end performance and come with features like adjustable suspension, traction control and a bidirectional quick shifter - depending on the variant. In your Rs. 7 lakh budget, you can also get the BMW F 450 GS, although depending on your city's taxation structure, you may need to stretch your budget a little if you are eyeing the top Trophy variant. The new entry-level GS is a competent machine and will be a step up in refinement from the single-cylinder machines mentioned above and it is also lighter than them. You will, however, need to be prepared for higher running and maintenance costs expected of a machine wearing the BMW badge. Take test rides of these machines to decide which one works best for you before you make your next purchase. If none of these options seem enticing, you could also retrofit the latest-gen Hunter's suspension to your older model which will bring some much needed relief in terms of ride quality. Do bear in mind that this swap will likely void your warranty and we'd recommend reaching out to your nearest dealership for more clarity on the same.

KTM 390 Adventure
Royal Enfield Himalayan
Royal Enfield Hunter 350
BMW Bikes F 450 GS

Popular discussions right now

Posted on: 9 Feb 2026