autocar-logo
Delhi
JI

Jitender

2d

Hi, I am currently driving a Toyota Fortuner 4x2 AT, and my daily driving is approximately 100km in the city. I want to upgrade to a new car, with a maximum net budget of ₹50 lakh after exchanging my existing car. I am open to both sedan and SUV options. Kindly suggest a suitable option.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
1h

A 100km daily city run is quite substantial, and the big, heavy Toyota Fortuner 4x2 AT isn’t really the most convenient or efficient car for that kind of usage. However, since you are used to the toughness and reliability of the Fortuner, a logical upgrade would be to stay within the Toyota family.The Toyota Innova HyCross in its strong-hybrid guise is a very sensible option. It offers excellent fuel efficiency, which will really help, given your high daily running. At the same time, it retains typical Toyota traits, like a tough build and strong long-term reliability. Compared to the Fortuner, the HyCross has a more practical and spacious cabin, and the top-spec version, which comfortably fits within your Rs 50 lakh net budget, even gets Ottoman recliners in the middle row, adding a real touch of comfort.If you’d like to explore an SUV outside Toyota, the Skoda Kodiaq is worth considering. It’s a full-size seven-seater with a stronger focus on comfort and luxury, offering a more urbane and premium feel compared to the hardy Toyotas. The Volkswagen Tayron is essentially the same car underneath, with a slightly different interior treatment and character. Both the Kodiaq and Tayron are better suited to urban driving in terms of refinement and comfort, but the Toyota would still edge ahead in terms of efficiency and long-term peace of mind.You could also consider the Toyota Camry, which would actually be our pick. Sedans inherently offer better ride comfort and handling balance for city use, and the Camry is spacious, extremely comfortable and easy to get in and out of. For your kind of daily driving, it would feel far more relaxed and effortless while still giving you the Toyota reliability you’re accustomed to.

VehicleToyota Camry
VehicleToyota Innova HyCross
VehicleToyota Fortuner
VehicleSkoda Kodiaq
VehicleVolkswagen Tayron
SR

Shobhit rastogi

2w

I have a 2016 Maruti Brezza manual ZDI+ diesel. I am really happy with the car, but I need to upgrade, as Delhi has a 10-year limitation on diesel cars. I have a budget of ₹30 lakh. We are a family of five (including a 4-year-old child), with mostly city usage. I am looking for a good driving experience, comfort, and value for money. I am open to electric cars and have test-driven the Mahindra XEV 9S, yet to try the 9E. I have read a lot about the soft suspension on the 9S and could feel the vertical movement. However, the Pack Three variant of the 9S has more features compared to the 9E, such as electric seat adjustment for co-passengers, seven seats, rear ventilated seats, and is cheaper by a couple of lakhs. I am confused, as I do not want to spend ₹30 lakh and regret it later. My mother did not like the Harrier EV, so that is out of consideration. My running is around 500km a month.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
14h

The Mahindra XEV 9S is, in many ways, is a clean and logical upgrade from your Maruti Suzuki Brezza diesel. For a family of five, the flexibility of three-row seating is genuinely useful, even if you don’t use the third row daily.As you rightly pointed out, the Pack Three variant of the Mahindra XEV 9S is very well equipped and, in fact, offers more features than the 9E Pack Three, like the co-passenger electric seat adjustment, rear ventilated seats and the added practicality of seven seats. Given that it’s also a couple of lakhs cheaper than the comparable Mahindra XEV 9e variant, from a pure value perspective, the 9S Pack Three does look more compelling.On the suspension, yes, the 9S is tuned on the softer side, but it's not a deal-breaker. You do feel a bit of vertical movement, especially at highway speeds over undulations, and that’s probably what you sensed during the test drive. However, in daily city use (which is the bulk of your 500), a softer setup at low speeds can actually work in your favour, better absorbing potholes and broken patches.Importantly, Mahindra has responded to feedback by introducing a ‘Custom’ drive mode, which lets you choose a sportier or stiffer suspension setting while keeping steering and power delivery in Comfort. That flexibility helps tailor the car to your preference.Since your usage is just around 500 km a month and mostly in the city, an electric car makes strong sense. Just ensure you have convenient home charging, that’s key to a stress-free EV ownership experience.

VehicleMahindra XEV 9S
VehicleMahindra XEV 9e
VehicleMaruti Suzuki Brezza