Tata Sierra vs Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

Autocar India
Tata Sierra

Tata Sierra

Accomplished+ Diesel AT

21.29 lakh

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

1.5 petrol ZXi+ AT

13.04 lakh

Engine & Transmission

Engine Type

Turbocharged
N/A

Engine Displacement

1497 cc
1462 cc

Number of Cylinders

4
4

Engine Installation

Front
Front

Fuel Type/ Propulsion

Diesel
Petrol

Pure Electric Driving Mode

Gearbox Type

Torque Converter
Torque Converter

Number of Gears

6
6

Manual Shifts via Gear Lever on Automatic Gearbox

Paddle Shifters for Automatic Gearbox

Sport Mode for Automatic Gearbox

Drive Layout

Front Wheel Drive
Front Wheel Drive

Lockable Differential/s

Max Engine Power

118 hp at 4000 rpm
103hp at 6000rpm

Max Engine Torque

260 Nm at 1500 - 2750 rpm
136.8Nm at 4400rpm

Fuel & Performance

Fuel Supply System

Common Rail
–

Emission Standard

Bharat Stage VI
Bharat Stage VI

Terrain Modes

–

Auto Start/Stop

Official Fuel Economy

19.22 kmpl
20.3 kmpl

Autocar Tested City Mileage

11.53 kmpl
–

Autocar Tested Highway Mileage

14.56 kmpl
–

Fuel Tank Capacity

50 litres
45 litres

Autocar Tested Mileage

13.05 kmpl
–

0-100kph

13.37 s
–

20-80kph (in third gear/ kickdown)

7.97 s
–

40-100kph (in fourth gear/ kickdown)

9.42 s
–

E20 Compatibility

–

CNG/LPG Tank Capacity

–
60 Kg

User Reported Mileage

–
17.66 kmpl

Suspension & Steering

Front Suspension Type

Independent, MacPherson Strut
Independent, MacPherson Strut

Front Springs

Coil Springs
Coil Springs

Rear Suspension Type

Non-independent, Torsion Beam
Non-independent, Torsion Beam

Rear Springs

Coil Springs
Coil Springs

Damper Control

Ride Height Adjust

Type of Power Assist

Electric
Electric

Steering Adjust type

Manual
Manual

Steering Adjust

Tilt and Telescopic
Tilt

Front Brakes

Disc
Discs

Rear Brakes

Disc
Drums

Wheel Size

19 inches
15 inches

Front Tyre Size

225/55 R19
185/65 R15

Rear Tyre Size

225/55 R19
185/65 R15

Wheels

Machine finished alloys
Alloys

Spare Wheel

Space Saver
Space Saver

4 Wheel Steer

–

Turning Radius

–
5.2 m

Dimensions

Length

4340 mm
4395 mm

Width

1841 mm
1735 mm

Height

1715 mm
1690 mm

Wheelbase

2730 mm
2740 mm

Ground Clearance

205 mm
–

Chassis Type

Monocoque
–

Boot Capacity

622-1257 litres
–

Doors

5
5

Kerb Weight

–
1150 - 1205 kg

Comfort

Dead Pedal

Keyless Entry

Cabin Boot Access

Rear Window Sun Shades

Interior Lamps

Third Row AC Vents

Climate Control

2-zone
1-zone

Comfort Headrest

–

Cooled Glovebox

Acoustic Windshield

–

Sunroof

Panoramic

Cruise Control

Yes (Adaptive)

Cup Holders

Sunglass Holder

Remote Locking

Roof Grab Handles

–

Rear Windscreen Sun Shade

Digital Instrument Cluster

Fully Digital
Part Digital / Part Analogue

Steering Mounted Controls

Audio and Phone
Audio and Phone

Door Pockets

Headlight and Ignition on Reminder

Driver Armrest Storage

Driver rear view monitor (DRVM)

–

Hands-free Boot Opening

Driving Modes

Front Seatback Pockets

Electric Tailgate Release

Front Passenger Seat Adjust from Rear

Exterior Mirrors Electric Adjust

Exterior Mirrors Electric Fold

Yes with power folding

Foldable Seatback Table

–

Launch Control

Power Windows with One Touch-Down

Driver Window Only
Driver Window Only

Utility Recess On Dashboard

–

Vanity Mirror

Front Passenger Only with Light
Front Passenger Only

Auto Parking

Ambient Lighting

Rear AC Vents

Push Button Start

Bluetooth Connectivity

Power Windows with One Touch-Up

Driver Window Only
Driver Window Only

Powered Tailgate

Yes (Gesture Control)

Voice Assisted Sunroof

Trunk Light

Power Windows

Front and Rear
Front and Rear

Rear Power Outlet

Bottle Holder in Doors

Rear Parcel Tray

–

Safety

Hill Start Assist

Tyre Pressure Monitoring System

With Display
With Display

Side Airbag

Speed Assist System

–

Seat Belt Warning

Speed-Sensing Auto Door Locks

Speed Sensing Door Lock

Video Recording

–

Rear Cross Traffic Alert

–

Rear Cross Traffic Collision Avoidance

–

Rear Washer/Wiper

Rear Defogger

Traction Control

Traffic Sign Recognition

–

Central Locking

Electronic Stability Control

Electronic Parking Brake

Yes with Autohold

Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD)

Dual Tone Horn

–

Driver Airbag

Door Ajar Warning

Day/Night Interior Mirror

Auto-dimming
Manual

Day Night Interior Mirror

Automatic
Manual

Dashcam

Curtain Airbag

BNCAP Rating

5
–

Clutch Lock

–

Child Safety Lock

Passenger Airbag

Brake Fade Support

–

Brake Disc Wiping

–

Brake Assist (BA)

Boot Open Warning

–

Blind Spot Monitor

Blind Spot Collision Avoidance Assist

–

Automatic Wipers

Automatic Headlamps

Anti Theft Alarm

–

Anti-Pinch Power Windows

Driver's Window Only
–

Anti-Lock Brakes (ABS)

Airbags

6
6

Adaptive Cruise Control

Front Collision Avoidance

Pretensioners & Force Limiter Seatbelts

–

Parking Sensors

Front & Rear
Rear

Parking Camera

360 degree
Rear

Overspeed Warning

Lane Keep Assist

–

Lane Departure Avoidance

ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts

Hill Descent Control

High Beam Assist

Height Adjustable Seat Belt

Heads Up Display

–

Emergency Brake Light Flashing

Crash Test Rating

–
3

NCAP Rating

–
3

Exterior

Sequential Turn Indicators

–

Scuff Plates

Front Fog Lamps

Puddle Lamps

Pop-Out Door Handle

Manual
–

Headlight Height Adjuster

ORVM turn indicators

Headlight Type

LED
Halogen

Rub Strips

Roof Rails

–

Outside rear view mirror (ORVM)

LED taillights

LED headlamps

Illuminated Logo

–

LED fog lamps

Projector Headlamps

LED DRLs

–

Integrated Washer Jets with Wiper

–

Follow Me Home Headlamps

Body Coloured Bumpers

Charging Indicator On Light Bar

–

Connected LED

–

Cornering Headlights

Stop Lamp

–

Daytime Running Lights

LED

Door Handle Finish

Body Coloured
–

Spoiler

Antenna

Shark Fin

Welcome and Goodbye Animation

–

Interior

Average Fuel Consumption

Low Fuel Level Warning

Average Speed

Shift Indicator

Trip Meter

Instantaneous Consumption

Tachometer

Digital
Analog

Distance to Empty

Head-up Display

Speedometer

Digital
Analog

Gear Indicator

Rear Seat Armrest

Yes with Holders

Adjustable Front Headrests

Adjustable Rear Headrests

Front Passenger Seat Height Adjust

Second Row Seat Adjustment

Electric Adjust for Front Passenger's Seat

Massage Seats

Ventilated Seats

Front Only

Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel

Leather-wrapped Gear Knob

Electric Adjust for Driver's Seat

Front Seat Armrest

Rear Seat Backrest Fold

Rear Seat Backrest Recline

Rear Seat Backrest Split

60:40

Seat Material

Leatherette
Fabric

Driver's Seat Memory

Third Row Seats

Individual Chairs at Rear

Driver's Seat Height Adjust

Seat Count

5
7

Front Passenger Seat Memory

Heated Seats

Third Row Seats Fold

–

Third Row Seats Split

–
50:50

Entertainment

Inbuilt Music App

–

Bluetooth Audio Streaming

Bluetooth Telephone Function

Rear Entertainment Screens

USB Input

MirrorLink

–

Branded Music System

JBL

CD Player

Touchpad

Wireless Phone Charging

AUX Input

Front Passenger Screen

–

Speakers

8
6

Steering Phone Controls

Web Browser

Display

12.3-inch Touchscreen
7-inch Touchscreen

Satellite Navigation

In-built
Phone-based

Audio System

Voice Commands

Steering Audio Controls

Apple CarPlay

Wireless
Wireless

Android Auto

Wireless
Wireless

Gesture Controls

Video Player

Connected Car Features

Phone App

–

Alexa Compatibility

Digital Key

–

Geo Fence

Smart Drive Information

–

Summon Mode

–

Navigation On Instrument Cluster

–

Low Battery Warning

–

Live Location Sharing

–

Service Reminder Via App

–

Emergency Call Button

Find My Car

Check Vehicle Status via App

Over the air (OTA) updates

–

Remote AC On / Off via App

–

Remote Car Lock/Unlock via App

–

Remote Sunroof Open / Close via App

–

Car Light Flashing & Honking via App

–

Questions you may find useful

•15w

I’m Kathir from Chennai. I have been following Autocar for many years, and it has always been interesting and useful, with clear explanations. I often recommend Autocar to others for reliable information, so thanks to the entire team! I currently drive a 2008 i10 1.2 Magna, and my wife drives a 2016 Grand i10 Asta automatic, which has now covered 92,000 km. We are planning to sell this car and buy a new automatic petrol car within a ₹20 lakh on-road budget. Earlier, choosing a car was easier, but now it feels more confusing. We like Hyundai cars but now, we are open to trying other brands. We have test-driven the Ertiga AT, Victoris AT, Creta AT, and Carens AT, and are also planning to test Volkswagen and Skoda models. I like the Sierra, Duster, and XUV 7XO, but I am not fully confident about buying them. I am also unsure whether to buy a new car or consider a used one. Please suggest both a new car option and advice on buying a used car.

Verified
•15w

You are upgrading from a Grand i10 automatic and want something that is easy to drive, comfortable for family use and reliable for long-term ownership. The Creta ticks all those boxes. The IVT automatic is smooth and effortless in city driving, the ride is soft and comfortable which your family will appreciate, and Hyundai’s aftersales experience is something you are already familiar with. This Hyundai car also feels like a proper step up in space, comfort and overall refinement without being intimidating to drive.The Grand Vitara automatic is a good alternative if fuel efficiency is a priority. It is smooth and easy to drive, but the engine feels less responsive and overall it does not feel as premium or as refined as the Creta. The Ertiga and Carens Clavis are practical, but they are more MPV-focused and since you do not specifically need a third row, they are not the best fit.Cars like the Sierra, Duster and XUV 7XO are interesting, but your hesitation is valid. They are either new or evolving products, and compared to the Creta, they do not offer the same level of proven reliability and ownership peace of mind yet.

VehicleMaruti Suzuki Grand Vitara
VehicleMahindra XUV 7XO
VehicleRenault Duster
VehicleTata Sierra