Opinion: How much protectionism is too much?

    The hue and cry over nationalism could be a step back in time for the industry, writes Sergius.

    Published On Apr 10, 2022 09:00:00 AM

    4,575 Views

    Autocar India Awards, Tata Punch crash test

    Liberalisation truly developed our Indian auto industry.

    Listen to this Article

    “From building licensed products to joint ventures, to designing and building our own products and to exporting them across the world, this is the story of the Indian automotive industry.” That was Venu Srinivasan, TVS Motor Co chairman, accepting the Person of the Year award at the 2022 Autocar India Awards.

    Srinivasan went on to say he was fortunate to have seen this transformation in his lifetime. But, amazingly, it took place over just his working career. That got me thinking, how did we achieve this transformation?

    In a word, ‘liberalisation’. Until then, the Indian auto industry was protected and we know the landscape that ensued, same cars for decades, outdated tech, poor quality and high costs. But that changed when we had to compete with the world.

    Mahindra Group chairman Anand Mahindra – also speaking at the awards – echoed this sharing an anecdote of when a consultant firm said they’d be wise to stick with tractors, reasoning Mahindra had no scale, no quality, never made a hard top car and would thus simply die in a liberalised market. Mahindra quipped he’s happy he wasn’t wise then. Indeed, competing in a liberalised market is what made our domestic automakers shine; look at the likes of Mahindra, Tata, TVS and Bajaj.

    Of late though, the brouhaha over nationalism seems to be hijacking business common sense. How much protection is too much? Recently, we implemented a blanket ban on imported drones. Reason? We need to develop our domestic drone makers. But as history has repeatedly shown, protectionism does not spur development.

    Yes, the ban is also because most drones are Chinese. But our ambitious EV race needs us to develop battery tech overnight. And the battery development leaders – yes, development, not just manufacturing – are the Chinese. We’ll invariably have to invite them in, in some manner or the other. In any case, they’re already here; look under the skin of any ‘made-in-India’ EVs. Look at the mega future battery plans too that Indian OEMs have. The common ingredient, China.

    Then there’s Tesla who we are keeping out because they won’t make cars here. Is that the best reaction? We really need to figure out just how much protectionism is too much. It’s a delicate tight rope, but one that we certainly can walk. As I said in a past column, if we want a truly global auto industry, beyond self-reliant cars, what we’ll need is world class ones. And so, as history and the industry says, opening up and competing with the world is the only way to achieve this.

    Copyright (c) Autocar India. All rights reserved.

    Comments
    ×
    img

    No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

    Ask Autocar Anything about Car and Bike Buying and Maintenance Advices
    Need an expert opinion on your car and bike related queries?
    Ask Now
    Search By Car Price
    Poll of the month

    The Honda City Hybrid costs Rs 19.50 lakh. Would you:

    Buy it for its superior tech and fuel economy

     

    24.41%

    Buy a regular (and cheaper) petrol/diesel City

     

    32.07%

    Buy a high-performance turbo-petrol sedan

     

    14.47%

    Buy a pure Electric Vehicle with zero emissions

     

    29.04%

    Total Votes : 1057
    Sign up for our newsletter

    Get all the latest updates from the automobile universe