I currently drive a Land Rover Defender, which I absolutely love for its design and capability. That said, I’m starting to think about SUVs that offer a bit more performance and sporty driving dynamics. I’ve briefly considered the Porsche Cayenne, but I’m curious if there are other options that balance power, handling, and everyday usability. For someone coming from a Defender, what would you recommend?

Autocar India

•2h

The Tata Sierra is a large and capable SUV, and for your work, would give loads of space for camera gear and garment boxes alike, but in your budget of Rs 15-16 lakh, you will only get the base model. Moreover, the downside of it being a large and heavy vehicle is that the mileage is not great compared to rivals, whether comparing the petrol or diesel versions. However, should you go with the Sierra and want to get the maximum mileage, the diesel is probably the best way to go, and if possible, we would recommend stretching the budget by at least Rs 1-1.5 lakh to get a few more features.Consider the Kia Seltos instead - it too has a large and spacious cabin, almost as big as that of the Sierra, and good boot space as well. However, its engines, comparable to what you get in the Sierra, offer better real-world mileage. And, as safety is another concern, the Seltos has scored a 5-star Bharat NCAP crash test rating, just like the Sierra. What's more, you can get mid-spec variants, at least with the petrol engines, in your budget of Rs. 15-16 lakh, so you don't necessarily have to increase it so much. If you want even more space, and don't mind picking an MPV over an SUV, the Kia Carens Clavis is a far more practical option.

Tata Sierra

Kia Seltos

Kia Carens Clavis

Autocar India

•4h

Pick the Kia Carens Clavis petrol automatic for your use case. You sometimes need six or seven seats, and your running is low, so a petrol automatic with a roomy 3-row cabin makes far more sense than a 5-seat SUV.The Carens Clavis gives you proper family flexibility: five can ride in comfort, and when one or two more join, you have a usable third row for short trips. With the third row folded, the boot is big enough for plenty of luggage. The ride is comfy, it comes feature-loaded and getting in and out is easy for elders. Go for the 1.5 petrol with the automatic in a mid trim to stay near your Rs. 20 lakh cap.

Kia Carens Clavis

Autocar India

•4h

Get the Kia Carens Clavis diesel automatic. It fits your family size, is easy for a senior to get in and out of, and stays well under Rs. 25 lakh. For your 50 km daily city run, the diesel engine is refined, the torque converter automatic is smooth, and it is very easy to drive. On your monthly highway trips, it cruises calmly, feels secure at speed, and you get a genuinely usable third row and decent boot space. The Carens Clavis can be had as a 7-seater or a 6-seater, with individual captain's chairs in the middle.Cabin comfort is a strong point. The second row is spacious, the ride is comfortable enough over bad roads, and the panoramic roof in the higher variants makes the cabin feel airy. It is also a bit smaller outside than the big SUVs, so parking and driving in traffic is less stressful.One catch is that with all three rows up, the boot is tight, so you'll have to plan your way around it.

Kia Carens Clavis