Hi, We want to buy a new SUV. We have selected some of the options between Siera and Creta. Our budget is between 16 and 16.50 lakhs. Firstly, we are going for the Sierra Pure Plus because it is new, but later we found out that its engine is the worst in this segment. So, we decided to go for the diesel variant of Sierra Pure, comprising the sunroof and also my dad wants a new design, actually Sierra's design. So what should we do, go for the Creta or the Sierra diesel? In Creta, we got almost all features. Our mostly drive is in highway, we take trips every four months, long trips like 1000km.

Autocar India

•1d

Our first recommendation would be the Kia Seltos 1.5 petrol automatic. With 70% highway driving, you will appreciate its comprehensive ADAS suite with adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assistance. It also has a 5-star Bharat NCAP safety rating, a wide service network, and you’ll get the full spread of modern features inside your budget. The honest catch is that the automatic is tuned for calm progress, not thrills. The honest catch is that the automatic is tuned for calm progress, not thrills.The Hyundai Creta 1.5 petrol automatic lands very close. It matches the features and ADAS you want, rides a touch softer for family comfort, and Hyundai’s service reach is the strongest. Highway economy is similar to the Seltos, and it is E20-ready.The Honda Elevate is a strong choice, too, giving you ADAS and a very easy drive. It also offers slightly quicker performance than the above two. It stays within your price range and is proven on long runs.All three are E20-compliant. No mainstream brand here officially guarantees E30 yet, so that is the one future-proofing gap today.

Kia Seltos

Hyundai Creta

Honda Elevate

Autocar India

•2d

Pick a diesel SUV for now, because your 1000 km highway runs will be far less stressful. Owning a diesel means 5 minute refuels almost anywhere, no hunting for chargers or waiting for the battery to be topped up. With today’s patchy fast-charging in tier 3-4 towns, an EV road trip still needs careful planning, backup options, and usually 2-3 long stops. Your 40 km daily run does suit an EV, but only if you have reliable home charging and if those long trips are rare.For diesel, a Hyundai Creta or Kia Seltos is the easy, efficient, and comfortable choice. If you want lower city running cost without charging worries, pick a strong-hybrid like the Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder or Maruti Suzuki Victoris instead.

Kia Seltos

Hyundai Creta

Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

Autocar India

•3h

In your case, we would actually stick with the diesel. The reason is that this is not going to be your primary city car. You have clearly stated that it will be used mainly for highway travel, occasional family trips and as a second vehicle. Those are exactly the conditions under which a modern diesel is happiest. With regular highway runs, the DPF gets the opportunity to regenerate properly, so we would not be overly concerned about DPF issues.The bigger factor is your planned two-year ownership period. In the used market, the diesel XUV 7XO is likely to be more desirable and easier to sell than the petrol, especially because buyers looking at a large SUV often prefer the stronger torque delivery and superior fuel efficiency of the diesel. That should help residual values as well.If you were doing 5,000 km a year entirely in city traffic, we would steer you towards the petrol. But your usage pattern is different. The car will spend most of its time doing exactly the kind of driving that suits the diesel powertrain.

Mahindra XUV 7XO