I am planning to buy a new SUV. My daily commute is around 50km in Mumbai city with occasional intercity trips on the highway. Should I go with a diesel or a petrol engine? I have shortlisted the Mahindra XUV 7XO 7L Automatic Diesel. Which is the other option in a similar range?

autocar.india

•18h

Consider the Kia Seltos DCT. For a 12km commute and occasional 5-6-hour road trips, you will find it comfortable in the city, quick on the highway and easy to own long term. The latest-generation Seltos is larger than before, so feels spacious inside. The cabin is tech-laden and upmarket, and the ride quality has improved too. The turbo-petrol DCT has good performance for quick overtakes on the highway, and the DCT is responsive. The downside is that it can occasionally hesitate in the city, but with your short commute this shouldn't be a deal-breaker. Kia's service is also amongst the best in the business.If you want something larger, the Mahindra XUV 7XO petrol automatic is also a solid choice in your budget. It is a genuinely comfortable car with a spacious cabin, excellent ride quality and strong highway manners. The petrol engine is smooth and refined, and the automatic gearbox makes city driving effortless. Mahindra's service network is strong in Thane and Mumbai. The drawback is that the big petrol engine will be thirsty in the city.An electric car makes sense if you can charge at home and if there are fast chargers on your usual highway route. In that case, the Hyundai Creta Electric is a safe bet. It is well suited to your short daily commute and offers very low running costs. In our real-world testing, it managed an impressive 486km on a single charge in the city and 378km on the highway.Overall, the Seltos is the best balance of comfort, reliability, running costs and ownership experience for your needs.

Kia Seltos

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Hyundai Creta Electric

autocar.india

•21h

Given your usage pattern of high daily running and frequent highway trips, the Honda Elevate has clearly done its job as a dependable and comfortable workhorse. That said, your need for a meaningful performance upgrade is understandable. The 1.5-litre naturally aspirated engine paired with the CVT is smooth and efficient, but it does start to feel underwhelming once you begin to prioritise performance and responsiveness.A logical step up on the ICE side would be the Mahindra XUV 7X0 petrol. Its 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine with 200hp delivers a strong jump in performance, and the 6-speed automatic is far more engaging than a CVT. Overtakes are effortless, and it brings a sense of urgency that the Elevate simply cannot match. The trade-offs, however, are worth noting. It is a larger car, so it won’t feel as nimble or easy to manoeuvre in tight urban conditions, and fuel efficiency can drop into the mid-single digits, especially with enthusiastic driving.If you are open to going electric, the upgrade in performance becomes even more pronounced. The Tata Sierra EV stands out as a compelling option. Like the Elevate, it sits in the mid-size SUV space but offers significantly more performance and space. With a 0 - 100kph time of under 6 seconds, it delivers instant torque and strong, seamless acceleration, which will feel like a dramatic leap, particularly in city driving and quick overtakes. It is also shaping up to be a well-rounded EV with a usable real-world range and a ride quality suited to long highway runs.In both cases, you are looking at a clear step up in performance, but the choice really comes down to whether you want the familiarity and refuelling ease of petrol, or the instant performance and lower running costs of an electric car.

Honda Elevate

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Tata Sierra EV

autocar.india

•1d

For a family of three with a five-month-old child, your priorities should be comfort, safety, space for a child seat and luggage, and a relaxed driving experience for both city and highway use. Your budget of Rs. 10-20 lakh gives you a wide range of options, but the key is to choose a car that will remain comfortable and practical as your child grows and your travel increases.The Mahindra XUV 3XO is a strong recommendation. It offers a spacious cabin, a wide rear seat that easily accommodates a child seat and an adult, and a comfortable ride that makes long drives less tiring. The Mahindra car is also well equipped and feels like a genuinely premium product for the price. The only drawback is the relatively small boot, which can be a limitation on longer trips with a lot of luggage.If boot space is a concern, the Tata Sierra is worth considering. It offers a larger boot and a more premium cabin, making it better suited to long trips with family and friends. The Mahindra XUV 7XO is also a good option if you want more space and a more powerful engine for highway cruising, but it is a larger car and may not be as easy to manoeuvre in the city.Overall, the XUV 3XO strikes the best balance between city usability, comfort and value, while the Sierra and XUV 7XO are better choices if space is your top priority.

Mahindra XUV 3XO

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Tata Sierra