I’m looking to upgrade to a new car. My monthly usage is around 1,000 km, mainly for city commuting as a college student. My budget is ₹10-15 lakh, and I’m considering the Mahindra Thar 4x2 or the new Hyundai Venue diesel.

Autocar India

•21h

For that requirement, the Toyota Fortuner is the safest bet. It feels built for bad roads, can be had with proper low-range four-wheel drive for steep, loose climbs and snow, and Toyota’s service reach is strong even in smaller hill towns. On highways, it sits steady at speed, the seats are supportive, and you can load it up with family and bags without worry. Coming from a Pajero, you will feel the same go-anywhere confidence but with a far more modern cabin and easier ownership.Two things to keep in mind. It is very expensive for what it is, and in slow, broken patches, the ride can feel firm. It is also a big SUV, so narrow village lanes and tight hotel parking will require patience.If you want most of that ability for a lot less money, look at the Mahindra Thar Roxx. It too can be had with low-range four-wheel drive, strong pull at low speed for hairpins, and Mahindra support is widespread in the North. You give up some highway polish, and it may not be as rock-solid reliable as a Toyota, but it is a serious mountain tool. Overall, the Fortuner fits your brief best; the Thar Roxx is the strong value alternative.

Toyota Fortuner

Mahindra Thar Roxx

Autocar India

•17m

Your running is mostly city with relatively low monthly kilometres, so petrol makes more sense than diesel. It is smoother, easier to live with and avoids the need to think about DPF or long-term diesel usage patterns.Now, within petrol, the choice depends on what you value more. The 1.5 NA petrol with IVT is the most suited for your use. It is smooth, very easy to drive in traffic and pairs well with the IVT gearbox, which is seamless in stop-go conditions. It may not feel very powerful on paper, but in real-world use, it is adequate for both city driving and occasional highway trips if you drive in a relaxed manner.The 1.5 turbo petrol with DCT is the more performance-oriented option. It feels quicker and more responsive, especially on highways and during overtakes. However, in city traffic, the DCT can feel slightly less smooth, and fuel efficiency will be lower. It suits someone who prioritises performance over ease.So the difference is clear. The IVT is about smoothness and comfort; the DCT is about performance.

Kia Seltos

Mahindra XUV 7XO

Autocar India

•52m

The core point is this: both cars are essentially the same under the skin. The Maruti Suzuki Invicto is based on the Toyota Innova Hycross, so engine, platform and driving experience are nearly identical. That means performance, comfort and mileage are not the deciding factors.Where the difference comes in is ownership. Toyota’s aftersales experience is still more consistent and predictable across cities. Service quality, long-term reliability and resale value are all areas where the Innova badge has a clear edge. Over a long ownership period, this matters more than a few extra features.The Invicto Alpha does offer slightly more features for the price and can feel like a better value on paper. But in real-world ownership, Toyota’s support and brand strength make the Hycross the safer and more reassuring option.

Maruti Suzuki Invicto

Toyota Innova HyCross